Check out the stunning visual story of death row prisoners’ last words.
—
In 2009, California-based photographer Amy Elkins began exchanging letters with several men on America’s death rows for what became an extensive project that looked at capital punishment and solitary confinement in the United States.
Three months after her correspondence began with an inmate in Texas, the man was put to death. On the day of his execution, Elkins, searching online for more information, landed on the Texas Department of Criminal Justice website, with the state’s executions archive in macabre detail.
Texas meted out more than one-third of all of U.S. executions in 2013 — 16 of 39 nationwide. These 16, along with every Texas execution since the death penalty was reinstated in 1976, are listed on a dedicated Web page maintained by the state Department of Criminal Justice. On the “Executed Offenders” page, members of the public can scroll through the names, ages, prison IDs, race, convictions and last statements of the doomed inmates, in chronological order.
At the time Elkins stumbled upon the website, it listed 440 men and women. Today, four years later, the site includes 509. The website had not yet been updated with the latest Texas execution on Wednesday.
The website launched Elkins into the project “Parting Words,” an ambitious visual archive of the more than 500 prisoners who have been executed in Texas. It’s a portrait series with a twist: The portraits are mug shots and the faces are made not of pixels or pigment, but of letters and phrases. Using the content provided by the state website, Elkins has layered mug shots with excerpts from each prisoner’s last words, repeated in the patterns you see below.
“I allowed my obsessive side to surface,” Elkins said. The result is a sinister, marching, op art-style grid. Individual portraits are powerful. But through hundreds of hours of work, Elkins brings us the terrifying truth of state-sanctioned killing inside our homeland. “Parting Words” stirs a critical contemporary debate, while it inhabits the unnerving historical matrix of photography, power and death.
Elkins’ approach is neutral, yet the inmates’ words are amplified. The goal is to allow the audience to reflect from the perspective of those who were condemned, and to spur debate about the death penalty in modern America. Texas is a reasonable focal point for the discussion. The state’s prolific execution machinery has carried out 509 of the 1,360 U.S. executions since 1976.
Attitudes are changing. The Death Penalty Information Center reported earlier this month that public support for the death penalty is at its lowest level in 40 years.
“Twenty years ago, use of the death penalty was increasing. Now it is declining by almost every measure,” Richard Dieter, executive director of the center and the author of the report, said in a recent press release. “The recurrent problems of the death penalty have made its application rare, isolated and often delayed for decades. More states will likely reconsider the wisdom of retaining this expensive and ineffectual practice.”
Trust in the accuracy of the criminal justice system has eroded, and with it confidence in the ability of governments to fairly apply the death penalty. In October, Reginald Griffin became the 143rd person in the U.S. to be exonerated and released from death row after his murder conviction was overturned.
As any intelligent artist does, Elkins appropriates and reframes knowledge, turning the logic of a flawed system against itself.
Karla Faye Tucker: Executed Feb. 3, 1998; Age 38
Elliot Johnson: Executed June 24, 1987; Age 38
Ignacio Cuevas: Executed May 23, 1991; Age 59
David Goff: Executed April 25, 2001; Age 31
Robert Black Jr: Executed May 22, 1992; Age 45
Samuel Hawkins: Executed Feb. 21, 1995; Age 52
Leonel Herrera: Executed May 12,1993; Age 45
Miguel Richardson: Executed June 26, 2001; Age 46
Richard Beavers: Executed April 4, 1994; Age 39
Edward Green: Executed Oct. 5, 2004; Age 30
Tommie Hughes: Executed March 15, 2006; Age 31
Javier Cruz: Executed Oct. 1, 1998; Age 41
Willie Shannon: Executed Nov. 8, 2006; Age 30
Robert Thompson: Executed Nov. 19, 2009; Age 34
Randall Hafdahl Sr: Executed Jan. 31, 2002; Age 48
Franklin Alix: Executed March 30, 2010; Age 34
Robert Coulson: Executed June 25, 2002; Age 34
Luis Salazar: Executed March 11, 2009; Age 38
Allen Janecka: Executed July 24, 2003; Age 53
Mathis Milton: Executed June 21, 2011; Age 32
Vincent Gutierrez: Executed March 28, 2007; Age 28
Edgar Tamayo: Executed Jan. 22, 2014; Age 46
***
Amy Elkins is a photographer, writer and co-founder and co-curator of the website Women In Photography. Her work has been exhibited and published nationally and internationally, including Kunsthalle Wien in Vienna, Austria; the Carnegie Art Museum in California; and the Minneapolis Institute of Arts in Minnesota.
