“I want to become more self-confident.”
One of my new sales people told me that last night.
“But do you?” I asked. “Or do you really want to become something else?”
He was puzzled, so I went on.
“Do you want to become more self-confident, or are you really looking to increase your self-esteem?”
There’s a distinction between the two.
Self-confidence is based on at least two things: the situation you’re in and how skilled you are at what you’re trying to do.
Think of a basketball player as an example. He practices shooting free throws at the end of every practice. There’s nobody else in the gym; no competition and no crowd. And there’s no score. It’s just him, his basketball, and the hoop.
Out of 100 shots, he’ll make most of them. He’ll make them all when he’s feeling good.
But something happens when he steps to the free throw line during a game. He gets incredibly nervous. He loses focus. He hears the crowd, sees the other players, and feels the pressure. And his team is down by two points.
The situation changed, and so did his level of self-confidence.
While he’s completely confident when he’s alone at the gym, he may not be as confident when it’s game time. This applies to many situations, like sales, relationships, public speaking, casual conversations. Hey, you name it.
When the situation changes, so does our level of self-confidence.
So he should never leave the gym, right?
It seems like one possible way to never lose your self-confidence would be to never do things you’re not good at in new situations. I don’t think that’s the best way to handle it. That’d be the equivalent of telling that basketball player to never leave the gym. There’s no way to convince him to do that!
The better option is to increase your self-confidence by using your skill in different (and challenging) situations. Better yet, deliberately practice that skill in different and challenging situations.
Let’s go back to the basketball player for one moment.
If he wants to truly become more self-confident in tough situations, then he’d find a way to replicate tough situations into his practice. My basketball coach in grade school used to have us yell distracting (and usually funny) things at our teammates during free throw practice. The yelling ultimately led to dancing like dorks or making funny faces at our teammate as he tried to sink the shot.
Sure, maybe it didn’t perfectly replicate the game time situations, but it was something different than standing in the gym all alone.
And that’s the thing about increasing your self-confidence at anything: you can improve your self-confidence with practice inside different situations. You can train yourself to be self-confident in a similar way to how my grade school team became better at free throws.
Hey, who said deliberate practice couldn’t be fun?
But here’s the catch.
Yes, the catch.
You saw it coming. I know you did! Well, here it is.
Self-confidence is incredibly difficult to acquire when you don’t hold yourself in high self-esteem. Not impossible, but incredibly difficult.
Sometimes we get self-confidence mixed up with self-esteem. They overlap, but they aren’t the same thing. Remember, self-confidence is based on how good you are at a skill in a certain situation. It comes and goes depending on the situation.
Self-esteem is not based on your skill level or the situation.
In reality, self-esteem is based on your perception of yourself.
Self-esteem is the hardest to build, but most worth the effort.
Think of self-esteem as a platform for self-confidence.
Self-esteem is what you think of and believe about yourself. While you can be influenced by a whole bunch of outside forces—like what other people think about you—you have the opportunity to decide how high you hold yourself. You carry your self-esteem around from situation to situation. The actual situation doesn’t matter like it does with self-confidence. What matters now is what you believe about yourself.
Jump back to our basketball player one last time.
Maybe he’s never had to shoot free throws in the final seconds of the game. Maybe he’s never been in a position in which the fate of the game depended on making those two shots. In those cases, we can’t blame the guy for not being really self-confident.
But he holds himself in high self-esteem.
Throughout his career he’s believed in himself. He’s believed in his ability to perform under pressure. He’s seen himself as the go-to guy. Sure, he’s doubted himself before, but he knows that doubt is just a temporary replacement for confidence.
He sinks the shots.
If you’re looking to become more self-confident, start with self-esteem. Change the way you look at yourself and you’ll be able to adapt to more situations, which leads to more self-confidence.
Now get to work!
Would you like to help us shatter stereotypes about men?
Receive stories from The Good Men Project, delivered to your inbox daily or weekly.
—
Photo: Flickr/Wendy Berry


I think you just solved an old puzzle of mine. Back in high school, I was an actor. Started in a couple of small roles freshman year, was consistently doing leads by the time I was a junior. I don’t know how I caught on to the secret, but after the first performance or so, I was never afraid to go on stage, and ended up as probably one of the best actors who ever attended that small school. So, clearly I was outgoing, poised, and a great success with the ladies, right? Nuh-uh. I was hopeless socially, and with… Read more »
Hey Rich, thank you for leaving your kind note. Puzzles aren’t always fun to piece together, but beautiful once they’re finished. Cheers.