Editor’s note: This information is provided for educational purposes only and is not meant to diagnose or treat any condition.
One point two BILLION dollars. That’s what the fish oil industry is worth each year in the US alone. $1.2 billion.
But does fish oil actually help with issues such as heart disease or weight loss?
Considering that in developed countries men are more likely to be overweight and have heart disease, this is an important question.
This article looks at 8 of the most popular health claims surrounding fish oil to uncover the truth.
What does fish oil do?
Fish oil supplements are made from fats (oils) of fatty fish species like salmon, sardines and mackerel.
The fats in these fish are mostly omega-3 fats, which play a vital role in brain function, cell growth and inflammation. These fats cannot be made by our bodies, so it’s essential we get them from food.
EPA and DHA are able to influence our health primarily through signalling compounds, known as eicosanoids. These compounds are produced in response to cellular stress and help combat harmful inflammation.
Long term stress and inflammation is a driver behind many of today’s physical and mental health burdens, which is why the benefits of fish oil pills are so widespread.
Summary: Fish oil is a concentrated source of healthy omega-3 fats, which play a vital role in our brain function and inflammation. It works by helping to relieve stress and harmful inflammation that occurs in our cells.1. Fish oil improves symptoms of depression
1. Fish oil improves symptoms of depression
Depression is now one of the most common mental disorders in the world.
An estimated 16 million US adults experienced at least one major depressive episode in 2012.
A large review of 28 previous studies found that in most cases fish oil, particularly EPA, was helpful in treating depressive symptoms. It appears to be much more effective in those with severe depression vs those with low depressive symptoms (1).
The majority of study participants with severe depression were also being treated with standard anti-depressant medication. This suggests that fish oil could improve the effectiveness of conventional therapy. In fact, treatment response rates increased up to a whopping 30% using combination therapy (2).
Summary: Using fish oil in combination with conventional medication has been shown to greatly reduce depressive symptoms, especially in those with severe depression.
2. Fish oil can lower high blood pressure
One in three (1/3) US adults has high blood pressure, and it is responsible for 1,000 deaths per day in America alone.
That’s why correcting high blood pressure is one of, if not the most important thing you can do to improve your health and lifespan.
The mechanism of effect is still unclear, although there is good reason to believe it’s related to the Omega-6: Omega-3 ratio. It’s thought that the more omega-3 fats in your diet compared to omega-6 fats, the better for your cardiovascular health.
Fish oil provides an affordable and convenient way to improve this ratio, which likely improves blood pressure as a result.
If you’re interested, there are even better ways to lower your blood pressure quickly, without medication.
Summary: Research shows that fish oil is an effective treatment for high blood pressure. It is thought to help by improving our Omega-6: Omega-3 ratio.
3. Fish oil lowers triglycerides and improves HDL
Elevated blood triglyceride levels is a major risk factor for heart disease.
This is a known fact and is not disputed like Total or LDL cholesterol.
Research shows that both EPA and DHA in fish oil reliably help to reduce triglycerides in those with elevated levels, sometimes by as much as 20% (8).
These effects are only seen in long-term supplementation and doses of around 4 grams of fish oil per day, so consistency is key.
Fish oil also appears to notably increase HDL and LDL levels, which are cholesterol markers of heart health. An increase in HDL is good, however, an increase in LDL is undesirable, particularly in those who already have elevated LDL.
If you take a cholesterol-lowering drug or your doctor deems lower triglyceride levels as the most important factor, there are benefits from using fish oil pills.
But if your LDL is elevated and difficult to control then you should speak with your doctor before making changes.
Summary: Regular fish oil supplementation can lower triglycerides by up to 20% in individuals with elevated levels. It can also increase HDL levels but in tandem with increased LDL levels. If you have raised LDL levels you should consult with your doctor first.
4. Fish oil may help prevent or treat arthritis
Arthritis is a form of inflammatory joint disease that tends to occur as we grow older.
Given the anti-inflammatory properties of omega-3 fats, many fish oil supplement brands claim they can prevent or alleviate inflammatory symptoms associated with osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthritis.
Theoretically fish oil could be directly responsible for these effects, however we can’t say for sure until more long-term human trials are undertaken.
Summary: It is thought the anti-inflammatory properties of fish oil are beneficial for treating osteoarthritis and rheumatoid arthritis, however the evidence is not solid.
5. Fish oil can help treat ADHD in children
Attention deficit-hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is the most common neuro-developmental disorder in childhood.
Those with ADHD appear to have deficits in the maturation of the frontal lobe and circuits connecting with other parts of the brain involved in regulating behaviour.
