
In 2018, after a men’s retreat on #MeToo, I began publishing essays urging a transformative men’s movement—one that would challenge and overturn our dominance-based culture of masculinity. I saw that men needed to learn from the women’s movement, but the moment was not ripe for large-scale organizing: consensus was missing that men were both victims and perpetrators of a crisis. Now, our collective grasp of these issues has deepened—and the urgent need for such a movement is clearer than ever.
In 2023, I spent a day in Atlanta walking in the footsteps of John Lewis and Martin Luther King Jr. I toured Sweet Auburn, passed by the Southern Christian Leadership Conference headquarters, the Atlanta Breakfast Club, and visited Ebenezer Baptist Church. With a local expert, I learned how black and white leaders—Democrats and Republicans—worked together in the 1960s and 70s to make Atlanta an economic engine. As I absorbed these lessons, I reflected on how we might also learn from John Lewis, a Democrat, and Amo Houghton, a Republican known for his integrity and bipartisanship. They, too, had demonstrated a crucial collaboration that we need today. This experience reaffirmed my vision for a men’s movement that transcends race, gender, orientation, and politics to dismantle Man Box Culture for everyone’s benefit.
A few weeks ago, I joined a Faith & Politics pilgrimage to Charleston to learn more about the city’s role in the civil rights movement. Although I thought I knew this chapter of our history, I realized there were many more lessons to grasp. Nearly half of all enslaved people entered America through Charleston. Many were chosen for their skills in cotton, rice, and indigo—skills white landowners lacked. I was reminded of Judge Julius Waties Waring, whose bold decisions paved the way for Brown v. Board of Education. I also learned the anthem “We Shall Overcome” began as “I’ll Overcome Someday,” first sung by 900 black women in a tobacco warehouse.
As I toured the International African American Museum before dinner on the final night of our pilgrimage, the scattershot of information that I had assembled over the decades began to fall into place. I finally put together all the missing pieces I was gathering using the museum’s timeline, which was exactly for that purpose. A renewed, integrated sense of reverence for the grit, resilience, and courage of the individuals who have risen above our system of oppression overwhelmed me.
Then, the scale of this movement struck me. I began to think about others who face similar obstacles in society: ethnic minorities, Indigenous people, LGBTQ individuals, and women.
My head spun with pain and trauma. The anger and frustration were intense. I felt disappointed that, for so many, the American Dream was an empty promise. For too many, it remains out of reach.
Then a final realization hit me, and I nearly sank to my knees. We now live in a country where a majority of people feel there are structural hurdles to their own thriving, as institutions and economic forces beyond their control continue to consolidate power and wealth in the hands of a mighty few. And further, young men, feeling displaced and battered by these forces, have gravitated to the “strongmen” at the apex of our dominance-based culture of masculinity that they believe have the power to solve this problem but are not. Indeed, it is this group of men and women of great power and wealth who now threaten all except their own, the 1% at the top.
This epiphany was confirmed by Jon Meacham in his remarks over dinner later that evening. In his view, our Constitution was designed to enable disagreement, debate, and sometimes even fierce fights, but at the end of the day, the Founders expected that all parties would come together and govern as a united whole. They never intended to create a structure where winners assume sole power and control. That is the danger that we are in now. The people who govern want to hold and exercise power on their own, without contending with opposition or the checks and balances the framers of the Constitution put in place to protect us from our own worst behaviors.
As our diverse, bipartisan group left for Charleston International Airport with help from local authorities, I reflected more on the leadership of John Lewis and Amo Houghton. Despite different backgrounds and political beliefs, both served the greater good through principled bipartisanship. Their legacies urge us to champion collaboration and protect our democracy, the rule of law, and the promise of life, liberty, and happiness.
We are the lucky ones. We have somehow navigated the system so that we are on this caravan of buses (literally and figuratively), but aren’t we guilty of collusion if we don’t step up and speak truth to power in this moment? Aren’t we guilty of crimes of omission if we don’t unravel this culture of masculinity that infects not only our economic system but our politics as well?
We must urgently confront our dominance-based culture of masculinity—it damages everyone and undermines our founding national ideals. To truly protect America’s spirit and the principle that all are created equal, a transformative men’s movement must lead the way toward a more just and inclusive future.
Mark Grayson
Senior Advisor to The American Road, a Lewis-Houghton Civics and Democracy Initiative at the Library of Congress
Author, Getting Naked: A Field Guide for Men
Founder and Director, Trinity Spiritual Center
https://www.instagram.com/mark_grayson_
https://www.linkedin.com/in/markgrayson/
image courtesy of author
