
We all know what happened to Jane Doe on October 19–20, 2024, at a Cornell University fraternity. At around 11:00 p.m. the already intoxicated young woman walked into the Chi Phi fraternity house, arriving “visibly intoxicated” after consuming “about 10 standard drinks within the past 3 hours,” according to her civil lawsuit. What happened next was all too predictable.
In one version, Jane Doe was invited to participate in a threesome sexual episode with two of the fraternity men. She agreed, but being so intoxicated meant that she was unable to give proper consent. Next, she was given ketamine, a very powerful sedative, seemingly without her knowledge, and subjected to gang rape by a total of seven fraternity men lasting several hours. These are the allegations.
There will be no attempt here to adjudicate the case, nor to prove anyone was right or wrong. That is a task for a special attorney investigation, a Title IX investigation and possibly a criminal case heard in a court of law. But we need to acknowledge that the reports regarding this incident are complicated, conflicting and difficult to decipher.
Rather, we are here to make certain broad inquiries. First, why do we expect young men and women, who are very likely sexually naive, to prevent rape? Do we imagine that the average university student is even capable of defining rape? Second, who is responsible for teaching students about consent and its rather obvious limitations? Third, what was it in the prior experiences of these young men that led them to believe that they could sexually abuse this semi-conscious woman for several hours and get away with it?
We were all stupidly naive as young people. But hormones were raging, attraction and arousal were real, and we were surrounded by beautiful young men and women. I am sure that most of us had some vague idea that sexual interactions should be mutual experiences. But what did we know about consent? In my generation, thinking back through college, we barely understood sexuality, especially about the opposite sex.
We all had a vague notion of a line between mutually agreeable sexual encounters and pressuring others into sex which they did not want or perhaps were not ready for. Of course, alcohol and drugs complicated matters as they do today. But what we did not have in my time was readily available, cinematic pornography that appears to show the mechanics of sex acts without any of the emotional dimensions.
Why do we expect young men and women, who are very likely sexually naive, to prevent rape?
I believe rape was an ambiguous concept to the young men at Cornell, as it is to many young men. They probably learned about sex from watching pornography while engaged in self-pleasuring. Certianly there nothing wrong with self-pleasuring since it is a wonderful way to learn about one’s body, sexuality, and fantasy life. But porn has a way of pulling the viewer into ever more risky, dramatic and brutal behavior that should not be associated with sexual encounters that express loving kindness.
Sex for university age men is viewed as a kind of adventure, and that’s fine as long as their partner is also thinking this way. Of course, a prospective sexual partner must ask the other. Communication must happen before any clothes come off or intimate touching begins. Sorry guys, life is not porn, and women do not exist for your imagined pleasure.
Rape has always been hard to define, and even harder to prove in a court of law. From a young person’s point of view, it is somehow related to crossing a line, and often in a thrilling way. But where is that line? Without significant adult counsel and what we might call “intimacy education,” many young people cannot determine where the line is, especially in the heat of passion, or in this case, groupthink.
Rape is also directly contingent on the question of consent. Jane Doe claims that she did not grant consent to be gang raped by seven young men in a dorm room. But the reality is that consent is multi-layered. In this case, these young men should have observed how intoxicated this woman was even as she walked in the door, and kindly escorted her back to her sorority.
Even if she agreed to the initial threesome, in her intoxicated state she could not have granted consent. Few men understand this caveat. The young men were the aggressors in this situation and so they did not need consent. The truth about rape is that it is about dominance, not sex, and certainly not about sexual relations to express loving kindness.
Obviously not one of the young men intervened, and no one escorted her back to her sorority. Instead, they gave her additional drugs to knock her out and then gang raped her. Where does a young man learn about gang rape? It turns out that “gangbang” is one of the most searched categories of pornography websites.
I believe porn should be regulated, just like alcohol, marijuana and sex shops. And I also believe that young people need to be educated about consent and all of its limitations. The goal is to err on the side of basic humanity, respect and brotherly concern. Someone should have escorted Jane Doe home.
Who is responsible for teaching students about consent and its rather obvious limitations?
At the moment, no one. Any parent who sends their teen child to a residential university should be aware of this and take action as a family. Universities with residential programs are also responsible, and need to develop mandatory programs for any entering students to learn and openly discuss these issues.
Harvard has such a program. It offers a framework to teach children from early education through to high school. The RAINN program (Rape, Abuse & Incest National Network) is the largest anti-sexual violence organization in the United States and offers numerous helpful materials for teaching consent at every age. SIECUS is another organization that encourages peer-to-peer education on consent and intervention, healthy relationships, and violence prevention. There are also numerous programs for parents to begin teaching children about boundaries from very young ages.
In short, everyone is responsible for educating young people about consent and its various limitations and caveats. It is essential to connect sex to awareness of boundaries, respect for persons as whole people, and what we mean by the term “sexual violence.”
What was it in the prior experiences of these young men that led them to believe that they could sexually abuse this woman or any woman?
We have already addressed the dangers of porn, especially for sexually naive young people. Increasingly, the question of sexual violence has become a recognized research subject. One study from Binghamton University by Richard E. Mattson and his graduate students found that “adherence to cultural myths about what constitutes rape was the strongest predictor of assaultive behavior.” Mattson reports that:
“A high proportion of men report that they would commit a considerably violent rape if they could be assured that they would not get caught. This may sound surprising, but the men that are likeliest to commit rape also tend to carry traits that make their reporting less surprising, like high levels of impulsivity and adherence to hypermasculine ideologies that see nothing wrong with male sexual dominion.”
We will add a concept that is generally unspoken in the United States, and this is class privilege. While this is not a linear relationship to sexual violence, it is a powerful predictor of risk. In brief, we know that there are higher rates of sexual assault and sexual violence among low-income women when compared to economically privileged groups. The same is true for vulnerable and dependent women who do not possess the means to leave a sexually abusive relationship.
There are clear relationships between upper class privilege and beliefs about impunity. Young men with elite insitutional backgrounds such as private secondary schools often assume that their status protects them from accountability. A study from the University of Ottawa by Masters student Danielle Guarino (available only as a pdf) shows that when it comes to IPV or intimate partner violence, gender oppression and class privilege intersect to promote IPV but also to suppress the reporting of these crimes.
Finally, the Greek System appears to impact campus culture in ways that compound the risk of sexual violence toward women. Researchers studied these male institutions at elite universities, in particular the “party culture” of fraternities, and found that class privilege promotes sexual competition, objectification of women, and institutional protection of perpetrators.
Please do not misconstrue anything reported here as justifying the abusive actions of the seven young men alleged to have gang raped Jane Doe. The problem is widespread and largely unreported. But the victims often carry the burden of trauma for the rest of their lives. We know that sexual assault is the primary threat to women’s safety on university campuses.
It is time to take action and find effective ways of intervening.
Vic Caldarola is the founder and lead facilitator of the Shine a Light Men’s Project, a men’s mindfulness program, and a member of the Still Water Mindfulness Practice Center. He holds a PhD in Communication Studies.
—
This post was previously published on medium.com.
Did you know? We have 8 publications on Medium. Join us there!
***
–
Photo credit: Ahtziri Lagarde on Unsplash
