—
In which Hank and John Green teach you about humanity conquering the Earth. Or at least moving from Africa into the rest of the Earth. As human beings spread out across the world and populations grew, humanity reached a critical mass of innovators, and collective learning took off! All these innovations were great for lots of human endeavors, but none fared better than agriculture.
—
—
Transcript Provided by YouTube:
00:00
Hi, I’m John Green, welcome to Crash Course Big History. Today, we’re gonna be talking
00:03
about the spread of human foragers across the world and the start of the agrarian era.
00:09
Mr. Green, Mr. Green! Didn’t we study all that agrarian stuff in World History, because
00:12
I’m a very busy person, I don’t wanna do it again.
00:15
Yeah, a couple things, Me From the Past, first off, playing Zelda alone in your basement
00:18
does not constitute being busy. Also, in Crash Course World History, we zoomed through a
00:23
lot of this stuff, because we wanted to get to, like, the real history-ish parts of history,
00:27
you know, the parts with the funny hats and the Mongols. [Mongoltage]
00:32
But if it weren’t for agriculture and the surpluses that came with it, we never would
00:35
have had funny hats. That’s why we study Big History.
00:39
[Theme Music]
00:47
So as mentioned last week, humans anatomically similar to us have been around for about 200
00:53
or 250 thousand years. Like, here’s a picture of one of the oldest known fossil remains
00:57
of our species from Ethiopia, dated to approximately 195,000 years ago. For the vast, vast majority
01:04
of our existence, homo sapiens were hunter-gatherers, like farming, civilization, modernity, all
01:10
of that happened in the last 10-15,000 years. And you’ll remember that the eruption of Mount
01:16
Toba about 74,000 years ago reduced the human population to a few thousand, and that scrappy
01:22
group of survivors held on, and for the next 60,000 years, human populations migrated over
01:28
the world, separating into their own little petri dishes. And that was interesting, because
01:33
the human experiment could proceed in isolation in several different zones in the world: the
01:38
Afro-Eurasian, the Americas, Australasia, and the Pacific. And this was really useful,
01:42
because it allowed each of those world zones to develop their own distinct brand of football,
01:47
which makes for such a beautiful game today, apparently there was no football back then.
01:51
Really? What did they do all day?
01:53
Apparently they were hunting and gathering.
01:55
Okay, so by 11,000 years ago, the human population had recovered from the Mount Toba disaster
02:00
and grown to about 6 to 8 million people. Now, because foraging requires humans to constantly
02:06
move on to new ecosystems to find food while the old ones regrow and replenish themselves,
02:11
6 to 8 million is about the largest population of foragers that the entire surface of the earth could support.
02:17
Now you may remember in the very first episode of Crash Course World History we talked about
02:20
the mystery of why humans developed agriculture even though foraging is easier. One theory
02:25
involves so-called Gardens of Eden, where the warming climate of the earth created some
02:30
lush ecosystems with enough food for foragers to quit migrating and settle down for several generations.
02:36
The Natufians of what later became the Fertile Crescent in the middle east hunted
02:40
gazelles and fished and harvested wild grains, but they weren’t really farmers. But then
02:45
after a few generations of vigorous population growth, food started to grow scarce in these
02:49
Gardens of Eden. Given their new relatively sedentary lifestyle, those humans may have forgotten
02:54
how to forage effectively. Also, surrounding areas may have been already overpopulated
02:59
with other foragers. So humans had to choose between starving to death and getting more
03:03
out of the land that they were currently on — a choice that historically we make by trying not to die.
03:08
These humans already had a deep knowledge of plants and animals, and if you’ve got
03:11
organisms nearby that might be useful to domesticate like wheat or goats or wild pigs – bingo, agriculture!
03:18
Now of course there are also many other theories about why agriculture emerged around the world
03:22
but regardless, agriculture represents a massive shift in human activity. Hunter-gatherers
03:27
adapted themselves to the resources provided by the environment, right? But agriculturalists
03:33
increasingly adapted the environment to suit their needs. Forcing the environment to adapt to humans
03:39
became an increasingly big deal until, you know, like today when it is arguably the biggest deal of all.
03:46
Now, all that being said, the advent of agriculture didn’t, like, immediately lead to wars and
03:51
cities and kings and funny hats. In fact another 5000 years would pass before the first states
03:57
emerged. So for the first half of the agrarian era, humans lived in a world of villages with
04:01
transient herders and foragers in the gaps between.
