
Anti-intellectualism has a long history in America. That said (and provided that one has at least attained the lofty perch of middle school), even those who spurn the often smug narratives of academics ought to be capable of reading words on a page and ascertaining their underlying meaning.
To wit, words like these, which aren’t particularly complicated:
Congress shall make no law…abridging the freedom of speech…
These are the ten simple words regarding freedom of expression, located in the First Amendment to the Constitution. They are clear and relatively unambiguous, if not regarding the precise speech that is allowed or disallowed (more about that in Part II), at least concerning which entities are prohibited from disallowing it.
And yet, lately it has become commonplace for some, despite having long since cleared the middle school hurdle referenced above, to argue that Twitter and Facebook — pro tip: both private companies — are violating the “free speech” of conservatives by supposedly using algorithms to limit their reach, or suspending them for comments deemed hateful, in violation of community standards.
Or that YouTube — also a private company — is violating the rights of conspiracy theorist and walking aneurysm, Alex Jones, by removing certain of his videos considered especially egregious in their display of slanderous and bigoted wingnuttery.
Or that the refusal of web servers (yep, private) to play host to neo-Nazi Andrew Anglin’s online orgy of hatred, which has forced his Daily Stormer site to the dark web, is an untoward restriction of free expression.
Or that ABC’s decision to stop lining the pockets of a woefully under-medicated racist like Roseanne Barr is somehow tantamount to an assault on the rights and liberties of Trump supporters.
I’ve even been accused of censorship and violations of “free speech” by some for making the decision several years ago to shut down comments on my own website because I was tired of having to sift through the violent and sexually explicit threats regularly made against my family. So too when I block trolls on my social media pages for inviting me to “get in an oven.”
All of this because people apparently think that their right to say whatever comes into their desiccated brains obligates others to open up their private online homes for the spewing of such nonsense.
Or that the right to belch hatred entitles the bigot to the ears of others, or to someone else’s megabytes of bandwidth, or an audience purchased with someone else’s money, and that any attempt to limit bigoted commentary — even if imposing such a limit is a way of expressing your opinion, on your platform — amounts to leftist authoritarianism.
Even pushing back on hateful speech and calling it hateful, or morally condemning those who engage in such vituperative discourse — calling racism racism, or misogyny misogyny for instance — is criticized by some. To these confused souls, public condemnation of another person’s bigotry is not itself an act of free speech, but rather a censorious move, which doesn’t adequately respect the bigot’s right to be a bigot, unsullied by the criticism of others.
Free speech, on this account means consequence-free speech. Racists have a right to racist, and for anyone to talk back is oppression.
In the words of a famous philosopher whose name escapes me: Yeah, nah.
Free speech entitles you to remain un-jailed, un-tortured and alive even when you demonstrate your ignorant fuckery. Other than that? Pretty much nothing.
Specifically, here’s what it doesn’t mean.
It doesn’t mean anyone is obligated to provide you with the means for getting your views heard.
No one owes you a microphone, column inches in their newspaper or a podium at their college (I’ll have more to say about the issue of speakers on campuses in Part IV).
Feel free to print your own newsletter, or stand on a corner and pontificate to your heart’s delight to any who pass. Knock yourself out sending around chain e-mails that “prove” the moon landing was fake, or opine that the planes we all saw fly into the twin towers were really just 3-D holograms, or stupidly bleat that vaccines cause autism and that humans rode on the backs of dinosaurs.
Just don’t insist that a radio station, writer’s syndication service or publishing house has to extend a contract to you for the dissemination of such quackery, or that when they opt not to, that you’ve been the victim of an injustice.
Free speech also doesn’t protect you from losing your job.
Unless you have a specifically-negotiated union contract that requires a clear performance-related rationale for termination, your First Amendment rights mean very little when it comes to your place of employment. And even with a union contract — for instance, as a police officer or teacher— racist speech might well result in your being canned (as well it should), since a case could be made that such biases would likely impact your ability to perform your job equitably in those kinds of positions, thereby violating the rights of others.
