
[The Drama of Insignificance is a multi-part, ongoing series. I hope you’ll check out other posts in the series. The series runs in conjunction with the launch of the much-anticipated Human Experience Specialist Certification Course. Become one of the world’s first Human Experience Specialists. Learn more about the program here.]
I wonder if we have sufficiently examined what we mean when we say that we feel insignificant. We use the word as if it describes a single experience, but I suspect that it actually describes a family of experiences that are related but meaningfully different.
A person who feels invisible is not necessarily experiencing the same thing as a person who feels powerless. A person who feels worthless may be suffering from something quite different from a person who feels unappreciated. A person who feels that his life has amounted to nothing may nevertheless be loved, respected, and needed by many people. If we want to understand the drama of insignificance, it may be important to distinguish among these experiences rather than treating them as interchangeable.
Consider the experience of being invisible. A woman may have spent thirty years working in an organization, performing her duties conscientiously, solving problems, helping colleagues, and making herself indispensable. Yet when important decisions are made, nobody consults her. When accomplishments are celebrated, nobody mentions her contribution. When she offers an opinion, the conversation moves on as if she hadn’t spoken. She may know perfectly well that she is competent and valuable. Her difficulty is not that she thinks poorly of herself. Her difficulty is that she appears not to exist in the eyes of the people whose recognition matters to her. She is present, but she is not seen.
Now consider a different experience, that of being powerless. A man may be highly visible, widely respected, and frequently consulted, yet unable to influence the circumstances that matter most to him. Perhaps he is watching a family member make disastrous decisions. Perhaps he is struggling against an institution that refuses to acknowledge an obvious injustice. Perhaps he is a citizen of a country whose political direction frightens him, and he can find no effective way to alter that direction. He is not invisible. People know who he is and may even admire him. But his wishes, judgments, and efforts seem unable to produce consequences. His experience of insignificance arises not from being unseen but from being unable to make anything happen.
There is also the experience of being irrelevant. This may be especially painful for people who have spent much of their lives being useful, influential, or knowledgeable. A professor retires and discovers that nobody particularly wants his opinion about developments in his field. A parent whose children once depended on her for everything discovers that they now make important decisions without consulting her. A skilled professional watches technology render his expertise obsolete. These people may continue to be loved and respected. They may even be financially secure and reasonably content. But something has changed in their relationship to the world. They are no longer necessary in the ways they once were, and they may experience that change as a diminishment of their existence.
Worthlessness is something else again. A person who feels worthless has not merely concluded that other people fail to appreciate him or that his efforts have little effect. He has come to believe that there is something fundamentally deficient about himself. He may regard his failures as evidence of personal inadequacy, his disappointments as deserved, and his inability to achieve what he hoped to achieve as proof that he is somehow less than other people. This is a particularly painful form of self-diminishment because the person has become an active participant in his own humiliation. The world may be treating him harshly, but he is also treating himself harshly, perhaps more harshly than anyone else.
Then there is obscurity, which deserves its own consideration. Most human beings live obscure lives. Their names are unknown outside a small circle, their accomplishments go unrecorded, and their deaths receive little public notice. But obscurity is not necessarily experienced as insignificance. A person may be perfectly happy to live without public recognition, finding sufficient satisfaction in work, relationships, interests, and ordinary pleasures. Another person may experience precisely the same circumstances as an intolerable failure. The difference is not in their objective obscurity, but in what that obscurity means to them. One person regards being unknown as an ordinary feature of existence; another regards it as evidence that existence has somehow cheated him.
We might add the experience of being interchangeable. A worker discovers that the organization to which she has devoted twenty years can replace her in a week. A lover discovers that the person who once declared her indispensable has quickly found someone else. An artist discovers that his work, which he regards as uniquely expressive of his sensibility, resembles the work of thousands of other artists. What wounds these people may not be invisibility, powerlessness, or worthlessness, but the suspicion that there is nothing particularly necessary about their individual existence. They had imagined themselves to be irreplaceable in some important way, and life has informed them otherwise.
These distinctions matter because the experiences call for different responses. The invisible person may need recognition. The powerless person may need some restoration of agency. The person who feels worthless may need to reconsider the judgments he is making about himself. The person who has become irrelevant may need to discover new ways of participating in life. The person who suffers from obscurity may need to examine his expectations of recognition. And the person who feels interchangeable may need to reconsider what makes an individual life distinctive.
We would not expect the same response to be useful in every case, yet we frequently offer people experiencing insignificance some version of the same advice: believe in yourself, appreciate what you have, stop comparing yourself with others, or find something meaningful to do.
There is a further complication. These experiences can coexist, reinforce one another, and become difficult to disentangle. A person who is repeatedly ignored may begin to feel powerless. A person who feels powerless may begin to question his worth. A person who questions his worth may withdraw from activities that once made him feel consequential, thereby becoming more isolated and less visible. What began as a particular disappointment may develop into a much larger conviction that he simply does not count. At that point, the person may no longer remember which experience came first. He knows only that his relationship to the world has become painful and that something essential seems to be missing.
I think we should also distinguish between feeling insignificant and actually being diminished by circumstances. Sometimes people are treated as if they do not count. They are excluded, silenced, exploited, humiliated, or denied opportunities available to others. In such cases, it would be a serious mistake to regard their suffering primarily as a problem of self-esteem or distorted thinking. The person may be perceiving her situation with considerable accuracy. She may not need to think more positively about herself nearly as much as she needs her circumstances to change. A discussion of insignificance that ignores actual power, injustice, and social arrangements risks becoming an exercise in blaming people for injuries they did not create.
Perhaps, then, we should be cautious whenever someone tells us that he feels insignificant. Rather than assuming that we understand what he means, we might ask what kind of insignificance he is experiencing. Does he feel unseen, unheard, ineffective, unwanted, replaceable, unaccomplished, or fundamentally without value? Does he believe that his life has failed to become what it might have become? Does he feel that other people have diminished him, or that life itself has diminished him? These are not merely different ways of describing the same wound. They may point toward different understandings of what has happened and different possibilities for what might happen next.
The drama of insignificance may turn out to be not one drama but many dramas, sometimes occurring simultaneously in the same person. If we can distinguish among them, we may begin to understand why the experience takes so many forms, why it produces such different consequences, and why some people are able to live comfortably with their relative smallness while others find that smallness almost impossible to bear. Before we can understand what people do in response to feeling insignificant, we need to understand what, exactly, they believe has been taken from them.
CONCLUDING PROPOSITION:
Insignificance is not a single experience but a family of experiences—being unseen, unheard, powerless, unwanted, replaceable, or without value—and understanding which wound a person has suffered is essential to understanding what that person needs.
[The Drama of Insignificance is a multi-part, ongoing series. I hope you’ll check out other posts in the series. The series runs in conjunction with the launch of the much-anticipated Human Experience Specialist Certification Course. Become one of the world’s first Human Experience Specialists. Learn more about the program here.]
Enormous From Within, Small From Without
—
