We look at the deeper meaning of Billy Wilder’s noir classic Sunset Boulevard. Wilder critiqued Hollywood’s toxic star machine, its mistreatment of writers and its system discouraging true originality.
.
.
Transcript provided by Youtube:
00:00
[Music]
00:01
all right mr. DeMille I’m ready for my
00:04
custom one of the all-time most popular
00:09
Noirs Billy Wilder’s Sunset Boulevard is
00:12
a haunting Hollywood nightmare narrated
00:15
by a dead man William Holden’s
00:17
down-and-out screenwriter Joe Gillis
00:19
all right Guinness you’ve got five
00:21
minutes what’s your story about Sunset
00:23
Boulevard was described by film writer
00:25
Richard Corliss as quote the definitive
00:28
Hollywood horror movie need any help
00:31
with the coffin calling me but the
00:33
classic is more than a cynical takedown
00:35
of Hollywood looking inward at the
00:37
moviemaking process the 1915 you are
00:40
warned that making a quality picture
00:43
should be about devotion to good stories
00:45
vicki was I think you should throw out
00:47
all that psychological mess exploring a
00:49
killer sick mind Myka Pascal like
00:51
hotcakes not the pursuit of vanity or
00:54
past glory Sunset Boulevard indicted the
00:56
studio system’s mistreatment of the
00:58
writer don’t you know the finest things
01:00
in the world then written on an empty
01:02
stomach in its toxic star machine based
01:04
on an endless cycle of celebrity worship
01:07
and obsession with youth Norma Desmond
01:09
is coming in to see you mr. DeMille
01:11
no no yes she must be a million years
01:15
old these targets reveal a lot about
01:16
film history and they also make Wilders
01:19
cautionary tale feel all too relevant to
01:22
our moviemaking business today the dark
01:27
side of Hollywood star system is
01:28
embodied in washed-up silent film star
01:31
Norma Desmond played by the real silent
01:33
film star Gloria Swanson Norma’s vanity
01:36
is so overgrown it’s left reality behind
01:38
she was still sleep walking along the
01:41
giddy heights of a lost career plain
01:44
crazy when it came to that one subject
01:45
her celluloid self she lives in the past
01:48
watching her own old movies undergoing
01:51
rigorous procedures for her comeback
01:54
that will never come we had faces your
01:57
Norma Desmond used to be in silent
02:00
pictures used to be big
02:02
I am big it’s the pictures that got
02:06
small the star system emphasizes above
02:10
everything image and Norma is exactly
02:13
just an image she is all faces and being
02:16
big in image with nothing behind it we
02:19
come to pity Norma and her delusions as
02:22
casualties of a mean business well I ask
02:25
is for you to be a little patient and a
02:28
little kind the studio’s made her into a
02:30
monster she was a terror to work with
02:33
only toward the end you know doesn’t
02:36
press agents working overtime and do
02:39
terrible things to the human spirit and
02:42
then traded her in for the next star to
02:44
promote an exploit it’s me
02:48
it’s fog I an object for the public to
02:55
worship get a good luck edge
02:58
[Music]
02:59
Norma why I thought she was dead and
03:03
then forget all right and I like that
03:07
regard
03:08
our fluctuating feelings toward Norma
03:11
provide a subtle commentary on Hollywood
03:13
and our own attitude toward older women
03:17
but the point is I never looked better
03:18
in my life
03:19
norm is a prime example of the monstrous
03:21
older woman trope whose presented is
03:24
ghastly for refusal to accept her age
03:26
yet why would anyone want to act like an
03:29
old woman when they’re just expected to
03:31
quietly disappear in historical context
03:36
Norma’s a symbol of a whole era of
03:38
silent film stars who had been
03:40
ungraciously cast aside Swanson was
03:42
herself a product of the silent era
03:44
system Wilder approached a number of
03:46
former stars about the role including
03:48
reclusive Mary Pickford who was
03:50
reportedly horrified by the idea of
03:53
playing Norma Wilder also considered
03:56
people like Mae West Pola Negri whose
03:59
polish accent was too strong Norma
04:02
Shearer and Greta Garbo director George
04:05
Cukor recommended Swanson who was aghast
04:08
when she was asked to do a screen test
04:11
Swanson was arguably the star of
04:13
Paramount in those days so when Norma
04:16
says and without me you wouldn’t have
04:18
any job because without me there
04:19
wouldn’t be any paramount studio you’re
04:21
right miss Desmond Swanson herself might
04:24
not be exaggerating to say the same yet
04:26
her fortunes declined as she aged and
