—
In which John Green finally gets around to talking about some women’s history. In the 19th Century, the United States was changing rapidly, as we noted in the recent Market Revolution and Reform Movements episodes. Things were also in a state of flux for women. The reform movements, which were in large part driven by women, gave these self-same women the idea that they could work on their own behalf, and radically improve the state of their own lives. So, while these women were working on prison reform, education reform, and abolition, they also started talking about equal rights, universal suffrage, temperance, and fair pay. Women like Susan B. Anthony, Carry Nation, Elizabeth Cady Stanton, the Grimkés, and Lucretia Mott strove tirelessly to improve the lot of American women, and it worked, eventually. John will teach you about the Christian Temperance Union, the Seneca Falls Convention, the Declaration of Sentiments, and a whole bunch of other stuff that made life better for women.
—
—
Transcript Provided by YouTube:
00:00
Hi, I’m John Green; this is CrashCourse U.S. history and today we’re going to talk
00:04
about wonder women. Mr. Green, Mr. Green, finally we get to the
00:07
history of the United States as seen through the lens of Marvel comic superheroes.
00:12
Oh, Me from the Past, you sniveling little idiot. Wonder Woman is from the DC Universe.
00:18
Also this is the study of history, which means a constant reexamination and redefinition
00:22
of what it means to be a hero, and in the case of this episode, it’s about taking
00:26
the first steps towards acknowledging that not all heroes worthy of historical recognition
00:30
are men. So we’re going to talk about how women transformed
00:33
pre-Civil War America as they fought to improve prisons, schools, decrease public drunkenness,
00:38
and end slavery. And while fighting for change and justice for others, American women discovered
00:43
that the prisoners, children, and slaves they were fighting for weren’t the only people
00:47
being oppressed and marginalized in the American democracy.
00:55
Intro So in the colonial era, most American women
01:01
of European descent lived lives much like those of their European counterparts: They
01:05
were legally and socially subservient to men and trapped within a patriarchal structure.
01:10
Lower and working class women were actually more equal to men of their own classes, but
01:14
only because they were, like, equally poor. As usual, it all comes back to economics.
01:19
In general, throughout world history, the higher the social class, the greater the restrictions
01:23
on women—although high class women have traditionally had the lowest mortality rates,
01:28
which is one of the benefits of you know doors and extra lifeboats and whatnot. So at least
01:32
you get to enjoy that oppression for many years.
01:35
As previously noted, American women did participate in the American Revolution, but they were
01:39
still expected to marry and have kids rather than, like, pursue a career. Under the legal
01:44
principle of “coverture” actually husbands held authority over the person, property and
01:49
choices of their wives. Also since women weren’t permitted to own
01:52
property and property ownership was a precondition for voting, they were totally shut out of
01:57
the political process. Citizens of the new Republic were therefore
02:00
definitionally male, but women did still improve their status via the ideology of “Republican
02:06
Motherhood.” Women were important to the new Republic because
02:08
they were raising children—ESPECIALLY MALE CHILDREN—who would become the future voters,
02:13
legislators, and honorary doctors of America. So women couldn’t themselves participate
02:18
in the political process, but they needed to be educated some because they were going
02:22
to potty train those who would later participate in the political process. What’s that? There
02:26
were no potties? Really? Apparently instead of potties they had typhoid.
02:30
Actually it was a result of not having potties. So even living without rights in a pottyless
02:33
nation, the Republican Mother idea allowed women access to education, so that they could
02:38
teach their children. Also women—provided they weren’t slaves–were counted in determining
02:42
the population of a state for representation purposes, so that was at least an acknowledgement
02:46
that they were at, like, five fifths human. And then the market revolution had profound
02:50
effects on American women, too, because as production shifted from homes to factories,
02:54
it shifted away from women doing the producing. This led to the so-called “cult of domesticity,”
02:59
which like most cults, I am opposed to. That’s right, Stan, I’m opposed to the
03:03
Blue Oyster Cult, The Cult, The Cult of Personality by In Living Color, and the three remaining
03:08
Shakers. Sorry, Shakers. But who are we kidding? You’re
03:11
not watching. You’re too busy dancing. The cult of domesticity decreed that a woman’s
03:16
place was in the home, so rather than making stuff, the job of women was to enable their
03:21
husbands to make stuff, by providing food and a clean living space, but also by providing
03:26
what our favorite historian Eric Foner called “non-market values like love, friendship,
03:32
and mutual obligation,” which is the way we talk about puppies these days.
03:36
And indeed that’s in line with actual story titles from early 19th century American women’s
03:41
magazines, like “Woman, a Being to Come Home To” and “Woman: Man’s Best Friend.”
03:46
Oh, it’s time for the Mystery Document? I hope it’s from “Woman — Man’s Best
03:48
Friend.” The rules here are simple. I either get the
03:53
author of the Mystery Document right…oh, hey there, eagle…or I get shocked.