So what does fish oil do to help?
The omega-3 fats in fish oil are thought to play a key role in the early development of these circuits, which is why an insufficiency is quite possibly a risk factor for ADHD and other psychiatric disorders (15).
Researchers analysed ten previous studies involving 699 children and found that fish oil is usually effective in ADHD treatment, particularly varieties rich in EPA (16).
The impact is modest compared to psychostimulants and other regular medications like Adderall, but appear useful when taken alongside those conventional treatments.
Given there are little to no side-effects of fish oil use, it makes sense to try them out. Interestingly, plant-based omega-3 supplements appear to have no effect on ADHD symptoms (17).
Summary: Studies show the benefits of fish oil pills, particularly those high in EPA, extend to ADHD treatment in children. It seems most effective when used alongside conventional medication.
6. Fish oil during pregnancy
Due to the important link between omega-3 fats (specifically DHA) and brain development, adequate intake during pregnancy is crucial for the fetus.
The problem is that most fish species are also rich in the mineral mercury. Excessive mercury exposure during pregnancy – among other things – is linked with both pregnancy complications and developmental issues in infants (18).
Fortunately most fish oil pills and liquids are considered a safe, mercury-free source of DHA for expecting mothers. Pregnant women should go for at least 200 mg of DHA daily.
Just be sure to look for labels that confirm the product is low in mercury.
Summary: Mercury is thought to be harmful for the child when pregnant. Regular fatty fish species are rich in mercury, whereas most brands of fish oil are not. This makes fish oil a good alternative during pregnancy.
7. Fish oil does not appear to help treat acne
Acne is a complex inflammatory skin condition that is much more common in Westernised societies than others (19).
Many experts believe this is due to the low omega-3 intake (and perhaps high omega-6 intake) of most Western diets. Omega-3 fats are said to inhibit mediators responsible for most inflammatory acne lesions (pimples) (20).
But does that mean fish oil is good for your skin?
The one trial looking at the effects of fish oil and acne contained only 13 subjects. After twelve weeks, there was no significant improvements seen with fish oil treatment (930 mg EPA). Eight subjects saw improvements, yet four subjects got worse (23).
There is no doubt that diet influences acne occurrence and severity, but the reported benefits of fish oil pills needs to be studied further.
Summary: In theory omega-3 fats like fish oil could help treat acne, but current research shows no consistent improvements.
8. Fish oil does not aid in weight loss
Given the anti-inflammatory effects of fish oil, some researchers have proposed it may positively influence fat metabolism and therefore weight loss as well.
But studies on obese individuals have found it has little to no direct positive influences on weight management. Its effects seem to be completely dependent on other weight loss interventions like exercise and reducing calories (26, 27, 28, 29, 30).
In other words, fish oil may help slightly if you are also eating fewer calories and exercising regularly, but it does not have an inherent weight loss effect on its own.
You may be better off considering the probiotic Lactobacillus gasseri.
Summary: The benefits fish oil has on weight loss only occur with caloric restriction or increased exercise. It has barely any notable weight loss effect on its own.
How much fish oil should I take per day?
Optimal fish oil dosage depends on your reason for use.
For general health improvements, at least 1 gram per day is recommended, but I’d go for at least 2 grams. Most fish oil pills are 1-2 grams per pill anyways.
If you plan on taking more than 3 grams per day, consult with your doctor first.
Note that these doses refer to total fish oil, which is a combination of both EPA and DHA. The product label states how much of each omega-3 fat is contained within the pill itself.
If your goal of supplementation is to lower blood pressure or triglycerides, then 2-3 grams of (total) fish oil per day is recommended. For depressive symptoms, a fish oil supplement with at least 1000 mg of EPA appears most effective, while for ADHD it should contain at least 450 mg of EPA.
You can take fish oil pills at any time of the day, but it’s best with meals in order to minimise bloatingand “fish burps”.
Summary: Take 1-2 grams per day for general health, but don’t go over 3 grams without asking your doctor first. For depression and ADHD, choose fish oil doses that contain at least 1000 mg and 450 mg of EPA, respectively.
Wrapping it up
Even if it can’t live up to all the hype, it’s pretty clear what fish oil is good for and why it’s so popular.
There is strong evidence supporting its benefits on cardiovascular and mental health conditions, with little to no side-effects or risks.
The same cannot be said for weight loss and acne, however, with very underwhelming results.
For those who don’t consume fatty fish regularly, fish oil will very likely improve your health, especially into old age.
It’s easily the most inexpensive and safest way to meet your omega-3 requirements too.
Photo credit: Pixabay