
The truth is that I flirt with everyone, and no one. With a certain amount of natural charm, every conversation can come across as flirtatious, but I can’t remember the last time I genuinely flirted with anyone with the intention of doing so. When working a crowd, I had a passing thought that I miss that energy, the shimmer that comes with a flirtation with a crush.
But I also remember the flipside of that shimmer, the stomach churning anxiety that comes with liking someone as more than a friend. We often interpret that sensation of butterflies as chemistry or a crush, but what we’re often experiencing is the nervous system dysregulation of anxiety. It’s not an indicator of safety, that’s for certain. Yet, we have a society that promotes “having butterflies” with “falling in love,” and that basic misunderstanding leads a lot of us headlong into toxic, unwise, or unsafe relationships.
To be clear, that lack of safety might not be physical. Oftentimes, it’s a lack of emotional safety we’re sensing. The butterflies of attraction to a man who is emotionally unavailable aren’t a precursor to some epic love story; instead, they are a warning sign that we are strapping into an emotional roller coaster that will likely end badly for us. Misunderstanding that feeling can have us heading straight for danger while feeling confident that we’re on the right path. The sign reads “Heartache Ahead,” but we’re seeing neon lights flashing “Love.”
The Science of Butterfly Feelings
Science Insights explains the physiological experience happening inside our bodies when the butterfly feeling occurs:
Butterflies in your stomach are a real physical sensation caused by your nervous system redirecting blood away from your digestive tract during moments of stress, excitement, or attraction. That fluttery, hollow feeling isn’t imaginary. It’s your body preparing for action, and it involves a surprisingly complex chain reaction between your brain, your hormones, and a network of millions of nerve cells lining your gut.
This is what happens when our bodies go into the “fight or flight” response. We’re reacting to this attraction as danger. Because the gut has its own nervous system, the idea of “trusting our gut” isn’t just emotional; it’s a scientific reality. The gut can be an early warning system.
Science Insights goes onto explain why there’s an overlap between the “butterflies” of love and anxiety.
Fear and anxiety lean heavily on adrenaline and its cousin noradrenaline, producing a sharp, urgent version of the sensation. Romantic attraction adds dopamine to the mix. Dopamine activates your brain’s reward system, creating feelings of pleasure and motivation, which is why the butterflies of a new crush feel exciting rather than purely uncomfortable. At the same time, serotonin levels actually drop during the early phases of romantic attraction, which raises baseline anxiety. So the butterflies of new love are genuinely a blend of pleasure and nervousness happening simultaneously.
Your body can’t easily distinguish between “good” stress and “bad” stress at the hormonal level. A roller coaster, a first date, and a near-miss car accident all trigger the same core fight-or-flight machinery. The difference is mostly in how your brain interprets the context.
In other words, our interpretation of this feeling is what matters. We might automatically think that every experience of butterflies in the stomach is a sign of attraction, but doing so means that we’re disregarding every single warning sign when danger might be present. So, how are we supposed to tell the difference?
Interpreting Butterflies
If the gut can’t distinguish between danger and the anxiety and thrill of new attraction, how are we supposed to trust it or know what to do? Most of us aren’t diving headlong into one toxic relationship after another on purpose. Especially if we’ve experienced trauma, we’re trying to make healthy choices for ourselves and just don’t understand how we could have missed the signs. Science tells us that these butterflies could mean love OR danger. So, what do we do with that information?
We start by regulating the nervous system. That’s key. When we experience the butterflies that we associate with chemistry and attraction, we need to intentionally soothe this feeling, even if we’re finding it somewhat pleasurable.
Soothing the Nervous System
There are several ways to soothe this nervous system reaction:
- We can intentionally slow and deepen our breathing. This should calm the body and soothe the gut.
- We can splash cold water on our faces and necks, telling our bodies to calm down and slowing that racing heart feeling we often get alongside the butterflies.
- Humming or singing can produce a relaxing sensation, and while this might be weird to do mid-conversation with a crush, it could be a good thing to do on the drive home to see if it helps ease the unsettled sensation.
- Laughter can release tension, dispelling those butterflies.
- Gentle movement can also help achieve some relief.
…
If we do any or all of these things and get no relief from the swarm of butterflies in our stomachs, we might want to consider if we’re feeling chemistry and attraction or a warning sign of a toxic connection. That gut feeling might be telling us that someone is dangerous, untrustworthy, or inauthentic. We might be picking up on subtle cues that this person is not a good match or presents some type of risk.
When the Nervous System Stays in Dysregulation
Let’s break this down to be more clear. Here are some experiences that might give us negative butterflies, warning us away:
- This person is married (or in a monogamous relationship), and we know it. Disregard all attraction, and run.
- This person has some red flag rhetoric in either words or actions that we’re picking up on. There might be elements of misogyny or control that our gut is picking up on, even if we’re busy trying to explain away the sense that the vibes are off.
