
By Joshua P. Starr, The 74
This story first appeared at The 74, a nonprofit news site covering education. Sign up for free newsletters from The 74 to get more like this in your inbox.
A few years ago, “quiet quitting” was the buzz phrase used to describe an apparent crisis in the workplace. It described employee responses to unengaging workplaces. Instead of simply leaving a job, workers slowed down and just did the bare minimum in order to keep from getting fired.
I wonder if we’re seeing something similar with the current crisis of chronic absenteeism: the quiet quitting of our youth from the one institution that’s supposed to set them on a path for success in life.
Chronically absent students — those who miss school more than 10% of the time — are telling us that school just isn’t important enough in their lives to get to every day. While there may be external factors that compromise their abilities to get to school, most of those have always existed, and educators have always taken them into account. Something feels different about today’s new pandemic of chronic absenteeism, which means we need different strategies.
Young people need to be in school. Getting students back into classrooms is absolutely necessary for their achievement and success. But keeping them there is the real challenge.
As I watch the myriad of very necessary attendance management strategies that leaders are putting into play, I wonder whether they’re sufficient. Yes, we need to reach out to families in a variety of ways. Yes, incentives for good attendance can work up to a point. And, yes, it’s the whole community’s responsibility to reinforce the importance of school and help educators increase attendance.
All of that is necessary, but it’s not sufficient. Schools must do all of that as first steps when it comes to chronic absenteeism. And then they have to do the real work of focusing on belonging and engagement.
Organizations such as Panorama and Attendance Works have demonstrated that students who don’t show up are less likely to graduate, have worse academic performance and social connections, and go on to futures with less potential. School definitely matters. But students must feel a reason to be in school. They have to know they matter and that what they’re learning will help them succeed once they graduate.
They have to be engaged, and unfortunately, too many aren’t, especially at the secondary level, according to a recent study by the Walton Foundation and Gallup. Employees who quietly quit can be compelled to fulfill their job responsibilities. While inspiration is a preferable strategy, accountability can spur action. For students, however, it’s not so easy.
Students who disengage from school need a reason to return. They not only have to come through the schoolhouse door; they have to want to stay. For that to happen, we need a comprehensive approach to increasing student engagement and a sense of belonging.
Studies on school belonging have found that students who are engaged in school and feel that they belong there are more likely to succeed academically and in life. Some students are intrinsically motivated and will show up and fulfill requirements regardless of the instruction they’re receiving. But others need educators and a school who make them feel that they matter.
At CASEL, we’ve focused on this issue for more than 30 years, and we have evidenced-based answers. Recently Dr. Shelley Berman and Dr. Rista Plate of CASEL published a brief that highlights four levers for attendance: developmental relationships, caring classroom and school community, social-emotional competencies and engagement.
In classrooms and schools where there’s a strong sense of belonging and engagement, middle and high school students are more likely to attend. According to a recent study by the UChicago Consortium, attendance is higher in schools where students’ relationships with peers and teachers were stronger and where they find value and meaning in their classes. So yes, we need to get students back into school, but we must also create schools where they want to be.
How do we do that? One place is in the classroom, where teachers play a critical role in forging those sustaining relationships. It can be as simple as greeting students by name at the door and learning about their lives outside of school. It might grow into practices like a “2×10”: two minutes of personal conversation a day for 10 straight days with a student who seems to be slipping away.
Sharing power is another way to strengthen relationships and ensure students feel like it matters that they are in class. For example, teachers can gather students who are experiencing more absences to learn more about why they aren’t engaging, invite students into decision-making around classroom policies and give them classroom leadership roles.
What teachers do on the level of the classroom can be supported and expanded by administrators as they develop structures and policies that foster belonging and engagement. For example, leaders can communicate to staff the importance of relationships and frame attendance as a shared, collective responsibility; we’ve seen in our own data that teachers often underestimate the role they can play in attendance.
Administrators can work to shift from a punitive, deficit-based mindset to one that is supportive and strengths-based. That same lens can be applied to attendance data, as leaders reframe analysis away from “What’s wrong with this student?” to an examination of the school’s or district’s culture, adult-student relationships, or climate.
Perhaps not showing up to school is a canary in the coal mine that portends a much deeper issue facing educators, especially at the middle and high school levels. Young people who are chronically absent are telling us something. Most of them know that school is both a societal and familial expectation. Yet the barriers of attending are too great for them to overcome.
Reminding them of the importance of school, cajoling them to get on the bus and rewarding them for showing up might get them through the door. But to inspire them to overcome those barriers and engage in learning so that they can live a full and productive life takes more. If we want all of our children to thrive, they must know they matter.
—
This story was produced by The 74, a non-profit, independent news organization focused on education in America.
***
If you believe in the work we are doing here at The Good Men Project, please join us as a Premium Member today.
All Premium Members get to view The Good Men Project with NO ADS.
Need more info? A complete list of benefits is here.
Photo credit: unsplash

