The Difference Between Calm and Numb (I Confused Them for Years)

My grandmother died on a Tuesday morning, and by Tuesday afternoon, I was answering emails.

Not because I’m heartless. Because I genuinely felt fine. Steady, even.

My sister called, sobbing so hard I could barely understand her, and I sat there holding the phone, murmuring the right things, feeling like I was watching the conversation happen to someone else. Someone calm. Someone handling it well.

At the funeral three days later, an aunt squeezed my hand and said, “You’re so strong. I don’t know how you’re holding it together like this.”

I remember feeling a small glow of pride at that. Holding it together. I’d always been good at that. It was practically my whole personality.

It took me almost two years to realize I hadn’t been calm that week at all.

The Compliment I Kept Chasing

Growing up, “she’s so calm” was said about me the way other kids got called funny or athletic. My mother would tell people I never made a fuss. My teachers wrote it on report cards: even-tempered, doesn’t rattle easily.

I liked being that kid. Being unshakeable felt like a superpower in a house where everyone else’s emotions were loud and unpredictable. If I stayed calm, I stayed safe. If I stayed calm, I didn’t add to the noise.

So I got very good at it. Bad news arrived, and I’d nod, breathe, handle it. Chaos erupted, and I’d become the person everyone leaned on because I “didn’t get overwhelmed like that.”

What I didn’t understand — not for another two decades — was that I wasn’t staying calm in those moments.

I was leaving.

What Actually Happens When You “Handle It Well”

A therapist finally named it for me, years after the funeral, during a session about something completely unrelated — a fight with my husband where I’d stayed eerily composed while he cried.

“What did you feel during the fight?” she asked.

“Nothing, really,” I said. “I just felt calm. I don’t really get worked up.”

She tilted her head. “Where in your body did you feel calm?”

I opened my mouth to answer and realized I couldn’t. I searched for it the way you’d search a room for your keys, growing increasingly aware that they weren’t there.

“I don’t think I felt it anywhere,” I finally said.

“That’s not calm,” she said gently. “That’s your body leaving the room.”

The Difference Nobody Taught Me

Here’s what I’ve come to understand since:

Calm has sensation. It’s steady breathing, a settled stomach, a body that’s present and simply not in distress. Calm can hold eye contact. Calm can say “this is hard” without falling apart.

Numbness has absence. It’s not feeling okay — it’s not feeling anything. It’s a kind of internal fog where your voice stays even because there’s no longer a clear signal reaching it. You’re not regulating the wave. You’ve left the ocean entirely.

For years, I mistook the second thing for the first, because from the outside they can look identical. Both produce a person who doesn’t cry at the funeral. Both produce someone who says “I’m fine” in a voice that doesn’t waver.

But one of them is a nervous system that processed the pain and settled. The other is a nervous system that got overwhelmed so early and so often that it learned to just… go quiet instead.

Why This Matters More Than It Sounds Like It Should

This distinction isn’t just semantic. It has consequences.

Real calm lets you connect with people in hard moments. Numbness quietly removes you from them, even while your body stays in the room.

My sister remembers that week after our grandmother died as the week I “wasn’t really there.” I remember it as the week I handled everything so well. We’re describing the same person, the same days, and coming away with completely different stories — because what felt like composure to me looked like absence to her.

Real calm recovers. You feel the hard thing, it moves through you, and eventually it softens. Numbness doesn’t recover, because there was nothing to metabolize in the first place — the feeling didn’t get processed, it got postponed. Mine got postponed for two years, and then arrived all at once, badly, at an unrelated moment over a fight about dishes, when I suddenly and inexplicably burst into tears I’d apparently been owing since a Tuesday in March.

Learning to Tell Them Apart

I wish I had a clean technique for this, but mostly what I have is a question I ask myself now, the same one my therapist asked me:

Where do I feel this in my body?

If I can find it — a tightness, a warmth, a lump, anything — I’m probably actually feeling something, even if it’s uncomfortable. That’s real. That’s calm-in-progress, or grief-in-progress, or whatever it is, moving through an actual nervous system.

If I search and find nothing — just a strange flatness, a sense of watching myself from three feet to the left — that’s usually the other thing. That’s the old exit route, still open for business after all these years.

I’ve started treating that flatness as information instead of success. Not “good, I’m handling this,” but “okay, something’s too big right now, and I’ve left the room.” Sometimes that just means pausing. Taking a slow breath and asking my body to come back before I say anything else.

The Slow Return

I’m not going to tell you I’ve fixed this. I still catch myself, weeks after something hard, suddenly crying over something small and unrelated, recognizing the delayed shipment for what it is.

But I no longer mistake the flatness for strength. I no longer let people call me “so calm” without a small, private correction running underneath: not calm — just gone for a minute. I’ll be back.

And more and more, I am. A little sooner each time. A little more in my body when the hard thing actually happens, instead of three days or three years later, ambushed by dishes in the sink.

If you’ve ever been told you’re remarkably calm in a crisis, and some part of you suspected that wasn’t quite the compliment it sounded like — it might be worth asking yourself the same question.

Where do you feel it?

If you can’t find an answer, that might be the answer.

—

Previously Published on Medium

iStock image