
By Bruce Lewolt, The 74
This story first appeared at The 74, a nonprofit news site covering education. Sign up for free newsletters from The 74 to get more like this in your inbox.
The first learning software I built shipped on a CD-ROM inside a McGraw-Hill textbook 25 years ago. I had left a Ph.D. program in learning science after realizing that research-based study strategies could be automated.
The disc became an app, and the app became artificial intelligence that can go to class with a student. But the way people learn has not changed.
Learning happens in a narrow band that researchers have called the zone of proximal development or desirable difficulty. I call it the Learning Goldilocks Zone. If the work is too easy, the student learns nothing. If it is too hard, the student gives up or guesses. Learning is fastest just beyond what a student can do alone. These five lessons are what I have learned about helping students reach that zone.
1. Knowing how to study changes almost nothing.
I did everything wrong in college: I reread, highlighted and crammed. Near the end of my junior year, I found a pamphlet with two tips: Turn your notes and reading into questions, and practice answering them on different days. My grades shot up. I was angry that nobody had taught me this, and that anger led me into learning science.
After two decades of building learning systems, I learned the uncomfortable truth: Good study advice has always been available, but habits have barely changed. Knowledge was never the issue. Time and effort were. Across five classes, the best methods can become a 30-hour-a-week job. The real question is who or what will carry some of that workload for students.
2. If studying feels easy, it probably is not working.
Early in my career, we built flashcard systems that worked exactly as designed. Students learned every card, then missed test questions on the same material because the questions looked different.
Rereading feels productive because the material becomes familiar, and familiarity feels like knowledge. But recognition is not the same as recalling, explaining or applying an idea. Productive learning includes mistakes. Students need to retrieve information, use it in different ways, and correct wrong answers. Instead of asking, “Did you study?” ask, “What did you get wrong today, and what do you understand now?” Mistakes during practice are evidence that the brain is doing useful work.
3. Students often change their method only after a failed test.
Some of the students who used my systems the most were nursing students on academic probation. They had memorized their flashcards, failed anyway and were one exam away from removal. Many became nurses. None had tried a different method before failing.
People rarely replace a method that seems to work. A bad grade may be the first time a student is willing to try something new. Do not spend it telling your child to study harder; that often means doubling down on the method that failed. Help them change the method so the effort they are already making begins to count.
4. Forgetting is the real problem, and it compounds.
Years ago, I worked with high school students in special education classes who, as it turned out, did not belong there. They had fallen behind in elementary school, and the gaps grew as the system moved them forward. By high school, they were four years behind in math and English, and nearly everyone treated that as a measure of their ability.
We went back, filled the gaps one at a time, and taught them how to learn. Eight months later, they were performing at grade level. Report cards can hide gaps because grades measure recent performance, not what remains months later. Going back to old material is not remedial. It helps what they learn actually stick and build a stronger foundation of knowledge.
5. The best tutor will not give a student the answer.
Three years before GPT-3, I built a personal tutor that ran on an Alexa device. What made it effective was not that it could talk. It asked questions, waited, and told students when they were wrong.
Generative AI can do the opposite. In a randomized 2025 study of about 1,000 high school students, unrestricted GPT-4 access improved practice performance but reduced exam performance. In the same research, an AI tutor that offered hints and feedback instead of answers produced better results.
An answer machine takes a student out of the Learning Goldilocks Zone. A tutor that asks questions and requires another attempt keeps the student in it. Ask this of any app, tutor, or AI: Does it make my child more capable or more dependent? A tool that teaches makes the student think and try again.
Successful people often tell stories about the teacher who believed in them. Many students never have that experience. Teachers care, but they may be responsible for well over 100 students within a rigid schedule.
The students I taught had a bigger problem than four missing years. Everyone around them had decided that being four years behind was who they were, and they had begun to believe it. What changed was not their ability. Someone refused to accept the verdict and gave them a method that worked.
A parent should be the one person who does not accept that verdict. The role is not to become the homework police or master learning science. It is to remain certain that your child can learn, change the method instead of blaming the child, and help them experience progress. Your child does not need you to know the Learning Goldilocks Zone by name. They need you to be sure they can reach it.
—
This story was produced by The 74, a non-profit, independent news organization focused on education in America.
***
Subscribe to our Email Newsletter:
Why Subscribe? Because this conversation matters.
When you subscribe, you’re directly supporting independent, mission-driven journalism about masculinity, relationships, mental health, fatherhood, and social change. Your inbox becomes part of a movement that’s been challenging stereotypes and expanding what it means to be a good man since 2010. Plus, our newsletter is curated by humans, not algorithms — thoughtful context in an AI-flooded world.
The Good Men Project is a mission-driven men’s media platform. A major platform for stories about men, identity, fatherhood, and emotional intelligence—and a trusted home for the national conversation about masculinity.
The Good Men Project accepts paid guest posts and provides bulk guest post packages for SEO agencies and resellers. Email [email protected] for more information
If you believe in the work we are doing here at The Good Men Project, please join us as a Premium Member today.
All Premium Members help support our mission and get to view The Good Men Project with NO ADS.
Need more info? A complete list of benefits is here.
Photo credit: iStock.com

