Being a Superhero puts you in one of the biggest spotlights there is. Choose your words carefully.
___
In this video by Digital Spy, Chris Evans and Jeremy Renner are doing an interview and … well … just watch.
So let’s discuss.
First, I’m going to make a point for you that Evans and Renner will ultimately make for themselves. I’m not defending their comments, I’m just covering all the angles.
It has become apparent over the last week or so that a press tour of this size takes its toll on the talent. And with such a rigorous schedule, sometimes there are “slip-ups.” While this isn’t a defense for the comments made, it should be mentioned.
While many people may say to themselves, “All they have to do is talk to press people and shoot, it’s the easiest job ever… ” hold on a tic. A typical schedule for one of these actors can include any number of interviews or appearances between the hours of 6:00AM to 11:30PM at least 6 days a week. This lack of sleep and jump-around schedule affects these guys not just on a physical level but on a mental level. This is because—we need to remember—they are in the middle of a continuous and rigorous work-out and eating schedule for their preparation for upcoming projects. A break in that schedule of any kind, let alone one of this size, can be intensely negative on both their body and mind. So to make a point for you that they will probably make for themselves: “They are being put through a physical and mental ringer and slip-ups happen. We really really regret this particular instance.”
While I can wrap my brain around that truth, what they need to understand is exactly the scale of this unimaginable f*ck-up. Their audience mostly consists of teen and pre-teen kids, who are still molding what is “right and wrong” in their head. As a parent, I’m hugely disappointed that they would forget their ability to influence their young fans and make a crack of this nature.
As a grown up I’m fully aware of these types of sexual jokes, and what kind of camaraderie there may be between the actors themselves, and that “slip-ups” happen. But as a fan of MCU, I’m also disappointed. Marvel is on top of the industry right now. They keep outdoing themselves over and over. But if this particular movie wasn’t being haunted enough by talk about Joss Whedon nearly having a mental breakdown, it’s certainly haunted now. These are not the types of things you say about another person, and then have it be lightly apologized for and packed away. Even if Scarlett, wonder of the earth that she is, says something like, “It’s OK, I forgive them, boys will be boys” etc., it won’t fix anything.
Millions of people will still go see this movie, but the fourth wall is now broken by that little nagging nugget in the back of all our brains that Chris and Jeremy have planted.
The comments were 100% disrespectful, 100% unnecessary, and 100% going to be seen by 100% of your fans.
You colossal f*cking idiots.
While they may also say in their defense, “How do you answer a question like that? Clearly anyone asking a question regarding the sexual nature of a character in the film and her possible relationships aren’t looking for a serious answer, so we did not take it as a serious question,” but that still doesn’t matter. If that really was the case, the answer should have been something like, “She’s an independent and strong character, as is obvious, but the series as made clear that she is also dealing with some emotional issues. It makes sense for here to be with someone that brings a sort of balance.” BOOM. Send ME on the press tour dammit.
In the end, the lesson will be this: Two young, successful, macho, and exhausted guys made a ridiculous and inappropriate comment about a coworker on a global stage. Colossal idiots.
But I’ll tell you what’s good about this: This will bring the conversation of sexualization in the comic book industry that has been creeping in the background into the forefront. We’ve been talking about it for a long time, the fact that we need more strong women in comics, as well as women in comics that aren’t over-sexualized. The conversation has been going strong over the past few months, especially what with the “big-booty” alternate cover of Spider-Girl, and the new Thor series starring a woman. But the one place this conversation has never really gone is into the realm of MCU’s films. Each one has included a strong female character, and never have they let us down.
Until … two of their primary stars called one of those strong female characters a “slut” and a “trick.”
This still needs to be talked about though, and not just in the context of comic books or comic book movies, but in the context of popular culture as a whole. We are growing as a society to be more inclusive and more sensitive, but the fact that in such an advanced period of our history we are still dealing with the ridiculous mindset that one gender dominates the other seriously bothers me, both as a parent, and as a sensible human being.
This will possibly go down as one of the biggest company wide face-palms in history, behind Jake The Snake and The Iron Sheik getting arrested for cocaine together in the 80’s.
In the end, it is unfortunate for Evans and Renner and the series as a whole, but I do believe it will work out for us. The conversation will be had, instead of overlooked, in the context of their film series’ moving forward. All that will be truly hurt is the reputation of two guys who should have known better in the first place.
Upon first draft of this post, a fellow Good Men Project contributor and friend pointed out something many may have missed:
A second layer to this unfortunate onion that a good portion of us have tuned out because of the level of insensitivity right from the start of the interview, Renner also goes on to make a negative comment about the fact that she has a prosthetic leg in light of the interviewer saying that the character will “always be the sidekick, just flirting away with everyone.”