03:56
Let’s see what we’ve got. “Woman is to win everything by peace and
03:59
love; by making herself so much respected, esteemed and loved, that to yield to her opinions
04:05
and to gratify her wishes, will be the free-will offering of the heart. … But the moment
04:10
woman begins to feel the promptings of ambition, or the thirst for power, her aegis of defense
04:15
is gone. All the sacred protection of religion, all the generous promptings of chivalry, all
04:20
the poetry of romantic gallantry, depend upon woman’s retaining her place as dependent
04:26
and defenseless, and making no claims, and maintaining no right but what are the gifts
04:32
of honor, rectitude and love.” Well it was definitely a dude and I have no
04:37
idea which dude, so I’m just going to guess John C. Calhoun because he’s a bad person.
04:42
No? Well, what can you do? It wasn’t a dude? It was apparently Harriet Beecher Stowe’s
04:46
sister Catharine who was an education reformer and yet held all of those opinions, so aaaaAAAAH.
04:52
So I assume Stan brought up Harriet Beecher Stowe’s sister to point out that it wasn’t
04:56
just men who bought into the Cult of Domesticity. The idea of true equality between men and
05:00
women was so radical that almost no one embraced it. Like, despite the economic growth associated
05:06
with the market economy, women’s opportunities for work were very limited.
05:10
Only very low paying work was available to them and in most states they couldn’t control
05:14
their own wages if they were married. But, still poor women did find work in factories
05:19
or as domestic servants or seamstresses. Some middle class women found work in that
05:23
most disreputable of fields, teaching, but the cult of domesticity held that a respectable
05:28
middle class woman should stay at home. The truth is, most American women had no chance
05:32
to work for profit outside their houses, so many women found work outside traditional
05:37
spheres in reform movements. Okay, let’s go to the Thought Bubble.
05:41
Reform movements were open to women partly because if women were supposed to be the moral
05:44
center of the home, they could also claim to be the moral conscience of the nation.
05:48
Thus it didn’t seem out of the ordinary for women to become active in the movement
05:52
to build asylums for the mentally ill, for instance, as Dorothea Dix was, or to take
05:56
the lead in sobering the men of America. Many of the most famous advocates for legally prohibiting
06:01
the sale of alcohol in the US were women, like Carry Nation attacked bars with a hatchet
06:06
and not because she’d had a few too many. The somewhat less radical Frances Willard
06:10
founded the Women’s Christian Temperance Union in 1874, which would be one of the most
06:14
powerful lobbying groups in the United States by the end of the 19th century. And women
06:18
gave many temperance lectures featuring horror stories of men who, rather than seeking refuge
06:23
from the harsh competition of the market economy and the loving embrace of their homes, found
06:27
solace at the bottom of a glass or at the end of a beer hose. And by the way, yes, there
06:33
were bars that allowed you to drink as much beer as you could, from a hose, for a nickel.
06:38
Today, these establishments are known as frat houses. These temperance lectures would tell
06:41
of men spending all their hard earned money on drink, leaving wives and children—there
06:46
were always children—starving and freezing, because in the world of the temperance lecture,
06:50
it was always winter. Now don’t get me wrong: Prohibition was a disaster, because 1. Freedom,
06:55
and 2. It’s the only time we had to amend the constitution to be like, “Just kidding
06:59
about that other amendment,” but it’s worth remembering that back then people drank
07:03
WAY more than we do now, and also that alcohol is probably a greater public health issue
07:08
than some recreational drugs that remain illegal. But regardless, the temperance movement made
07:13
a huge difference in American life because eventually, male and female supporters of
07:18
temperance realized that women would be a more powerful ally against alcohol if they
07:23
could vote. Thanks Thought Bubble. So, in 1928, critic
07:26
Gilbert Seldes wrote that if prohibition had existed in 1800, “the suffragists might
07:31
have remained for another century a scattered group of intellectual cranks.”
07:35
And to quote another historian, “the most urgent reasons for women to want to vote in
07:38
the mid-1800s were alcohol related: They wanted the saloons closed down, or at least regulated.
07:43
The wanted the right to own property, and to shield their families’ financial security
07:47
from the profligacy of drunken husbands. They wanted the right to divorce those men, and
07:51
to have them arrested for wife beating, and to protect children from being terrorized
07:55
by them. To do all these things they needed to change the laws that consigned married
07:59
women to the status of chattel. And to change those laws, they needed the vote.”
08:04
Many women were also important contributors to the anti-slavery movement, although they
08:07
tended to have more subordinate roles. Like, abolitionist Maria Stewart was the first African
08:11
American woman to lecture to mixed male and female audiences. Harriet Beecher Stowe wrote
08:16
the terrible but very import ant Uncle Tom’s Cabin. Sarah and Angelina Grimke, daughters
08:21
of a South Carolina slaveholder, converted to Quakerism and became outspoken critics
08:25
of slavery. Sarah Grimke even published the Letters on
08:28
the Equality of the Sexes in 1838, which is pretty much what the title suggests.
08:32
By the way, Stan, you could have made Sarah Grimke’s letters the Mystery Document. I
08:35
would have gotten that. But I want to say one more thing about Harriet
08:37
Beecher Stowe. There’s a reason we read Uncle Tom’s Cabin in history classes and
08:40
not in literature ones, but Uncle Tom’s Cabin introduced millions of Americans to
08:45
the idea that African American people were people.