04:05
Giving up foraging and settling down did have some downsides in the form of backbreaking
04:09
labor and diseases moving easily among denser and more numerous populations, but farming
04:14
allowed humans to support a much larger number of people within a much smaller land area
04:18
than foraging. This was very good for collective learning, which relies on both the number
04:23
of potential innovators and the close connectivity between them. The world population had grown
04:28
from roughly 6 million people at the beginning of agriculture to 50 million by the emergence
04:32
of states 5000 years ago – roughly 5000 times the size of the population that survived the
04:39
Mount Toba disaster 70,000 years prior.
04:41
And because early farmers didn’t really understand or have the technology to solve the problem
04:46
of pooping near the drinking water, another upside was that we invented alcohol which
04:50
was safer to drink instead. So the next time you see a person looking fancy with a glass
04:54
of champagne, just remember, it’s a tradition that started from there being too much poop
04:59
in the water, and ever since has fueled millions of bad decisions.
05:03
States did eventually appear but not all states emerged at once, any more than all agriculture
05:07
emerged at once. Agriculture first emerged in the Fertile Crescent in Egypt around 11,000
05:12
years ago and then in east Asia and Papua New Guinea around 9,000 years ago. Agriculture
05:17
emerged in west Africa and the Americas around 5,000 years ago, though estimates definitely
05:21
vary for the Americas. Accordingly, the first states to arise were in the middle east where
05:27
agriculture first emerged, followed shortly by the Chinese and Indus Valley Civilizations.
05:31
Papua New Guinea may have invented agriculture around the same time but they never developed
05:35
enough agricultural surplus to support states. So yeah, in every world zone the invention
05:40
of agriculture was a precursor for the rise of states.
05:43
The key to having a state is agrarian surplus. If you produce enough food, you can have a
05:48
class of people who don’t need to farm. They can then fulfill other duties in this increasingly
05:53
numerous and complex society whether they be leaders or judges who settle disputes,
05:58
bureaucrats who deal with administration, and infrastructure doctors who heal the sick,
06:02
priests who make sacrifices to vengeful gods or soldiers who provide security or at least
06:08
extract a portion of the agricultural surplus for the leadership through some kind of taxation.
06:13
And with more people filling new jobs and generating new ideas about them, this is also
06:17
good news for collective learning. Diversification of labor is also the first step of early states
06:23
toward hierarchies and classes – aristocrats and popular and despotic kings and pharaohs
06:28
and sultans, shahs and emperors. It also meant the first divisions into unequal, unfair,
06:33
and undemocratic hierarchies dividing man from man, man from woman, and the high from the low.
06:38
All of this brings us back to the Hobbes verses Rousseau debate. Hobbes viewed life without
06:43
state control as nasty, brutish, and short, while Rousseau viewed humanity as largely
06:48
egalitarian before claims to land and wealth and property corrupted them. Now certainly
06:53
the idea of an Age of Innocence or a Golden Age has been popular with many philosophers
06:57
and political idealists throughout history. I mean, if humanity had once been perfect
07:01
and was simply corrupted by societal structures or political systems, then it would take only
07:06
a few tweaks or reforms to get us back to perfection. Unfortunately, it now seems clear
07:12
that a lot of humanity’s evils are created simply by the bad wiring of our evolutionary
07:18
biology, and the solution to that problem is somewhat complicated. It’s very difficult
07:23
for me to imagine a world in which humans will say, “You know what? If the Earth can
07:27
only support 6-8 million foragers, then there should only be 6-8 million of us.” So where
07:32
you stand on this Hobbes v. Rousseau question affects your view of the entire 250,000 years
07:38
of human history, and also your view about much of human morality, character, and potential.
07:44
Another Big History take on agriculture is this: Consider the sun. We are made up of
07:49
the leftovers of its formation and the debris of stars that came before it, but its role
07:53
in our history doesn’t stop there. Fusion reactions happen in the sun’s core. This generates
07:58
energy, which is released into space and takes approximately eight minutes to get to us.
08:02
Here on Earth, plants capture that energy and store it via photosynthesis. Agriculture
08:07
lets one species, us, harness more of that energy, we either eat it or we use it to feed
08:13
animals that we eat, or we use it to feed animals like horses and oxen that pull carts and carry burdens,
08:18
providing 500-750 watts of power, about 10 times more than what a human being could do.