And there it is, in one 3 minute interview they were able to offend both women and the disabled. It’s obvious that both of these Hollywood stars need a lesson in what it means to be discriminated against based on gender or physical appearance. It seems that, while they are both typically nice guys compared to a lot of Hollywood’s darlings, they are still suffering from a case of, “I’m a wealthy, young, physically fit white male,” and it’s OK to make jackass comments about those seen as “lesser.” Exhausted at the time of the interview or not, you’ve got two very big issues sitting on your shoulders right now. And the whole world is watching.
Seriously guys, if you are reading this …*sigh*
Colossal. F*cking. Idiots.
To close, both Evans and Renner issued statements a few hours later in apology, and rightfully so. Here’s hoping that these two offhanded remarks, although offensive, be taken with a grain of inspiration to continue the discussion around these issues as often and as constructively as possible.
A version of this post originally appeared at Dad On The Mic. Reprinted with permission.
Photo provided by Digital Spy



What I find interesting, while perhaps not the exact same thing, is that just a few months ago people were practically tripping over themselves to defend Sarah Silverman saying, “I’m sorry, its a boy.” on the grounds that it was a joke….
The comments were 100% disrespectful, 100% unnecessary, and 100% going to be seen by 100% of your fans. They’re much more likely to be now that the outrage machine of the terminally and needlessly offended brigade has cranked into motion, but taking personal responsibility is never the strong suit of people like that. If the hoohah hadn’t kicked off, this interview would be background noise still. You can’t have it both ways, unless you seriously think all MCU fans will be watching every single preview these guys make in their oh-so-exhausting promo drive. Two young, successful, macho, and exhausted guys… Read more »
Hi, in my opinion, it’s absolutely obvious Jeremy is joking. What it’s bothering me is the comment in this note in the way it would be “proper” for Jeremy should had answered: “She’s an independent and strong character, as is obvious, but the series as made clear that she is also dealing with some emotional issues. It makes sense for here to be with someone that brings a sort of balance”. First, this is the kind of thing that shows macho thinking, why should we suppose she is “dealing with some emotional issues” just for everyone to think of she… Read more »
Sexism, even in a joke, is still sexism.
Okay, they weren’t talking about Scarlett Johansson. They were talking about the character she plays, Black Widow. Had they referred to the actual person, Scarlett, then yes I would expect there to be an apology. However, I’m not going to get bent out of shape over the feelings of a fictional character. Any more than I would expect them to apologize to Robert Downey Jr. if they called Tony Stark an asshole. …And that’s the thing, isn’t it? Had they called Stark an asshole, or a dick, or any other number of names… we wouldn’t be having this conversation, now… Read more »
I completely understand who they were talking about, a fictional character and not the actress herself. And yes, we would be having the same conversation if they referred to Tony Stark as an asshole. The base of the argument of whether or not they should apologize is that (like i mentioned in the comment reply above) there is a time and a place for that sort of loose talk, whether it’s a joke or not, and while in a high profile interview for a Disney/company under scrutiny produced movie is not the time, or the place. Whether we like it… Read more »
I can respect that you would be willing to have that conversation had it been Stark and not Natasha… but can you *honestly* tell me that there would have been this much of a backlash had they been making fun of one of the male characters?
I wouldn’t bet money on it.
Hi, two thoughts on this: 1) I think we can certainly argue whether it was appropriate to make any kind of sex-related joke in an interview for a film that is probably watched by a rather young audience who may or may not necessarily be able to properly interpret such a joke. So, fair enough, we can talk about it being inappropriate in terms of “in what context” it has been said. 2) To criticise the joke in and of itself as being offensive or even a reflection of some outdated views is to completely ignore the subleties of human… Read more »
Here’s the thing: I’ve been a part of a few theater groups in my time, and there is always, between actors, a level of camaraderie and such where comments like this fly around all the time. Usually with the same face, tone, and following laughter as Renner acted in. However, the big difference, it’s a Marvel Comics issue. Like I said above, they’ve already been under some scrutiny about sexualisation and such. Besides the fact they are owned by Disney, the king of “Family”. So considering the circumstances of who they work for and who is listening, they should be… Read more »
I agree. Like I said in my initial comment, I completely agree that this is potentially worthy of criticism. But I wanted to stress the point that IF one were to criticise it, then only on the basis of it being the wrong time and place, just like you suggested, e.g. because this is an interview for a kids/teen movie. My second point was merely that the joke in itself was not problematic. It wasn’t an incident of slut shaming or something, as the original article seemed to suggest. The article said that they “called Black Widow a slut” without… Read more »
Benjamin, a few times you expressed the opinion that there is a time and place where certain “loose” jokes can be made. Can you please tell me when it is okay to make loose jokes and what people it’s okay to make loose jokes about? I really need some examples here because the ambiguousness of your comments leaves alot open to interpretation. When can someone call women sluts and makes jokes about a woman’s supposed “sluttiness”? Even further than that, if it’s okay to make jokes at the expense of a woman’s sexuality, can we also make jokes about men… Read more »