08:48
At least in 19th century readers, Uncle Tom’s Cabin humanized slaves to such a degree that
08:53
it was banned throughout most of the south. So many women involved in the abolitionist
08:57
movement, when studying slavery, noticed that there was something a little bit familiar.
09:00
Now, some male abolitionists, notably Frederick Douglass and William Lloyd Garrison became
09:04
supporters of women’s rights, but ultimately the male leaders of the anti-slavery movement
09:08
denied women’s demands for equality, believing that any calls for women’s rights would
09:13
undermine the cause of abolition. And they may have had a point because slavery
09:16
only existed in parts of the country whereas women existed in all of it.
09:21
In fact, one of the arguments used by pro-slavery forces was that equality under the law for
09:25
male slaves might lead to a slippery slope ending with, like, equality for WOMEN.
09:30
And out of this emerging consciousness of their own subordinate position, the movement
09:34
for women’s rights was born. The most visible manifestation of it was the issue of woman’s
09:39
suffrage, raised most eloquently at the Seneca Falls Convention of 1848 where Elizabeth Cady
09:44
Stanton, Lucretia Mott, Susan B. Anthony and many others wrote and published the Declaration
09:48
of Sentiments, modeled very closely on the Declaration of Independence.
09:51
Except, in some ways this declaration was much more radical than the Declaration of
09:55
Independence because it took on the entire patriarchal structure.
09:58
Okay, so there are three things I want to quickly point out about the 19th century movement
10:01
for women’s rights. First, like abolitionism, it was an international movement. Often American
10:06
feminists travelled abroad to find allies, prefiguring the later transatlantic movement
10:10
of other advocates for social justice like Florence Kelley and W.E.B DuBois.
10:14
Secondly, for the most part, like other reform movements, the women’s movement was primarily
10:18
a middle-class or even upper class effort. Most of the delegates at Seneca Falls, for
10:22
instance, were from the middle class. There were no representatives of, like, cotton mills,
10:26
but this didn’t mean that 19th century feminists didn’t acknowledge the needs of working
10:30
women. Like, Sojourner Truth, probably the most famous
10:32
black woman abolitionist, spoke eloquently of the plight of working class women, especially
10:37
slaves, since she’d been one until 1827. And other women recognized that women needed
10:42
to be able to participate in the market economy to gain some economic freedom.
10:45
Now, of course all the women who wrote about the moral evils of 19th century America or
10:50
spoke out or took hatchets to saloons were doing what we would now recognize as work.
10:55
But they were not being paid. Amelia Bloomer got paid, though, because she
10:58
recognized that it was impossible for women to easily participate in economic activities
11:03
because of their crazy clothes. So she popularized a new kind of clothing
11:06
featuring a loose fitting tunic, trousers, and eponymous undergarments.
11:09
But then Bloomer and her pants were ridiculed in the press and in the streets, and this
11:13
brings up the third important thing to remember about the 19th century women’s movement.
11:17
It faced strong resistance. Patriarchy, like the force, is strong, which
11:22
is why Luke and Yoda and Darth Vader and Obi-Wan and whoever Samuel Jackson played…all dudes.
11:28
By the way, why did they train Luke up and not Princess Leia who was cooler and had more
11:32
to fight for and was less screwed up? Patriarchy. Many women’s rights advocates were fighting
11:36
to overturn not just laws, but also attitudes. Some of those goals, such as claiming greater
11:41
control over the right to regulate their own sexual activity and whether or not to have
11:44
children were twisted by critics to claim that women advocated “free love.”
11:49
It’s interesting to note that the United States ended slavery more than 50 years before
11:53
it granted women the right to vote and that although much of the march towards equality
11:57
between the sexes has been slow and steady, the Equal Rights Amendment, despite being
12:01
passed by Congress, was never ratified. But by taking leading roles in the reform
12:05
movements in the 19th century, not just when it came to temperance and slavery, but also
12:08
prisons and asylums, women were able to enter the public sphere for the first time.
12:13
And these great women changed the world for better and for worse, just as great men do.
12:18
And along the way, they made “the woman question” part of the movement for social
12:22
reform in the United States. And in doing so, American women chipped away at the idea
12:27
that a woman’s place must be in the home. That might not have been a presidential election
12:31
or a war, but it is still bringing real change to our real lives on a daily basis. Thanks
12:37
for watching. I’ll see you next week. Crash Course is produced and directed by Stan
12:41
Muller. Our script supervisor is Meredith Danko. The associate producer is Danica Johnson.
12:44
The show is written by my high school history teacher Raoul Meyer, and myself. And our graphics
12:48
team is Thought Café. If you want to suggest captions for the libertage,
12:51
please do so in comments where you can also ask questions about today’s video that will
12:54
be answered by our team of historians. Thanks for watching Crash Course and as we
12:57
say in my hometown, don’t forget to be awesome…oh, lights! Everything’s fine.
—
This post was previously published on YouTube.
—
Photo credit: Screenshot from video