By Shannon Roddel – Notre Dame
Even with all the hype around streaming, traditional TV still dominates ad spend. Advertisers are putting $139 billion into linear ads this year, compared to just $33 billion for ads on streaming/connected TV.
“We show TV ads are only about half as effective as we thought.”
With no way to track individual behavior among traditional TV viewers, it’s difficult to determine whether all that spending gets results.
New research from the University of Notre Dame helps determine the return on investment for TV ads, ironically by using digital data.
By combining massive datasets that track exactly what households watch and buy second by second, the study separates the real impact of TV ads from other factors.
Traditional methods of measurement, which rely mostly on ratings and aggregate market data, appear to overestimate ad effectiveness by 55% in a study of advertising for food delivery services, according to Shijie Lu, an associate professor of marketing at Notre Dame’s Mendoza College of Business.
Lu’s research appears in Marketing Science.
Imagine that a household watches only part of a live game. If a food delivery ad airs during the portion they watched, they may see it; if it airs earlier or later, they may miss it. That timing difference creates a kind of natural experiment, helping the researchers isolate the ad’s true effect from other factors, such as which households were already more likely to order food. Researchers could not easily do this before with traditional TV measurement. Smart TV tracking now provides second-by-second household viewing data, making this kind of measurement possible at a much finer level.
Using LG smart TV data, Lu and coauthors Tsung-Yiou Hsieh from Oklahoma State University and Rex Yuxing Du from the University of Texas at Austin analyzed the viewing habits of millions of people who opted in to sharing their viewing data, letting the researchers see exactly what was on peoples’ screens—broadcast networks such as NBC and ABC, specifically—over a four-month period. The study didn’t track streaming apps like Hulu or Amazon. LG watched what viewers watched and connected that data to people’s food delivery app usage to measure ad impact.
“This is a game-changer,” Lu says, “because we can now link precise TV viewing data with real purchase history to measure TV ad effectiveness more credibly.
“Brands are overestimating their campaigns and wasting money on ineffective placements,” he says.
“We show TV ads are only about half as effective as we thought. When corrected, the real sales impact is much lower, which has important implications for how advertisers evaluate performance and allocate spending.”
In addition to showing that traditional measures greatly overstated the effects of TV ads, the new measurement method revealed additional insights that could help companies better target their ads.
Data show that promotions for first-time buyers increase retention. Viewers’ responsiveness to ads peaks within two days of purchasing food on a delivery app, with the highest engagement rate found among customers who have ordered two to four times previously. Young, tech-savvy sports fans are better prospects than older news viewers.
“The old ways of measuring TV ads are missing an important part of the picture, because they do not fully account for who is more likely to see ads and who is more likely to buy,” Lu says.
Traditional TV ad tracking confuses ad effectiveness with pre-existing habits (like who is already likely to buy or who watches a lot of TV), leading to inflated results. This research fixes that by isolating the random timing of ad slots within shows, allowing the team to accurately measure the true sales lift of TV ads and determine how that impact varies based on a customer’s history.
The study provides a powerful tool for more precisely measuring the return on investment of TV advertising. By targeting ads based on what viewers actually buy—not just demographics like age or gender—this approach brings digital-level precision to TV.
Source: University of Notre Dame
This post was previously published on FUTURITY.ORG and is republished here under a Creative Commons license.
***
At The Good Men Project, this is the kind of media-and-culture story we find especially worth watching, because it reminds us that influence is often both more pervasive and less efficient than people assume. The underlying study is not saying advertising does nothing. It is saying that for one category, food delivery services, traditional TV ad effectiveness appears to have been substantially overstated when measured using older methods, and that more granular smart TV data gives a more credible picture of actual sales lift. The researchers specifically found that conventional methods overestimated effectiveness by about 55%, and the study focused on broadcast viewing rather than streaming apps.
That matters beyond marketing budgets. We live in a world saturated with messaging, nudges, brand cues, and repeated emotional prompts, and many of us are taught to think that if a message is everywhere, it must also be all-powerful. But sometimes the better takeaway is subtler: these systems shape us, yes, but not always as neatly or as efficiently as the people paying for them would like. That is useful to remember when we talk about culture, masculinity, health, identity, or the stories people absorb about what they are supposed to want. Constant exposure matters. So does human agency. Both things can be true at the same time.
It is also a good reminder to be more careful about what we count as persuasion. A message can be weak at driving immediate purchases and still be strong at creating atmosphere, habit, aspiration, or background norms. That is one reason we keep paying attention to how media works here. If we want to live well in a rapidly changing world, we need to get better at noticing the difference between what truly changes behavior, what merely surrounds us, and what quietly becomes the wallpaper of everyday life.
There are many ways to support The Good Men Project’s mission. Subscribe to our email or become a Premium Member, and follow our broader conversations about media, culture, masculinity, identity, and how people make meaning inside systems designed to influence them. We also work with authors, agencies, brands, and sponsors through our author amplification and paid guest post programs. For more information, email [email protected]
—
FAQs – About The Good Men Project
What is The Good Men Project?
The Good Men Project is a mission-driven media platform founded in 2010 that explores modern masculinity, men’s mental health, relationships, fatherhood, identity, and social change through personal stories, expert insights, and cultural analysis.
What is The Good Men Project’s mission?
Our mission is to expand the conversation about what it means to be a good man in the 21st century — in ways that are inclusive, emotionally honest, and grounded in real human experience.
How does GMP approach content about science and technology?
We examine science and technology through their impact on human lives. From AI and automation to social media and climate science, GMP explores how rapid technological change affects identity, work, relationships, mental health, civic responsibility and the future we all are inheriting and civic responsibility. We partner with other trusted sources, and believe in science and research to inform good decisions in a rapidly changing world.
—
If you believe in the work we are doing here at The Good Men Project, please join us as a Premium Member today.
All Premium Members get to view The Good Men Project with NO ADS.
Need more info? A complete list of benefits is here.
The Good Men Project is a mission-driven media platform founded in 2010 that helps writers, brands, agencies, and organizations build credibility, audience, and long-term authority. By publishing stories about masculinity, mental health, relationships, fatherhood, identity, and personal development, GMP provides a trusted ecosystem where ideas gain visibility, trust, and resilience in both search and AI-driven discovery. The platform supports individual contributors as well as high-volume agencies through paid guest posts, sponsored content, and bulk publishing systems designed for scale.
—
Photo by Glenn Carstens-Peters on Unsplash