- We’re experiencing the incongruence of someone presenting themselves a very different way than the reality or hearing words that don’t match the actions we’re seeing.
- This person is telling us why they’re not great in relationships while actively pursuing a relationship with us. We’re getting all the information we need to opt-out and free ourselves of this entanglement but may be interpreting butterflies as a waving flag to go ahead rather than to stop right there.
…
The Cost of Misinterpretation
I can look back and see the times I experienced butterflies that were misinterpreted warning signs. For instance, I dated someone who presented himself in a very specific way, one that would appeal to me and my interests. After spending some time with his friends, I was being told a very different version of this person, one that was the opposite of what I’d been presented with in his self-report. I met his family and also got some hints that there were traits he was doing his best to hide. I couldn’t see that the butterflies I was feeling came from an anxiety that I was dating someone who didn’t actually exist, a manufactured persona meant to lock down the relationship before I could see his true colors.
It took several months to disentangle myself from this relationship as I saw more and more how he’d manipulated me into it in the first place. By the time, I got out, it cost me several thousand dollars in stolen money and a credit card he’d run up without my knowledge and in my name. It ended up in a civil court case that felt humiliating for me as I stood up in court and talked about how I’d been deceived and what it had cost me.
What I didn’t say in front of the court and what took me months to admit to myself is that it also cost me emotionally. The relationship tipped quickly into emotional abuse after I’d already formed an attachment based on butterflies I was misinterpreting. I didn’t just have to recover the lost funds stolen from me and my children; I also had to rebuilt my sense of safety and self-worth after an abuser had targeted me.
Misunderstanding butterflies can cost us much more than time spent in the wrong relationship.
Butterflies, Regulation, and Co-Regulation
It is possible to experience butterflies and not be heading straight toward disaster. It’s possible to feel that sensation at first and then soothe it. If we’re able to do that, we might be able to move forward with a regulated nervous system without falling back into fight or flight with every interaction.
I experienced this the last time I entered into a relationship. I tend to panic when I realize I like someone as more than a friend. I’m talking about major denial that might just turn into a full-blown panic attack. In the defense of my gut, it has learned that love for me feels a hell of a lot like danger. If I love someone, they can hurt me. It’s only in keeping emotional distance that I feel safe.
So, at first, I just liked him as a person. I wasn’t even sure if I found him attractive. As far as I’m concerned, a lot of people are pretty, but that doesn’t mean there’s connection and attraction in real life. I try to keep an open mind. An open heart is another matter entirely.
I liked him, but I kept insisting I liked him as a friend. He lived too far away. He was older than the people I usually dated. He was wrong for me, for any number of superficial reasons that mostly went back to age and location. I felt initial butterflies at the thought that I had a little crush forming, but I was treating them like that old Atari game called Duck Hunt. A butterfly would pop up, and I would attempt to pew, pew it out of existence, ignoring the snickering dog any time I missed. I had to regulate my emotions because those butterflies scared the hell out of me.
But then he walked into the room where I was waiting, and my entire nervous system went calm. The room fell quiet in my head. Time slowed. I wish I was exaggerating because — spoiler alert — the relationship didn’t last. This is me, being completely honest about what it was like, that moment of everything falling into a sense of calm certainty. I wanted him, but I didn’t have butterflies trying to escape my gut. I had a little flutter that settled into a sense of knowing.
Now, we can all take a moment to snicker like the Duck Hunt dog that I was so completely wrong. But here’s the thing: Having the calm doesn’t mean we’ll have forever. It just means that I didn’t have any sense of panic at that moment that made me want to flee from danger. I knew this relationship was right for me in a gut-deep way.
And it was. For a little while, this was the relationship I was meant to be in, and I learned a lot about what I wanted and needed. I didn’t take one second of those months of connection and affection for granted. I cherished every bit of it.
But here’s what we have to remember: If the butterflies recur later in the relationship, we can no longer attribute it to the excitement of a new connection. If they come back, there are two possibilities:
When Butterflies Come Back to Stay
Those aren’t butterflies. Those are wasps in the belly trying to sting us into having the sense to save ourselves. If this is the case, we need to realize that something has changed, we’re not safe or connected anymore, and we need to get the hell out. We shouldn’t keep experiencing a sense of butterflies. We should be experiencing a calm and regulated nervous system. If we’re on a rollercoaster of ups and downs, it’s not healthy, and it’s time to go.
The relationship might have been healthy at the start or good for us, but if it goes back to the butterfly feeling and stays there, the good part is over. Some of us (I’m talking about myself here) stay too long because we keep thinking it will go back to the good even when we know the good is gone. We keep that hope alive because it’s painful to admit a relationship has run its course.