04:29
the sound era kicked in the time in
04:31
business when they had the eyes of the
04:33
whole wide world but a bloody good
04:35
enough for them hoho
04:37
that’s how the ears of the world – so
04:39
they opened their big mouths and out
04:41
came talk oh oh
04:44
until her triumphant return in Sunset
04:46
Boulevard landed the actress her first
04:49
Academy Award nomination in 21 years the
04:54
film also features silent film director
04:56
Erich von Stroheim as Norma’s stuck in
04:59
time Butler Max I discovered her when
05:01
she was 16 I made a rest
05:04
[Music]
05:06
who’s revealed to be Norma’s first
05:08
husband and former director iconic
05:11
director says would be DeMille plays
05:12
himself while silent film stars HB
05:15
Warner Buster Keaton and Anna Q Nielsen
05:18
all make cameos as Norma’s waxwork
05:21
bridge partners wilder and producer
05:24
Charles Brackett trying to keep
05:25
paramount in the dark about the full
05:28
extent of the movies digs at Hollywood
05:30
in avoid excessive censorship by the
05:32
Breen office by submitting the script
05:34
only a few pages at a time for review
05:37
the story goes that they told Paramount
05:39
they were adapting a story titled a can
05:41
of beans which didn’t exist legendary
05:45
producer Louie be mayor of MGM slammed
05:49
wilder you be fouled your own nest
05:52
silent era star Mae Murray reportedly
05:55
said none of us loses with that nuts
06:00
with his reflective monologues and
06:03
sarcastic retorts the weathered Gilles
06:05
presents a grim picture of the
06:07
screenwriters life as a cog in the movie
06:10
machine
06:11
I’m sorry mr. Gilles but I just didn’t
06:13
think was any good
06:14
I found it flat and trite exactly what
06:18
kind of material do you recommend James
06:20
Joyce Dostoevsky
06:21
he questions Hollywood’s impossible
06:23
demands for medium originality it
06:25
rejects formulaic stories yet won’t
06:28
accept truly creative ones either maybe
06:30
they weren’t original enough maybe they
06:34
were too original all I know is they
06:38
didn’t send the writers uncertain
06:40
prospects despite hard work I always
06:42
heard that you had some talent that was
06:44
last year this year I’m trying to earn a
06:45
living
06:45
the likelihood of executive meddling in
06:47
the creative process that’s when I wrote
06:49
was about Okies Modesto you’d never know
06:52
because when it reached the screen the
06:54
whole thing played on a copy the risk of
06:56
plagiarism my other writers never let
06:59
another writer read your material he
07:00
made Stephen in the general lack of
07:02
acknowledgement and respect for the
07:04
writers contribution audiences don’t
07:06
know somebody sits down and write to
07:08
picture they think the actors make it up
07:11
as they go along
07:11
all of these might have been Wilders own
07:14
concerns after all as an accomplished
07:17
screenwriter he wrote the story of a
07:19
writer and likely made Gilles a vessel
07:21
of his frustrations
07:22
it was exactly such fear an actual
07:25
personal experience that made him take
07:27
up directing himself during the filming
07:29
of ball of fire a film Wilder wrote
07:32
director Howard Hawks became his mentor
07:35
Wilders story concerns another writer
07:37
22-year old script reading an aspiring
07:40
screenwriter Betty Schaefer played by
07:42
Nancy Olsen I got twenty pages of notes
07:44
and I got a pretty good character for
07:46
the man in stark contrast with the
07:47
cynical Joe Betty is a passionate
07:50
newcomer I don’t want to be a reader all
07:52
my life I want to write betty is the
07:54
foil to delusional Norma she’s
07:57
level-headed grounded in reality and
07:59
flexible she grew up in a showbiz family
08:01
and once dreamed of being a star well
08:04
they didn’t like my
08:05
slanted this way a little so I went to a
08:08
doctor and had it fixed it made more
08:10
tests and they were crazy about my nose
08:12
I mean I didn’t like my acting but when
08:14
she failed she moved on and found her
08:16
right place behind the camera this
08:18
revelation of Betty’s previous dream is
08:20
a crucial counterpoint to Norma who
08:22
can’t face bad news or hear the answer
08:25
no Betty represents the virtue of
08:27
adaptability
08:28
Betty proves that if you like movies you
08:31
can find a way to be part of them as
08:33
long as you work hard and admit your
08:35
strengths and weaknesses meanwhile Betty
08:39
pesters Jo to work hard at some really
08:41
good writing I just think it picture
08:44
should say a little Tuffy oh one of the
08:46
