I once spent eight months thinking about someone I didn’t even want back.
That was the part that embarrassed me.
If you’d asked me whether they were good for me, I would’ve said no without hesitation. The relationship drained me. The communication was inconsistent. I spent more time confused than happy.
So why was I still checking their social media at 11:47 p.m. on random Tuesdays?
Why did their name still have the power to ruin an otherwise decent day?
I Kept Calling It Love
For a long time, I told myself I was stuck because I loved them.
That explanation felt romantic. Tragic, even.
It made the whole thing sound meaningful.
But the more honest answer was harder to admit.
I wasn’t thinking about them because they were right for me.
I was thinking about them because my brain hadn’t finished chasing something it never fully got.
There’s a strange psychological effect where unfinished experiences tend to stay alive in our minds longer than completed ones. We remember the conversation that got interrupted. The question that never got answered. The story without an ending.
And some relationships are basically one giant unfinished sentence.
No clear closure.
No satisfying explanation.
No final moment where everything neatly makes sense.
Just confusion.
My brain hated that.
The Night I Realized What Was Actually Happening
I remember sitting on my couch around midnight, replaying an old conversation for probably the thousandth time.
You know the kind.
The mental courtroom where you’re both the lawyer and the jury.
Maybe if they had said this…
Maybe if I had responded differently…
Maybe if I understood what they meant…
I was exhausted.
Then a weird thought hit me.
I wasn’t remembering the good moments.
Not really.
I was remembering the questions.
The uncertainty.
The things I never understood.
That realization felt like getting cold water thrown in my face.
Because if I was truly stuck on love, wouldn’t I be replaying the moments that made me happy?
Instead, I was replaying puzzles.
The Thing From Childhood That Nobody Warns You About
This is where it gets uncomfortable.
Sometimes the reason we can’t let go of the wrong person has very little to do with them.
It has everything to do with what they activated inside us.
A lot of us learned love in environments where attention wasn’t consistent.
Maybe affection had to be earned.
Maybe approval came and went.
Maybe emotional safety felt unpredictable.
So later in life, when someone gives us just enough connection to keep us hoping — but not enough to make us feel secure — it feels strangely familiar.
Not good.
Familiar.
And our brains often confuse those two things.
I hated admitting this because it sounded cliché.
But when I looked honestly at my dating history, a pattern appeared.
The people who treated me well made me feel calm.
The people who kept me guessing made me feel obsessed.
That’s not the same thing.
Not even close.
The Addiction Nobody Calls an Addiction
I used to think obsession meant strong feelings.
Now I think it often means inconsistent rewards.
The relationship that consumed my thoughts wasn’t the one where I felt safest.
It was the one where affection appeared randomly.
One day they seemed all in.
The next day they disappeared.
Then they came back.
Then they pulled away again.
My emotions became tied to uncertainty.
And uncertainty is incredibly powerful.
These were the signs I kept ignoring:
— I was more focused on getting their attention than enjoying their presence
— I spent more time analyzing their behavior than experiencing the relationship
— Small moments of validation felt disproportionately exciting
— My mood depended on whether they responded
Looking back, that wasn’t love.
It felt more like withdrawal.
A harsh word, maybe. But it explained a lot.
The Unexpected Part
The hardest thing wasn’t letting go of them.
The hardest thing was letting go of the version of me that thought winning their love would finally prove something.
Because underneath all the overthinking was a quiet belief I didn’t want to face.
If I could just get this person to choose me consistently, maybe it would mean I was enough.
Maybe it would erase old wounds.
Maybe it would fix something much older.
That’s a lot to put on one person.
Especially a person who wasn’t even right for me.
I wasn’t grieving the relationship as much as I was grieving the fantasy of what their validation would supposedly give me.
And that’s a painful difference to see.
What Finally Helped
Nothing changed overnight.
I wish I could tell you there was a magical insight that instantly erased them from my mind.
There wasn’t.
Actually, the first step was annoyingly simple.
I stopped asking, “Why can’t I stop thinking about them?”
And started asking, “What feeling am I trying not to feel?”
Different question. Different answer.
Loneliness.
Rejection.
Fear.
Old insecurities I’d been avoiding for years.
The thoughts about them were often a distraction from those deeper feelings.
Once I started dealing with those emotions directly, something strange happened.
The obsession lost some of its energy.
Not all at once. Just little by little.
Like a fire running out of things to burn.
I still thought about them sometimes.
But they stopped feeling like the center of the story.
What I Know Now
I don’t think the people who haunt us are always the ones we loved the most.
Sometimes they’re the ones who left us with the most unanswered questions.
The ones who activated old wounds.
The ones who made us chase something we’d been chasing long before we met them.
And that’s why moving on can feel so confusing.
Because you’re not just letting go of a person.
You’re letting go of a pattern.
A hope.
A familiar ache you’ve carried for longer than you realize.
When I finally understood that, something shifted.
Not dramatically.
Just enough.
Enough to see that I didn’t actually miss them.
I missed the ending I never got.
And once I stopped waiting for that ending to arrive, I slowly started writing a different one for myself.
—
This post was previously published on medium.com.
Love relationships? We promise to have a good one with your inbox.
Subcribe to get 3x weekly dating and relationship advice.
Did you know? We have 8 publications on Medium. Join us there!
***
–
Photo credit: Nathan Dumlao on Unsplash