When Butterflies Signal a Need for Co-Regulation
The other possibility is for all of us who have experienced trauma. If the butterflies return at some point, it’s possible that we are experiencing a nervous system dysregulation that’s caused by earlier trauma, not the relationship itself. Without the benefit of trauma therapy, it can be hard to tell the difference. Old hurts can come back with a vengeance, and in that case, it’s important to have a partner who is willing to co-regulate with us.
An article in Psychology Today goes deeper into this experience:
In romantic partnerships, our brains constantly scan for cues of safety or threat: a cold tone, a withdrawn glance, a delayed text response. These seemingly small things can trigger a huge physiological response. It’s not just in your head; it’s in your body.
This process is called neuroception, a term coined by Stephen Porges as part of Polyvagal Theory. Neuroception is your body’s automatic and unconscious system for evaluating whether people and situations feel safe, dangerous, or life-threatening. And when your brain interprets something as a threat — even something subtle — it flips you into survival mode. From there, you’re not connecting. You’re protecting.
That’s when we shut down or lash out or self-sabotage. This is when a lot of relationships fall apart. This is when my relationship fell apart. I was reacting to subtle changes in the relationship that made me start to panic — but so was he.
I didn’t see it at the time, but he was also experiencing dysregulation. Where we failed was that we didn’t have the skills to co-regulate and continue the relationship. He shut down, and I over functioned in the relationship. He felt guilty, and I felt abandoned. From the benefit of hindsight, I can see that we were both hurting, but we didn’t help each other through it.
Co-regulation is the process of calming your nervous system through connection with another person.
Co-regulation isn’t just something we do in the middle of a fight. It’s a skill we build before things fall apart — so our nervous systems know what safety feels like when things get hard.
Learning to co-regulate requires that we recognize the signs that our own system is dysregulated, and we pause to let the other person know, or we notice the other person is dysregulated and call for a timeout. We could make eye contact, touch one another in a grounding way (such as holding hands), or even take some deep breaths together. We can learn to calm ourselves rather than withdrawing or lashing out. We can even learn to do this together, as a couple.
In my defense, I did try this. I wanted to co-regulate, but I kept being accused of codependence for trying, something that’s commonly misunderstood. I wasn’t asking him to heal me or to save me. I was asking him to sit with me through the panic and to let me know that I wasn’t alone. His refusal to do so left me feeling increasingly panicked and isolated. When the relationship itself is causing dysregulation, no amount of self-regulation is going to solve the problem.
A once genuine connection turned to disconnection, and while I firmly believe that we could have co-regulated and gotten back on track, the truth is that he didn’t want to continue investing in the relationship, and I didn’t want to give up even more years of my life to another person with one foot out the door in hopes of finding someone better. As much as I loved the beginning, I truly hated that end.
The ability to co-regulate doesn’t necessarily mean we’re meant to be with that person forever, but without that ability, we cannot maintain a healthy relationship. It’s a relationship skill everyone needs, but it’s particularly important when we have past trauma.
I know that I’m going to have a sense of panic the next time I like someone, but I also know that I’ll be able to self-regulate if it’s a solid connection and will be able to co-regulate with the right partner. That initial panic might be inevitable for someone like me, but it doesn’t mean I can’t have a healthy, beautiful, loving, and calm relationship.
Love After Butterflies
These days, I don’t relish the butterfly sensation. It’s not what I miss. While I do sometimes miss that sense of adoring another person and feeling attracted to them, the things I really miss are so much simpler. A hand to hold. A shoulder to lean on. A good hug, a long talk, a forehead kiss. Quiet early mornings. Drinking coffee while reading together. An inside joke. A fondness for one another’s quirks.
But I don’t miss the uncertainty. The stomach-churning sense that one false move or wrong word would ruin everything. The quiet that meant distance, not comfort. The tone that meant disinterest, not affection. The sense of having everything I ever wanted walking alongside the sense of losing it all.
I’m working the room, and if it feels like flirtation, I admittedly roll out the charm. I enjoy talking to people, and every now and then, I enjoy the aesthetics of an attractive face. So far, that’s where my interest begins and ends. I often miss the banter of a romantic connection, but I don’t try to force it, and I know all too well that butterflies are lovely in the garden but terrifying in the gut. Maybe I miss the spark a little, but most days, I’m glad not to have a crush or to feel that flutter when I know that I’m looking for so much more.
I want a calm love. A certain love. A love that isn’t going to run away when things get hard or when novelty gives way to routine. I don’t want a riot of butterflies in my stomach, flapping wings of red flags to get my attention. I just want that marvelous sense of knowing in the center of my being. But the next time? I want to be able to keep it.
—
This post was previously published on medium.com.
Love relationships? We promise to have a good one with your inbox.
Subcribe to get 3x weekly dating and relationship advice.
Did you know? We have 8 publications on Medium. Join us there!
***
–
Photo credit: Alexander Krivitskiy on Unsplash