message kids just a story won’t do you
08:49
know turn down Gone with the Wind no
08:50
that was me I said who wants to see a
08:52
civil war picture Jo is hinting that
08:55
Betty’s high-minded outlook is no more a
08:57
phase that all writers go through and
08:59
she will end up jaded and defeated like
09:01
him but he begins to admire her passion
09:04
straightforwardness an eye for a good
09:07
story her pestering makes him a better
09:09
writer and a self respecting individual
09:12
don’t you sometimes hate yourself
09:13
constantly no in all seriousness this is
09:18
really good fun writing if Wilder was
09:22
projecting his cynical experiences onto
09:24
Jo Betty represented his inner idealist
09:27
the collaborative experience between Jo
09:30
and Betty mirrors Wilders process
09:33
working on the script of Double
09:34
Indemnity
09:35
six years before with Raymond Chandler
09:37
then also an impassioned newcomer in
09:39
Hollywood Gillis is deal with Norma to
09:42
become a kept man and work on a terrible
09:44
script is triggered by his creative
09:47
drought and need for money yet his
09:49
meeting Betty symbolizes that he still
09:51
has the ability to create original
09:52
material she dies because he has already
09:55
entangled himself too deeply in the
09:57
normal version of Hollywood in which one
09:59
sells his soul and dignity to what he
10:02
doesn’t love or believed in
10:07
doom and gloom has announced from the
10:09
start by the format itself we’re given a
10:12
story narrated by a dead man
10:14
this choice tells us what to expect
10:16
Hollywood is not a fertile place for
10:18
artists it will eat you up and spit you
10:21
out
10:21
yet a naive part of us still hopes
10:23
despite knowing the ending that Betty
10:26
and Joe can somehow transcend this world
10:30
suddenly I find myself terribly afraid
10:32
of losing you you won’t I’ll get us a
10:35
refill of this horrible equipment you’ll
10:37
be waiting for me with a wildly beating
10:39
heart life can be beautiful one of the
10:44
movie’s messages is that trying to hold
10:45
on to the Past and freeze things the way
10:48
they were is fatal delusion just like
10:51
trying to act like a fresh-faced youth
10:52
when you’re a middle-aged woman Norma
10:54
you’re a woman of 15 I’ll grow up
10:56
there’s nothing tragic about being 50
10:59
not less you try to be 25
11:01
above all Sunset Boulevard advocates the
11:04
will to confront reality and tell it
11:06
like it is good storytelling an artistic
11:09
creation hinges on viewing reality and
11:11
ourselves with honesty this also means
11:14
Rican fronting our changing realities
11:16
and selves as time goes by the world of
11:20
film moves on and movies are never
11:23
really about any one person or star
11:25
every person working on the movie is a
11:28
tool or contributor to the storytelling
11:30
even the glamorous star Wilder hints at
11:34
the glory of what people do that’s never
11:36
really seen by the audience
11:38
this anonymous contribution has the
11:40
potential to become great art if you’re
11:42
driven by the love of movies rather than
11:45
glory the movies final shot of normal
11:48
looking into camera is one of the iconic
11:50
moments in film history the image
11:52
underlines the dangerous appeal of
11:54
intoxicating stardom an addiction to the
11:57
public’s loving gaze yet this final
12:00
sequence gives us contradicting emotion
12:03
it represents Norma’s full descent into
12:05
hurt insanity it’s also a fabulous
12:08
transfixing performance by Swanson that
12:11
led the entire crew to applaud and
12:13
Swanson herself to burst into tears
12:15
after they wrap so well for the
12:17
character
12:18
represents that rejection of reality
12:20
within the film it represents a
12:22
brilliant piece of acting the heights
12:26
film can reach when people give
12:28
generously to their art like most noir
12:31
Sunset Boulevard starts by presenting a
12:34
casually cynical view of its subject
12:36
only to reveal by the end the despite
12:39
its high exterior it holds dearly to a
12:42
few key ideals in the end Sunset
12:44
Boulevard is a love letter to the joy of
12:47
making a really fine movie
12:50
[Music]
13:23
you
—
This post was previously published on Youtube.
—
***
If you believe in the work we are doing here at The Good Men Project and want to join our calls on a regular basis, please join us as a Premium Member, today.
All Premium Members get to view The Good Men Project with NO ADS.
Need more info? A complete list of benefits is here.
Talk to you soon.
—
Photo credit: Screenshot from video