In general, within the workplace, it should be obvious (though it isn’t to some) that free speech is not really a thing. After all, you cannot insult your boss and expect to continue collecting a paycheck from them. As for political speech, whether or not said boss should limit their employee base to Democrats or Republicans, for instance (neither a very smart move, given that doing so would cut their available labor pool roughly in half), there is little doubt, legally, that they could do so.
Fired for posting racist shit on your Facebook page? Or for being videotaped calling police on black people for no good reason? Check. Your boss can do it, and you are not a victim of anything but your own behaviors when they do.
And morally, it seems fair to conclude that an employer who was, say, Jewish, is under no obligation to keep a Hitler-loving skinhead on the payroll for the sake of liberty. As for what happens if no employer (Jewish or otherwise) is willing to employ Nazis? There’s an easy solution: don’t be a Nazi. Or form your own business along with some of your master-race friends inbetween chugging beer, posting on 4chan and asking your mom to make you another Hot Pocket.
. . .
But perhaps it’s no surprise that Americans don’t understand the issue of free speech or even constitutional liberties in general. After all, a survey in 2006 found that Americans were twice as likely to be able to name at least two characters from The Simpsons as they were to be able to name at least two of the five freedoms enshrined in the First Amendment. In fact, while 22 percent of Americans could name all five members of the Simpson family, only 1 in 1000 (that’s one-tenth of one percent) could name all five First Amendment liberties.
Oh, and this: according to the same survey, one in five actually believed that the First Amendment guarantees the right to own and raise pets as well as to drive a car. Reflect on that: the right to drive a car…in the late 1780s.
As a side note, and since the right to vote isn’t actually enshrined in the Constitution per se (although the document prohibits limiting access to the franchise on the basis of race, sex or age for those over 18), let me suggest that anyone believing in the right to own pets or drive should be summarily banned from casting a ballot for anything ever again.
Like, even in their high school student council election.
Or for the Major League Baseball All-Star Game.
Or America’s Got Talent.
And since we’re on the subject of restricting the right to vote for people who believe ridiculous things, I’d also make a pitch for the nearly half of Trump voters who think it “probably or definitely true” that Hillary Clinton was helping to run a child sex slave ring from the non-existent basement of a D.C. pizza parlor. Or that Barack Obama was born in Kenya: also believed by at least half of Trump supporters; or that Sandy Hook was a hoax and the grieving families one sees on television in the wake of mass shootings are really just crisis actors, hoping to whip up sympathy for a nationwide gun confiscation scheme.
Oh, and in a perfect world, we most assuredly would find some way to deny the franchise to those who think the online meanderings of “Q” represent revelatory exposures of “deep state globalism,” ritualistic pedophilia, and the president’s secret plan to crush the enemies of liberty: a theory increasingly prominent among Trump’s base, as evident at his recent rallies in Tampa and Wilkes-Barre, PA.
Actually, I’m kidding. I’m fully aware that when we start advocating even the most basic literacy or mental capacity tests for voters we head down a road that almost always works to the detriment of the least powerful people in society, regardless of their intelligence. So I don’t actually think the Q-Tips and Trump cultists should be banned from the voting booth.
But so long as mouth-breathing dullards such as these are allowed to participate in the electoral process, I definitely don’t want to hear another word about how undocumented immigrants are casting illegitimate ballots. First, because it’s not true, and second, because I’d bet most such persons know more about the country they’re trying to become a part of — and are more in touch with reality — than at least half of the Trump supporters who’ve been here their entire lives.
. . .
As for the issue of free speech and the apparent inability of so many to grasp what it does and doesn’t mean, at the risk of sounding like the somewhat grizzled and occasionally-cynical middle-aged man that I am, let me say: Perhaps it’s the fault of the internet.
For those of us who grew up at a time when being heard took more effort than banging out 140 characters and hitting “send,” or pushing the record button on a phone cam and uploading 10 seconds of deep thoughts on Snapchat, the idea of feeling entitled to spread your views seems preposterous. Except for those who held forth on AM radio, the notion that you could be taken seriously pontificating about things you’d never actually studied would have struck us as fanciful.
