History often arrives quietly, not with fanfare or monuments, but in whispers: a family story passed across generations, a name murmured over a kitchen table, a half-remembered tale waiting for someone to listen. For Luis-Alejandro Dinnella-Borrego, that call was present from childhood. Growing up in Bergen County, New Jersey, he was always conscious of the importance of family and faith. Half Cuban, half Italian, he spent his early years surrounded by grandparents who shared vivid memories of distant lands and turbulent times: his mother’s family had lived through the Cuban Communist Revolution, while the other side hailed from Sicily and southern Italy. Today, he and his wife are raising their two children in Miami, Florida — continuing the very lineage of stories, faith, and memory that shaped him.
“I always had all my grandparents for most of my childhood and adulthood,” he recalls. “I was fascinated by backgrounds — what life was like in pre-revolution Cuba, or the Italian ghetto in New York City. Reflecting on that now, I guess the reason I chose history is that I grew up with all these stories of the past. I am still the genealogist of the family.” Living with these stories made him inclined to study the past in an academic form, and the faith that ran through his family life intertwined seamlessly with his curiosity. “I consider myself a devout Catholic,” he says. “I would either be reading the Bible or a world history book. These two forms, secular and biblical history, shaped the way I view the world. My childhood felt idealized, even enchanted. It was full of love and very dynamic.”
That early formation, faith braided with historical consciousness, set the course for a life of scholarship and service. He received his undergraduate degree at Dartmouth College, pursued graduate studies in history at the University of Virginia and Rutgers University, completed seminary studies in philosophy and theology at Saint John’s Seminary, and continued his theological training at Saint Leo University. He recently completed a Doctor of Ministry in Spirituality at The Catholic University of America.
Mentorship and collaborative learning are central to his philosophy. Between 2017 and 2018, he co-supervised eight student interns to create Local Stories, National Struggle: The Civil War in Appomattox and Lynchburg, a joint exhibit between Lynchburg College students and The American Civil War Museum in Appomattox, Virginia. His scholarship — spanning African American history, Reconstruction, and broader themes in American political and social life — reflects the same commitment to intellectual rigor and moral engagement.
This integrated lens shapes how he approaches the world. Historians often ask what happened and why; theologians explore meaning, purpose, and the moral demands that follow. For Dinnella-Borrego, the tension between historical causality and spiritual understanding is not a problem to resolve but a place of creative encounter. Pope Francis’ idea of “integral ecology,” with its attention to both social and natural worlds, offers him a framework for seeing human beings as embedded in intertwined networks of memory, responsibility, and grace.
Christianity, particularly Roman Catholicism, resists easy political categorization. The gospel of life and the social gospel enrich each other. During the Civil Rights Movement, priests and nuns marched alongside rabbis, Protestant ministers, and Black clergy with Martin Luther King, Jr. Their witness showed that solidarity needn’t depend on shared backgrounds. That balancing act remains urgent today. In an era marked by polarization — what historian Daniel Rodgers called an “age of fracture” — the Church faces pressures from every direction. Liberals may find it too slow to change; conservatives may wish it would preserve more. But Scripture offers another way. “They are not of the world,” Jesus says (John 17:16). St. Paul adds: “Do not be conformed to this world but be transformed by the renewal of your mind” (Romans 12:2). The Church, Dinnella-Borrego believes, must be a countercultural force, shaping society without being shaped by it.
This conviction extends to education. “We need a blend of civic-centered and classical education,” he says. “Humanities, Social Sciences, and STEM must work together to form citizens and leaders.” He values Greek and Roman classics, the Judeo-Christian tradition, and medieval studies, but he is wary of cultural debates that turn learning into a zero-sum contest.
The tension between practical knowledge and intellectual formation is not new. During his doctoral studies at Rutgers, he took a class with Eric Foner, who had been a student of Richard Hofstadter. Hofstadter’s Anti-
The same tension resurfaces today in debates over expertise, higher education, and the rise of artificial intelligence. “Practical experience has long been seen as the real source of learning in America,” he notes. “And now we see this in AI — why consult an expert when a chatbot can give you an answer in minutes?” Higher education, he argues, must reckon honestly with its own shortcomings. “For decades, people were told, ‘Go to college and you’ll get a great job.’ That hasn’t been everyone’s experience.” The solution is not to dismiss practical knowledge or defend academia uncritically, but to see how the nation’s intellectual and spiritual traditions can strengthen each other.
Trust is the foundation. Without it — among educators, leaders, and institutions — skepticism prevails, distorting conversations about what matters most: Humanities or STEM, practical or abstract. Rebuilding trust, he believes, is essential to forming citizens capable of moral reasoning and civic responsibility.
The ethical responsibility of history itself stands at the center of his work. His book The Risen Phoenix traces the political lives of six African American congressmen — John Mercer Langston, James Thomas Rapier, Robert Smalls, John Roy Lynch, Josiah Thomas Walls, and George Henry White — who served between the Civil War and the dawn of the twentieth century. Drawing on political history, gender history, Black history, and U.S. foreign relations, the book argues that these leaders navigated a hostile postwar South while effectively serving their communities.
Reflecting on their legacy today, he observes, “If Langston and the others were alive now, facing the current political and social landscape, they would be at the forefront defending voting rights and civil equality.” Debates about a “second reconstruction,” ongoing court battles over the Voting Rights Act, and attempts to limit federal oversight reveal how fragile democratic rights remain. “Political rights alone are insufficient,” he notes. “Without representation and protection in the social sphere, equality is hollow.”
The stakes extend to public memory itself. “Five or ten years ago we were debating how we interpret the Civil War,” he says. “We cannot separate the way we celebrate the war from how we remember Reconstruction.” Confederate monuments, largely built during Jim Crow, projected a narrative that sought to delegitimize Reconstruction. “If we preserve them, we must also honor those who fought for emancipation.” Monuments to Black congressmen tell a different story — one of civic duty and moral courage. For Dinnella-Borrego, the historian’s task is not neutrality but fidelity: to present competing interpretations honestly, to narrate painful events with integrity, and to foster spaces where genuine dialogue can unfold.
Across archives, classrooms, and the Catholic intellectual tradition, Dinnella-Borrego weaves history and faith into a shared vision for civic life. He challenges us to engage stories fully, confront complexity honestly, and cultivate courage in our own lives. In a moment marked by fracture and waning trust, he reminds readers that the work of history, the call of faith, and the pursuit of justice are inseparable. Moral imagination, he shows, is both a guide and an invitation, to wrestle with truth, honor complexity, and discern God’s presence in the world we inherit and the society we are called to build.
—
If you believe in the work we are doing here at The Good Men Project, please join us as a Premium Member today.
All Premium Members get to view The Good Men Project with NO ADS.
Need more info? A complete list of benefits is here.
Photo credit: iStock
