
Good men aren’t just good, Billie Hill writes, they’re priceless.
A good man is hard to find, to be sure. Hold him tight.
Good men, kind men, compassionate men are out there, and they are desirable no matter what anyone says. They are so desirable that when you meet a man who opens doors for you, pays the tab, comes to your aid no matter the cost, and seems to relish every moment with you, when he decides he no longer wants to be with you … your world may seem to crumble.
I’ve been in the ‘bad boy’ relationships. I’ve not bothered to get to know men because they didn’t bother to get to know me. I’ve tried Internet dating, blind dates, and the grocery store. In general, I’ve not shared intimate details. I’ve not shared my favorite colors or the fact that I guiltily adore romantic comedies. I’ve not shared that I enjoy chatting with children, adore Fred Rogers, lust for a signature perfume, or that I would KILL for Dita Von Teese’s or Christina Hendricks’ wardrobe. If I don’t have a nightcap or a sleep aid, I have elaborate dreamlike nightmares that wake me up—gasping for no reason—staring into the closet, up at the ceiling, through the bathroom door, or suddenly I wake up at the front door, wondering where I can hide.
With him, I could share some of those things.
♦◊♦
I learned that I stop breathing in my sleep nightly. I learned I clean my glasses nearly constantly, and that if I’m not careful, he flinches in his sleep if I touch him. With him, I also learned what selflessness really is.
What man would purchase four brand new tires for you, replace a battery, replace spark plugs, replace a radiator, supply your dog with food when you’ve run out (and adore that dog at the same time), pick you up in the middle of a road trip and leave work to do so, go to the grocery store (for more than half a day), and buy food at your request so he doesn’t eat oven-baked frozen pizza or McDonald’s every day (and instead gets a home-cooked meal).
This one did…and I never asked him for any of those things. In fact, I told him I didn’t want those things. But, I took them. That was probably a mistake.
We spent a glorious four months together. We shared interests, politics, the sex was awesome, and we had a few arguments here and there (but who doesn’t have those?). We laughed a lot, and learned each other’s tickle spots (which is hard to find on me). The idea, at 37, of being in a long-term relationship no longer seemed bleak. Come on, I adore a man in his 30s who has never been married, doesn’t have kids, loves my dog while I adore his, and seems to actually give a shit? Wow.
♦◊♦
The only other man I had cared about this much committed suicide. I beat myself up. I was sure it was my fault. I had given him an ultimatum. He was ill and refused to take care of himself—a diabetic who is in the hospital six times per year should not be in a bar nightly or be eating fast food nearly daily. My lecturing didn’t help. The ultimatum was that if he didn’t see a doctor on a regular basis, I could never see him again. This man that I loved more than anything cut his wrists shortly after, in the bathtub, with a lady razor. Dead. Dead. Dead. I entered into this new endeavor with tremors: a glimmer of a relationship of any sort with some hefty luggage.
Baggage is never a good thing, but neither are preconceived notions of what a ‘good man’ is.
The closer I got to him, the more I cared about him, the more I felt I was awful. Again, I felt there was no way I deserved a man like him. This man, whose family had enough issues to cover every spectrum, was patient, kind, and humorous despite being the emotional rock for his clan. He was patient with me. He never asked me to change in any way. I smoke, I drink, I’m mercurial…it can be rather taxing. And he never asked me to change a thing.
I constantly worried that there was no way in hell I was good enough for this man, and I proved it. My obsessions and manic-depressive disorder caught up with me.
♦◊♦
We had made plans to go to an event, and I had spoke with a blast from the past. Before I knew it, I was drunk.
I showered, dressed, put the dog in her harness, and drove to his house. Needless to say, he was not pleased. He texted me, all but begging me to leave his house after I had passed out crying and he left for the event. Pleading with him to lecture me or yell at me would not do; he was gone. I knew, at that moment, I had ruined it.
He said he would call me in a few days after he cooled off. We talked, and he relayed his experiences with his mother, of which I already was fully aware. After it all, he and his dog (my only other companions, aside from my own dog) left.
I’ve done my best to keep my distance, it’s not been that long. Tonight, my dog has a sleep-over night with his. I’ve missed her for the few hours that she’s been gone, and I could barely make eye contact with him today. I can’t see him and our dogs together…not yet. With these dogs, it’s like being a divorced couple with children—and it’s painful.