In those days you could write an article or letter to the editor of your local paper, send it in, and then hope that it might get published. Or you could call into a radio program or produce a low-budget public access TV show, seen by 37 people with insomnia (and no Ambien yet to help them through it). Or you could try any number of other media-attracting tricks to get someone to pay attention to your views. But at no time would you have felt oppressed by the unwillingness of someone else to amplify your ideas to the world.
The internet — which can prove to be a wonderful tool, providing us with access to information in ways we couldn’t have imagined thirty years ago — has also reinforced the “look at me, listen to me,” hyper-individualistic mentality of modern western culture. Which is no doubt why misanthropic libertarians have such an outsized influence within cyberspace — and much more so than their numbers in real life would predict.
On the web, everyone can carve out their own little intellectual fiefdom, without regard for others (except as audience members, clicks, likes, shares, upvotes, and retweets). We create one-word hashtags and memes (the cyber-equivalent of a children’s picture book compared to, say, a novel) and think of them as profound arguments.
The internet tells us all we can be our own expert, on anything from tax policy to the situation in Syria to immigration to what the sharp pains in our right side mean.
As for the first three, or other political topics, there is no longer a need to weigh the words of those who have spent their lives studying those issues. After all, what do they know that I can’t discover with a few minutes spent on Wikipedia? As for the latter, why trust someone who went to medical school when I can consult a Reddit thread and know, thanks to the insights of KombuchaKatie411 or ChiaSeedCharlie, the name of the horrible disease from which I’m suffering?
Because we now can access information so quickly — and have become able to do so far more rapidly than we’ve learned how to use that information or think critically about it — we feel duty-bound to share what we’ve learned, even if it’s bullshit. What’s more, we feel entitled to tell everyone our personal opinions about things, even if we haven’t done our homework at all, just because doing so is incredibly easy, and fast.
Today, we live in an era where even teenagers can amass followings (and fortunes) on social media platforms, and become famous for sharing makeup tips or pulling pranks on people among other vital endeavors. In such a world as this, it is hardly shocking that some might come to think they had a right not only to an opinion but an actual right to be heard.
How precious.
How utterly adorable.
How completely, ineluctably wrong.
In moments like this, perhaps we would do well to ponder the words of an old friend of mine, who put it thusly:
Just because speech is free, doesn’t mean that it has to be worthless.
. . .
In part two, I’ll explore what free speech is, legally speaking. What speech is protected, what speech is not, and why does it matter? Understanding the state of existing jurisprudence will help us determine — at least from a legal perspective — what kinds of limitations on free expression might be permissible, even in the public sphere. And, importantly, which types of restrictions are, at present, impermissible.
In part three, I will examine the philosophical and practical limitations of the First Amendment absolutist position, as well as some of the arguments made by those who would restrict so-called hate speech. Both sides of the debate put forward nice-sounding slogans, but they both also ignore the way that social power dynamics make an entirely hands-off approach or one that seeks to impose certain types of content-based restrictions unworkable or illogical.
And finally, in part four, I will explore the issue of colleges and universities, and whether or not they should be obligated to allow any and all speakers to make presentations on their campuses. Are there differences between public and private institutions in this regard? Should there be? And are there legitimate reasons for schools to say no to particular speakers, on academic and scholarly grounds, if not purely political ones?
—
I’m an antiracism educator/author. I Facebook & tweet @timjacobwise, podcast at Speak Out With Tim Wise & post bonus content at patreon.com/speakoutwithtimwise
—
This post was previously published on Medium and is republished here with permission from the author.
—
◊ ◊
Have you read the original anthology that was the catalyst for The Good Men Project? Buy here: The Good Men Project: Real Stories from the Front Lines of Modern Manhood
◊ ◊
Talk to you soon.
If you believe in the work we are doing here at The Good Men Project and want to join our calls on a regular basis, please join us as a Premium Member, today.
All Premium Members get to view The Good Men Project with NO ADS.
Need more info? A complete list of benefits is here.
—
Photo credit: iStock