Pete Brook is a freelance writer and curator with a focus on photography, prisons, social justice and visual culture. He writes and edits Prison Photography and is a regular contributor to Raw File, the Wired photography blog.
Like The Good Men Project on Facebook
–Originally appeared on The Huffington Post
I didn’t know Carla Faye Tucker was a fan of Mumford and Sons.
I found the pictures haunting and thought provoking. It’s all too easy to see them as a sum of their offenses or to feel righteous and alienated by the atrocities they dealt to their victims. We want to separate ourselves from them. We want to believe that they don’t know love like we do. That they didn’t experience life like we do, that there is something “sick” inside them that we are not capable of, that they are undeserving of forgiveness. This makes us feel “safe” in our separation from them. But at the end of the day, they are… Read more »
What I always note is that people see “perpetrator” and “victim” as absolute categories. They cannot grasp that a person can be guilty of some deed and at the same time victim of another. Say e.g. a person catches another picking his pockets and shoots him with his handgun. If the media say “the victim was taken to the hospital” 1000 online commentors will go “but that is wrong, he was not the victim, he was the criminal”. I think they really don’t get it.
Here’s a different “perspective”: Carla Faye Tucker – Murder with pickax. Ignacio Cuevas – Murder of hostage. David Goff – Murder of kidnap victim. Samuel Hawkins – Murder and rape of pregnant woman. Leonel Herrera – Murder of police officer. Miguel Richardson – Murder and robbery of security guard. Richard Beavers – Murder, attempted murder, kidnapping and rape of restaurant manager and wife. Edward Green – Murder and attempted robbery of couple. Tommie Hughes – Murder and attempted robbery. Javier Cruz – Murder of two elderly men. Willie Shannon – Murder and rape. Robert Thompson – Murder and robbery of… Read more »
How is that a “different perspective?” That eye-for-an-eye perspective is as old as time immemorial. At least this art makes people think. Your “different perspective” does not.
ALL perspectives can make people think.
I systematically against the death penalty even when guilt is not at issue. Unfortunately in far too many cases it seems race, and guilt, are in question. I see this as a way to bring the question of whether killing even our worst criminals makes sense under any circumstances. Death for death is not something I see as part of being a civilized country in the 21st century. But then neither does putting 2 million men in prison, over half men of color and many for non-violent drug charges.
Immortalizing these killers with their last words in “art” seems so wrong. What about tattooing the last words of the innocent people they killed on their face? The words of the dads, mothers, children they took away from their loved ones forever. This artist is sick in the head.
Their words are immortalized in more detail as part of the public record already, so I don’t think this really changes anything in that regard. But you do raise an interesting point, where this addresses only the humanity of the criminals rather than the inhumanity they chose to display in their actions. It would be interesting to see if the artist came up with a way to show that juxtaposition. Personally, for those quotes that speak so boldly of the importance of love, I would like to see how that mindset compares to the one these individuals had when they… Read more »
If our justice system has, without perfect certainty of guilt, taken the lives of those accused (of terrible crimes, true), perhaps the least we can do is give life to their last words. The words “I am innocent” are, to me, particularly haunting; they represent either the last hopeless protests of those wrongly accused or the last lie ever to pass the lips of killers. The point of this art is to provoke thought, which it certainly did. I think the death penalty is a mistake even in the most horrid cases; death is an escape from the reality killers… Read more »