I Slept With My Best Friend’s Boyfriend. She Still Doesn’t Know

It happened the night after I turned 20. A night that feels like a blur until one moment that won’t leave gets burned into your memory. Music, cheap wine, people conversing loudly over one another — chaos so brimming with celebration. I was surrounded by people who loved me, and I still felt so alone.

She — my best friend — threw the whole thing for me. She had planned it for weeks, baked a cake herself, hung streamers and candles and flowers in her apartment. She did it because she genuinely cared. I knew that. Everyone knew that.

Including her boyfriend.

He’d always been around, obviously. I’d never considered there was more to him than her. But then there were moments — small ones, the kind you brush off because they add up — when it felt like he saw me differently.

Not in a weird, creepy way. In quiet ways. Such as remembering things I mentioned in passing. Asking how I really was when everyone else just said “you good?” and moved on.

She overdid the drinking and passed out early that night. The crowd slowly thinned. I was on the couch, shoes off, drinking water, attempting to fend off a thousand thoughts. That was when he sat down next to me.

He asked if I was okay. Not the chitchat kind of how-are-you; I mean the kind of really-how-are-you that breaks you open.

I hadn’t said anything to anyone, but a few weeks before I had gone through something that had left me hollow. I lost someone in my family — someone I was really close to. It wasn’t a one-night stand or moment of poor judgment — it came after a short-lived romance that was nice until I let down my guard.

He disappeared. I didn’t tell my family. Not even my best friend. I just sucked it up, on the down low, like I always do. I clean up my own mess.

That night, on that couch, I didn’t feel that I had to pretend. I didn’t even mouth the words — I didn’t have to. He glanced at me as if he already knew I was carrying something weighty. And, for the first time in weeks, for I don’t remember how many weeks, I did not feel invisible.

I don’t know how it happened. There was no plan. No intention. Only silence and closeness and too many emotions I had not unpacked. I cried, and he held me, and something inside of me burst open. I wanted comfort. I needed to feel okay, if only for a little while. I just needed someone to see me and not turn away.

It wasn’t passionate. It wasn’t romantic. It was desperate and mistaken and real.

I barely slept. When I woke up the next morning, I could not face myself in the mirror. All I could hear was her laughter in my brain. Recalling the countless instances when she told me, “I trust you more than anyone.”

I haven’t told her. I don’t know how. When I attempt to, they catch in my throat like glass. I am sitting across from her, and I think, If you knew what I did, you would never speak to me again.

We never discussed it, he and I. We just kept going like it didn’t happen. And perhaps that’s how he deals with guilt — by making believe. For me, it’s different. It’s sitting in my chest right now, heavy and sharp, always there; it tells me what I did and what it meant.

I have been hating myself for that night for so long. Telling myself I’m a terrible person. Then justifying it by saying I was vulnerable, heartbroken, alone. Both things are true. I didn’t do it to hurt her. I did it because I was drowning and he was the only one who noticed.

But that doesn’t make it okay.

This is not a confession designed to make myself feel better. It is not some perverse form of closure. It’s just the truth. The messy, awful, complicated truth.

If she learns that someday, I will not try to justify it. I’ll let her leave. I’ll let her hate me. Because I kind of already do.

—

This post was previously published on medium.com.