—
After the 2018 U.S. Open women’s final, with accusations and blame being directed at both Serena Williams and the referee, I found myself agreeing with people on both sides of the issue. Of course, I had an initial snap opinion as I often do, but seeing as I am not an avid tennis fan, a person of color, or a woman, I was particularly curious to hear a comprehensive, fact-based conversation regarding what transpired.

I actually found it refreshing to feel so conflicted on an issue. Because here is the thing, feeling conflicted on an issue is a very natural emotion. Unfortunately, it has become one that is frowned upon.
Our media (and that includes the social media we create) generally does not allow for any grey area. Issues must be black and white, forcing all to take a side. This continuous march into a world of binary conflicts has exhausted me. The rational middle ground gets ignored on many issues. Those in power are reluctant to appear weak or incorrect. Black or white is where confidence is sowed. The grey is for the indecisive. The unconfident. The wrong.
It has been my experience the more I learn about something, the more obscured my initial perceptions become. To understand anything deeply is to know a deeper understanding doesn’t always mean clarity. Nothing is truly as it initially seems from the outside. There are variance and nuance to feel conflicted about. More and more I find myself craving such variance and nuance.
Rarely do we witness those with a platform acknowledge a mistaken belief or change their mind. Winner take all is the only way. Any admission of fault immediately becomes a hole in the dike, a Jenga piece taken from the bottom of the tower.
Which leaves opposing individuals hesitant to agree with each other. Each side plows forward, increasing their intensity and volume, trying their best to come across as wholly right. I don’t know if I have ever seen somebody escalated to a fever pitch suddenly stop and say, “Woah, you know what… I was wrong. You were right.”
Temper and speed do not allow room for self-evaluation, certainly not self-correction. This heightened behavior is modeled for us and so we emulate it. And so, the way we all interact suffers.
It was during the back and forth around Serena Williams and the referee that a familiar phrase popped into my head. One from the improv comedy community which had become popular over the past decade as a mental framework applicable to all aspects of life.
Yes and.
It is used in improv scene work for one partner to acknowledge the world their scene partner is inventing, and add to it. It is one of the quickest and most effective ways to build a coherent and funny scene.
And I think we need more of it our discourse.
The statement does two things when used in conversation. It first acknowledges and respects the other person’s opinion. It lets them know what they said has been heard. They are seen and valued. So much conflict at every level of our lives results from not being or feeling heard. Sometimes we don’t even want to be right, we just want to state our opinion. To know we have contributed. To know we were not ignored.
And second “Yes and” builds a dialogue. It creates a structure of points from both parties to scaffold a conversation. The way we currently engage with each other by saying “No” or “But” immediately disavows or ignores the points of another person. It is like watching somebody build a tower of blocks only to knock it down after they finish for no reason other than to build your own in the exact same spot.
As though the two of you couldn’t build together.
We are not even talking about having to admit when we are wrong. It seems unlikely that will happen in the near future. We are merely saying it is possible for two people to be at least partially right.
Often enough I find myself having arguments with my fiancé about some nonsensical thing. Wanting so desperately to make my points, I move quickly to be heard without making sure I have been listening. It is not at all helpful. Every relationship in my life could benefit from my ability to say:
Yes, what you are saying is correct. I hear you. And, here is my position.
But we don’t acknowledge, we dismiss. Even if we say “yes” we follow it with a “but” which instantly devalues the contribution of the other person so we can establish our views as more important.
Yes, you have an opinion but, I have one too. And I need you to know how much more important it is than yours.
I know how it feels to be dismissed. To feel unheard. To struggle to convey my views to an otherwise uninterested party. And yet, I am still guilty of doing the same thing to my own conversational partners. I believe keeping “yes and” can help me. I believe it can help all of us.
Arguments are more convincing and comprehensive when they are inclusive. Our discourse need not be a zero-sum game with only one winner. In fact that the goal of discourse should not be to win at all, but to connect, to understand, and to resolve.
And that means admitting when we feel conflicted. Even if it makes us uncomfortable.
—
If you believe in the work we are doing here at The Good Men Project, please join like-minded individuals in The Good Men Project Premium Community.
◊♦◊
◊♦◊
Get the best stories from The Good Men Project delivered straight to your inbox, here.
◊♦◊
◊♦◊
Sign up for our Writing Prompts email to receive writing inspiration in your inbox twice per week.
—