♦◊♦
Despite my dysfunctions, I know there’s nothing wrong with me. I know after that I am as worthy as anyone of a ‘good guy.’ I just have to be patient enough and disciplined enough to find him and let him find me…despite my glaring flaws.
A good man is hard to find, a good man is hard to keep, and a good man is even harder to let go. I’ve had to do it twice.
Men that care like they do, and did, are not only good…they’re priceless. Find them. Keep them.
—Photo crimsong19/Flickr

Ah i know what you mean at 19 yrs old. I had found him but i let him go. I still cry for him every once in a while. I miss him so much lol
Julie, I deliberately left out his frame of mind. i don’t know what he was thinking or why he made any choices he did. Was it messed up? … yeah, I think so. But blaming him does no good for me and it only makes me better for trying to understand. Does he have his own issues … TREMENDOUSLY. However, it’s never been my place to put him in his. Do I have my own issues to get over? NO QUESTION. But, to elaborate on an intimate moment that I would only rather hint upon, rather to bring commenters to… Read more »
For those not understanding that I take full responsibility for my part in this break up, I’m afraid you will not get passing blame from me.
I will not make him the bad guy in this. That’s unfair.
I think the issue is that you’ve not really explained your part in it. The piece you’ve crafted is vague enough as to be frustrating for the reader and seems to be giving the reader the impression that your partner just dumped you…or something. Again, the writing is unclear, though your emotions connected to the break up are very clear. If what has happened was your trigger met his trigger than you either share responsibility and work through it and learn from the mistakes, or you break up and neither one of you are “bad” or “good.” But the piece… Read more »
If he can’t talk to you, and ASK why you were upset, he is not the right guy for you. You crossed a line of reality w/ past trauma. Until you are resolved w/ tragedy and loss, you may need a guy who can support your “triggers”. Does he know what a “trigger” is? Look him in the eyes, and tell him you need support. You don’t have cancer. Not asking too much in a mature adult relationship. Getting drunk…unless he is religiously opposed, not the end of the world. You can’t be w/ a “good guy” unless you can… Read more »
no. i don’t think he knows what a trigger is. certainly not mine. the ‘blast from the past’ was the sister of the man who took his life.
So he couldn’t support you through that very emotional situation? And cut you off? That’s not a “good guy.” That’s someone who needs to deal with his own relationship baggage and learn how to stay connected.
I like the ambiguity of your story. The real meaning comes through loud and clear. I think despite the issues you have that hope remains present in your writing. Good luck with everything and please keep writing for the site and in general.
All I get is a suggestion of a drunken indiscretion. I guess im not clued into subversive speak
1) no one’s suicide is your fault. It might be a very good idea for you to seek out professional counseling to help you process that loss and it’s effect on you. 2) I”m also quite unclear at your story. It’s not written clearly to show what caused the break up-though it seems that you did some action purposefully out of a desire to prove you weren’t worthy and he reacted accordingly. Again, I think that therapy with a qualified professional and if you do have bi-polar disorder, proper medication could also support your healing. 3) It’s not so much… Read more »
It was deliberately fuzzy. Fuzzy is how I felt both times. It wasn’t an alcohol induced fuzziness, just a stunned numbness.
No, I didn’t cheat on him. He just decided he didn’t want to be with me anymore. The other love just gave up.
Really, it’s why relationships are hard for me. I do my best.
So, you came to his house and he broke up with you flat out? No inciting incident? Or was he angry that you got drunk and drove to his place in a messy state (reminding him of his mother)? Then I’d say he wasn’t as good to you as you needed him to be. If the dog belongs to you, I’d cease the sleepovers and make a clean break. If he broke it off with you for no reason, that’s not a good dynamic. If he broke it off with you due to the alcohol issues, maybe you both could… Read more »
his general solution to any conflict, no matter the severity, was to ask me to leave.
Well, I can’t see that he’s a totally good guy. Relationships take work and sometimes that involves conflict. I hope you find that person who can be with all of you, and stay connected to you even if that feels hard.
I guess I must be dense. Did you sleep with somebody else, or did he break up with you for driving drunk, or making a scene at his house?
I guess I’m not following what happened.
“A good man is hard to find.”
About as hard as finding a good woman. Thankfully, I found one, and have held on to her for quite a few years.
I am sorry for your losses and wish you all the best.
thank you.