
We were on the verge of giving up the home we loved, not because we wanted to leave, but because I was afraid of what might happen if we stayed.
Not long ago, I wrote an essay called Trust the Nudge about the times I listened to that quiet internal voice and where it took me. I ended with these words: “But when that quiet voice inside me whispers, I have learned to lean in and listen.”
What happened next did not make me doubt that belief. It made me wonder whether a nudge always points toward the destination we imagine.
Fear began the search
Chris and I were happy in our own home. Nothing was pushing us out. Yet I began thinking more and more about the future: what might happen if one of us eventually needed more help, whether I would cope, and whether I might find myself alone, making difficult decisions.
I love Chris, and I wanted to protect him. Gradually, the idea of a retirement village, with independent living now and aged care nearby if it were ever needed, began to feel less like a possibility and more like an answer.
Fear was certainly what started me looking. But I no longer think fear explains everything that followed.
When the possibility acquired an address
Geelong, Victoria, made the idea tangible. My sister was already there. Peter was there. Through my sister, I had made friends among the women in her village. I could see community, companionship and support, not as promises in a brochure, but as something people were actually living.
Then Henry appeared. He was only two days into his new job when he showed me another villa, around $50,000 less than the one I had been considering. I liked the village. I could imagine us there. The figures seemed manageable enough to keep the possibility alive.
At the time, I thought the signs were leading me to Villa 24 Magnolia Drive. Looking back, I wonder whether they were leading me through it.
Had Henry not appeared, had the villa not been available, had it not been about $50,000 cheaper, I probably would have stopped looking. And I never would have asked all the questions that followed.
The questions the villa made me ask
I applied for Villa 24M, requested documents and began reading them properly. Chris flew to Geelong to inspect it with Peter, my brother-in-law. The inspection began with the two of them driving around looking for Villa 24, because Chris had forgotten the minor detail that it was on Magnolia Drive. A life-changing decision had briefly become a suburban treasure hunt. Apparently, it took two men and quite a bit of driving before either considered the radical idea of asking someone!
I spoke with our financial adviser and sought legal advice. Gradually, I understood that moving would not simply mean selling one home and buying another.
We would be giving up ownership of our home and placing a substantial amount of our capital into a retirement-village arrangement. There would be a weekly fee, significant deferred management fees, and the possibility of delay in recovering our remaining capital if we later wanted to leave. We also had to consider the additional financial burden if one of us eventually needed high care while the other remained in the villa.
The security I had been trying so desperately to create for the future involved giving up some of the security and flexibility we already had.
Perhaps the $50,000 difference wasn’t saying, Here is your villa. Perhaps it was saying, Keep going. There is something here you need to discover.
The question that brought everything into focus
After all my research, Chris distilled everything into one simple question:
“Are we prepared to give away our money as a loan to the village operator and our title to our beautiful home because we are afraid of what the future may bring?”
His words did not make me think I had mistaken fear for the nudge. Fear had started the search. The nudge, I was beginning to realise, may have been leading me through it. His question made me see where the journey had been taking us.
I had followed what seemed like a series of nudges. I had gathered information, tested the possibility and kept going long enough for Chris to ask the question that brought the whole matter into focus.
Had someone told me at the beginning, Don’t move, I am not sure I would have listened. I needed to see the villa. I needed to like it. I needed the figures to work well enough for us to continue. I needed to discover the answer for myself.
Perhaps the Universe works a little like a patient parent. It does not always tell us what to do. Sometimes it simply shows us a path and leaves us to ask the questions and reach the understanding in our own time.
What we could decide later
My brother-in-law Peter is devoted to my sister. He visits her twice a day at her residential care centre and often sits down at the grand piano to play for her and the other residents. He has become a familiar and much-loved figure there.
Peter plays the piano for my sister, Alaine — author video
During one of our conversations, Peter said quite naturally that if Chris ever needed high care, perhaps he could be cared for in the same place as my sister.
“And where am I?” I asked.
Beneath the humour was something deeply reassuring. His comment told me that, if that day ever came, Chris would matter to him too.
I had also met widows at my sister’s village who moved into serviced apartments when their circumstances changed. I realised we didn’t have to move now to prepare for something that might never happen. If the day came when Chris needed that level of care, and a place was available, we could consider it then. I could make my own decisions about where I wanted to live and what would work for both of us.
We did not have to solve tomorrow today.
Seven o’clock, two cups of tea
After weeks of documents, flights, professional advice and imagined futures, Chris and I sat up in our separate beds in two different cities, me in Gosford and Chris in Geelong, at seven in the morning, each holding a cup of tea.
After almost sixty years together, here we were, discussing another enormous decision in the most ordinary way, during one of our morning tea talks before the day began.
This time, we arrived at the same place.
We were not moving.
Not because the village was bad. Not because anything dramatic had happened. We realised how happy we already were in our home. We owned it, kept our financial flexibility, and still had options for the future. There was no reason to surrender today’s security out of fear of tomorrow’s uncertainty.
Earlier that morning, Chris had telephoned Henry to tell him we would not be proceeding with the villa. Later, when Chris arrived to visit my sister, he happened to see Henry arriving at the office. Henry invited him in for a cup of tea. During the inspection the day before, Henry had been unusually quiet. He had shown Chris around and done his job. But over their cuppa that morning, he seemed brighter and much more communicative.
Chris left with the curious impression that Henry was almost pleased for us. Maybe he was. Maybe he wasn’t. I don’t know what Henry was thinking, and I wouldn’t pretend to. But somehow that small encounter felt like one last gentle reassurance.
Where the nudge had led
Yesterday, I thought the journey had ended when Chris and I decided not to move. This morning, thinking again of those two cups of tea in Gosford and Geelong, I began to see it differently.
I still cannot explain the coincidences that kept the possibility alive. I do not know whether Henry, Villa 24M or the $50,000 difference were arranged for any purpose at all. I only know that without them I might not have travelled far enough down that path to discover what I really needed to know.
Perhaps a nudge does not always lead us where we expect. Sometimes it takes us towards a place not because we are meant to remain there, but because the journey itself will reveal what we could not have understood from the beginning.
I had thought the nudge meant go.
Now I wondered whether it had been leading us all along, not towards a new home, but towards clarity.
It had taken us past Villa 24 Magnolia Drive.
And brought us home to the answer.
—
This post was previously published on Infinite Impulse.
***
You may also like these posts on The Good Men Project:
White Fragility: Talking to White People About Racism |
Escape the “Act Like a Man” Box |
The Lack of Gentle Platonic Touch in Men’s Lives is a Killer |
![]() |
If you believe in the work we are doing here at The Good Men Project, please join us as a Premium Member today.
All Premium Members get to view The Good Men Project with NO ADS.
Need more info? A complete list of benefits is here.
Photo credit: iStock
White Fragility: Talking to White People About Racism
Escape the “Act Like a Man” Box
The Lack of Gentle Platonic Touch in Men’s Lives is a Killer