08:23
So essentially, agriculture is the act of harnessing more energy from the sun, way more
08:27
than we could as foragers. All of this leads to an interesting perspective: human history
08:32
has frequently been viewed as too chaotic or complex to allow us to find an underlying
08:37
trend, a bottom line or overarching theme. And this to some people makes conventional
08:40
history differ greatly from the natural sciences. However, given what we know of energy and
08:46
complexity, consider the following: If we want to prevent our bodily complexity, as
08:51
well as the complexity that we have created, from descending into chaos, we must keep harvesting
08:56
matter and energy flows on a regular basis. This is the bottom line of human history.
09:01
I will therefore argue that during most, if not all, of human history, the quest for sufficient
09:05
matter and energy to survive and reproduce has been the overriding theme.
09:09
That doesn’t mean that the bottom line is all there is to human history. You’ve got
09:12
political history and the history of warfare and gender history, class history, art history,
09:17
environmental history, oral traditions, creation myths, and much, much more, but none of those
09:22
would matter if we were all dead. If you don’t eat, if you don’t drink, you die. Much of
09:27
the collective learning, invention, shifts in social structure, have been geared toward
09:31
coping with the problem of energy flows as the population continued to expand by leaps
09:36
and bounds, from a tiny 10,000 people 74,000 years ago to over 7 billion people today.
09:42
So the beautiful thing about being able to remember and accumulate the ideas of your
09:47
ancestors is that some of their ideas are great for agriculture, also other things,
09:52
but mostly food. Whether it’s new forms of irrigation invented in ancient Mesopotamia
09:57
or the four-crop rotation that gradually proliferated across Europe in the 17th and 18th centuries,
10:03
these innovations increased the number of potential innovators who could exist in a
10:07
social order without starving.
10:09
And there were also great innovative leaps in connectivity. For instance, the invention
10:13
of writing in ancient states about 5,000 years ago. Like, starting from a bureaucratic form
10:17
of accounting, mostly to count livestock, to an art, largely enjoyed by the elite, writing
10:22
gradually communicated more abstract and complex ideas. And those ideas became available to
10:28
more and more people as more people could read, until eventually writing became so popular
10:32
that these days, everyone writes books, even some of your Crash Course Big History hosts.
10:36
We also liked writing because it made it less likely that things we’d learned would be forgotten,
10:41
like when people started to write down what they knew, that knowledge became set in stone.
10:46
Sometimes literally! And then with the invention of printing in China and later Korea and the
10:50
printing press in Europe, more writing could be produced and circulated more quickly, and
10:55
often more cheaply than books copied out by hand. All of this turned into a beneficial
10:59
feedback cycle, potential innovators raise the carrying capacity of the population, more
11:04
people go on to produce more ideas, which raises the carrying capacity of the population,
11:09
which in turn produces more potential innovators. And we can do it all without anything bad
11:14
happening to the environment. What’s that? Oh. Oh my.
11:18
So, throughout the agrarian period, collective learning continued to raise the carrying capacity
11:22
of the world. Populations grew from 6 million 10,000 years ago to 50 million by the dawn
11:28
of states to 120 million by 1000 BCE in the midst of classical civilizations. By the end
11:34
of the agrarian era, in the beginning of the industrial revolution, 954 million people lived on the Earth.
11:40
But while collective learning gradually raised the carrying capacity in the agrarian era,
11:45
it did not keep pace with population growth, and this is a significant problem with humanity.
11:50
Just like any other animals in nature, we breed until we strain the resources of our
11:55
environment, so we are prone toward unsustainable levels of overpopulation. So every two or
11:59
three centuries, humans would hit the carrying capacity and then the population would recoil,
12:04
resulting in famine, disease, periods of in-fighting and population decline, in every agrarian
12:10
civilization, from civil wars between Caesar and Pompey, the English War of the Roses,
12:15
to the revolt of the Janissaries in the Ottoman Empire, and similar events all across the
12:20
world, the cycles of prosperity, strain, crisis, and civil in-fighting repeated themselves.
12:26
And I do worry a little bit that when we talk about traditional history, we don’t do it
12:29
enough in the context of carrying capacity. We are, after all, organisms, and we behave
12:34
a lot like other animals on this planet. We want there to be more of us, and we want more
12:39
resources for that more of us to enjoy.
12:41
So that broad, Big History take on the agrarian era takes us to the Age of Exploration. Explorers,
12:47
including Christopher Columbus, but also many others, united the previously isolated world
12:52
zones of Afro-Eurasia, the Americas, Australasia, and the Pacific. Eventually, this combination
12:57
of world zones into one unified global network, although not that unified, would produce an
13:02
even more astounding rise in complexity: the Modern Revolution — we’ll talk about that next time.
—
This post was previously published on YouTube.
—
Photo credit: Screenshot from video.