Pumpkin Grilled Cheese With Sage and Hot Honey

—

My pumpkin grilled cheese layers a lightly spiced pumpkin purée with sharp cheddar and fresh sage between two golden, buttery slices of bread, finished with a drizzle of hot honey right before serving. It comes together in one skillet in just about 15 minutes!

Why Pumpkin Belongs in a Grilled Cheese

I’ve been on a real grilled cheese kick lately. As a lifelong vegetarian, grilled cheese has always been a comfort food staple in my life, and I’m constantly playing around with what goes inside one. I’ve already shared my kimchi grilled cheese, my apple grilled cheese, and my jalapeño grilled cheese, and I finally decided it was time to start sharing more of these additions here on the blog.

This one might be my favorite twist yet. Pumpkin as a savory ingredient doesn’t get nearly enough credit. Mixed with Dijon, garlic powder, and a little smoked paprika, it turns into something closer to a spiced spread than a “pumpkin” flavor, and it complements the sharp cheddar, the mustard’s tang, and the hot honey’s kick perfectly. This one is going to be on repeat in my kitchen all fall.

Enjoy!

~Kristen

A hand holds a pumpkin grilled cheese sandwich with melted cheese and herbs, with another sandwich half on a clear glass plate in the background.

Key Ingredients

A few quick notes on the ingredients that matter most. Find the full ingredient list and instructions in the recipe card below.

Pumpkin purée: Use plain purée, not pumpkin pie filling, which is already sweetened and spiced and will throw off the balance here.
Bread: A sturdier, sandwich-style loaf works best, as very soft or thin slices may fall apart once the pumpkin layer is added. Gluten-free bread can absolutely be used. I use Schär Gluten-Free Sourdough Deli-Style Bread myself!

Two pumpkin grilled cheese sandwich halves stacked on a clear glass plate, with melted cheese and savory pumpkin filling oozing out and pooling onto the plate.

Tips for Getting This Grilled Cheese Right

Keep the pumpkin layer thin. A thick layer traps moisture against the bread and makes it soggy instead of crisp.
Cook low and slow. Medium-low heat gives the cheese time to fully melt before the bread over-browns.
If the bread is browning faster than the cheese is melting, cover the skillet for 30 to 60 seconds to trap heat and speed up the melt without scorching the crust.
Want more heat? Add a pinch of red pepper flakes directly into the pumpkin mixture before spreading.

Pumpkin grilled cheese sandwich cut in half and stacked on a clear plate, with melted cheese and chili oil dripping onto the plate.

What to Serve With Pumpkin Grilled Cheese

Serve alongside a bowl of my Jamaican pumpkin soup or vegetarian French onion soup for dunking.
Pair it with a simple arugula salad to cut through the richness of the cheese and butter.
Dip it into my tofu ranch dip for a cooling, herby contrast to the hot honey.
Enjoy it on its own with a mug of warm apple cider for a fall lunch!