A Moment That Can Kill Attraction
Modern dating can leave you feeling hopeless. It’s endless scrolling, swiping, ghosting, rejection, and heightened egos when no one wants to get caught giving more than the other person.
But then something seemingly amazing happens. You meet someone you actually like—maybe after years or even decades of trying—and they reciprocate some of that interest too.
Suddenly, the stakes feel incredibly high.
And this moment—that seems rare, incredible, and like everything you’ve been hoping for—actually becomes the most dangerous moment in dating. It has the highest potential to kill attraction.
We go from being ourselves to feeling like we need that person to like us too. We lose our standards and boundaries, and suddenly we act in ways that feel completely unnatural.
Our brain decides they are the prize and we are working to attain them. And when you position someone that way in your mind, you give away your agency and your power without realizing it.
–
Here is a summary of the transcript from YouTube, slightly edited with AI.
Our Instincts Can Be Misguided
Now we know why this moment is dangerous. Let’s talk about what we can actually do about it.
For those of you who are new here, I’m Matthew Hussey. I’ve been a love life coach for almost 20 years. I’ve helped hundreds of thousands of people navigate challenges through my coaching programs and have written two New York Times bestselling books.
On this channel, I help people build better relationships with others, with themselves, and with life itself.
Part of what makes this moment so dangerous is that it happens subconsciously. We’re often unaware of how sneakily this natural urge to impress and win someone over takes hold.
As I’ve said many times before, our instincts can sometimes guide us in the wrong direction.
Despite all the advice out there telling us to follow our hearts, dating becomes especially difficult because we have an attachment to the outcome. We both want and need love.
That doesn’t mean we can’t be happy without it. But if we’re dating, we’re usually hoping to find something meaningful—and that desire can cloud our judgment.
We start acting in ways we would never advise our friends to act. We lose objectivity.
We may criticize every move someone makes as if it’s life or death. They don’t text back immediately and suddenly we think they’re awful or ghosting us.
Maybe we want revenge. Maybe we decide to ghost them back. Meanwhile, they may simply be busy or just not a great texter—neither of which necessarily says anything about how they feel about you.
Or we become too proactive, constantly reaching out and trying to set up plans with someone who hasn’t shown equal enthusiasm.
Do You Feel Discouraged in Dating?
If you’ve been single for a long time, you might feel hopeless about dating. That creates two big risks.
The first is giving up entirely—and in doing so, potentially wasting your opportunity for connection and love.
But there’s another risk people don’t see coming: you actually meet someone you really like.
And when they show even a small amount of interest back, hopelessness quickly transforms into desperation and obsession.
Suddenly you think, “Oh my God, this is a shooting-star moment. I have to hold onto this with both hands.”
Now you stop being yourself. You act irrationally. You act insecurely. And from that place of obsession, you risk pushing away the very person who may have been right for you.
Hopelessness vs. Obsession
And if you do push them away, obsession can become story.
You create a narrative about how amazing they were and how perfect that situation could have been.
You tell yourself you’ll never get over them.
Eventually that story starts to feel true—not because they were extraordinary, but because repetition creates belief.
Then every new person you meet gets compared to someone you barely knew and a relationship that never actually happened.
Hopelessness risks wasting your potential.
Obsession risks wasting your life.
Hopelessness and obsession are often the same person at different points in the journey.
Ask Me
So what do we do in these scenarios?
I have two specific suggestions.
The first is simple: ask for guidance.
Sometimes people turn to friends, social media, or online forums and get wildly different answers. One person says move on. Another says fight for it.
What we often need is nuance—something tailored to the specific situation.
Because dating is rarely black and white.
The Outcome Is Not in Your Control
The second thing you can do is recognize the pattern as it’s happening.
You clicked on this video, which means you’re now aware of the problem.
Awareness grounds you in reality.
Instead of thinking, “I need this person to work out,” you can catch yourself and say, “I’m doing that thing again where I’m making this person too important.”
Then bring your attention back to the truth: all you can control is your part.
You can show up as your best self in texts. You can communicate honestly. You can follow through on plans and show genuine interest.
But ask yourself:
Am I investing solely based on how much I like this person, or based on how much they’re also investing in me?
A Messy Process
The real balance we’re trying to strike is between proactivity and pride.
These sit on opposite ends of the spectrum.
A lot of dating advice today tells us to cut things off at the first sign of discomfort. But love is often messy.
It doesn’t always fit neatly into rules.
If someone you’ve never met is flaky about making plans, you could write them off immediately. Or you might decide there’s little risk in trying one more time.
That doesn’t mean approaching them with the same enthusiasm as before. They’ve shown you something important.
They move to a different category in your mind.
But remember: they don’t know you yet. Their behavior is not necessarily a rejection of you.
It may reflect their own patterns, their circumstances, or simply the fact that you’re not important to them yet—and maybe that’s normal at this stage.
Time reveals these things.
And if they continue to be unreliable, then you step back with confidence, knowing you tried without losing yourself.
Redefining Winning and Losing
If we want more success in love, we have to redefine winning and losing.
People today are very concerned with protecting their power.
But winning isn’t necessarily getting the person or getting the date.
Sometimes winning is more subtle.
Maybe a younger, more prideful version of you would have cut someone off immediately because your ego felt threatened.
Today, you gave someone a chance.
You acted from confidence instead of fear.
Confidence isn’t acting like you don’t care.
It isn’t avoiding vulnerability.
Confidence is walking away with your self-respect intact regardless of the outcome.
That’s how you navigate emotionally dangerous moments safely.
Too Little or Too Much Effort?
Here’s something important to remember:
When we put in too little effort, that often represents insecurity.
But putting in too much effort can represent insecurity too.
Between those extremes is the sweet spot: vulnerability and generosity of spirit.
That’s the territory we’re aiming for.
A useful question to ask yourself is:
How much can I give to this situation while still feeling proud of myself if it doesn’t work out?
You don’t want to give so much that you later feel ashamed and think, “Why did I try so hard?”
But you also want to give enough that you don’t feel like fear held you back.
This isn’t about endlessly pursuing people who don’t reciprocate.
Nor is it about constantly putting your heart on the line.
But if you’re approaching something unknown from a place of calm—and without attaching yourself to outcomes—it may be worth practicing a little vulnerability from time to time.
Would Love to Hear Your Thoughts
If you made it to the end, leave a comment sharing a situation you’re struggling with right now and how you might navigate it differently using this pride-versus-proactivity framework.
Do you lean too much toward pride? Or too much toward proactivity?
I’d love to hear your thoughts.
Thanks for watching, and I’ll see you next time.
—
This post was previously published on YouTube.
Blog → https://www.howtogettheguy.com/blog/ Facebook → https://facebook.com/CoachMatthewHussey Instagram → https://www.instagram.com/thematthewh… Twitter → https://twitter.com/matthewhussey ▼ Connect with Stephen ▼ Youtube → https://bit.ly/StephenHusseyYoutube Instagram → http://bit.ly/StephenHusseyIG
***
On Substack? Follow us there for more great dating and relationships content.
—
Photo credit: unsplash
