People Pleasing Is a Lie We Tell Ourselves

This morning, Craig and I were talking about how today was going to unfold.

Juliana has hopefully reached the point of being released from the hospital after a week of being there, and there were several errands, drop-ins, and check-ins that needed to be handled.

I said, “How about I run to the dairy with the boys, and then see where Juliana’s release is at, and we go from there? Then maybe we can pop by her apartment to take care of the other things.”

Craig replied, “I don’t like that. I don’t want to have to run here and there and be driving all over today.”

I paused. My first instinct was to feel like I had somehow asked too much or laid out a plan that was inconvenient and now needed fixing. But I caught myself. And instead, I said, “Okay, then how about this…” and we came up with a new plan. One that felt better to both of us.

Here’s the thing — I struggle to do what Craig did.

If the roles were reversed, and Craig had proposed the same plan to me, and I didn’t like it, my knee-jerk reaction would have been to bite my tongue, smile, and go along with it.

Not because it felt right.

But because I would’ve told myself it was easier that way.

Because somewhere deep inside, I was still operating under the old wiring that says my needs come second. My preferences are optional. And that if I don’t keep the peace, the price will be too high.

People-pleasing.

It sounds nice enough, doesn’t it?

Who doesn’t want to be agreeable, helpful, cooperative?

But make no mistake: people-pleasing isn’t the same as being kind. It isn’t generosity. It isn’t love. In its core, it’s manipulation. And yes, I know that’s a hard pill to swallow for all of my fellow people-pleasers out there — myself included. But hang in here with me.

People-pleasing is manipulative not because we have evil intent, but because we are trying to control the outcome of situations by hiding our truth.

We say yes when we mean no.

We smile when we feel resentful.

We accommodate even when we’re exhausted.

Why?

Because we want people to like us.

Because we are afraid of conflict.

Because we don’t want to feel the weight of someone else’s disappointment.

At its root, people-pleasing is about fear.

It’s the fear that if we show up fully as ourselves, with needs and preferences and boundaries, we will be too much. Or worse, not enough. That the love we receive is conditional, and we must constantly earn it by being agreeable, sweet, and easy. It’s born from experiences — often in childhood — where we were taught, directly or indirectly, that our authenticity came at a cost. Maybe you had parents who only responded to you with affection when you were behaving in a way that pleased them. Maybe your emotions were met with silence or punishment. Maybe conflict in your home meant withdrawal of love, slamming doors, or cold shoulders.

So, you learned to adapt.

You learned to perform.

You learned to please.

And that little girl or boy inside of you carried those patterns into adulthood. Into friendships, into romantic relationships, into work dynamics, into motherhood or fatherhood. Always measuring what you say and do against the anticipated reaction of the other person. Always calibrating your truth for the sake of someone else’s comfort.

But here’s the truth: when we people-please, we betray ourselves.

We dishonor our bodies, our needs, our intuition.

We diminish our power.

We become passive participants in our own lives.

And eventually, the resentment leaks out.

Maybe not at first.

Maybe not for a while.

But it always does.

Resentment is the residue of every “yes” that should’ve been a “no.” It’s the weight we carry when we’ve silenced ourselves too many times.

And let me be blunt, this isn’t just a “women’s issue.” While women are often conditioned more intensely toward people-pleasing, I have met many men who suffer in silence because they’ve been taught that asking for what they need is weakness. That expressing vulnerability is unmanly. So, they shut down, shut up, and give in. They provide and protect, but never ask for anything in return. They please quietly and die slowly inside.

Whether you’re male or female, people-pleasing keeps you small. And the price you pay is authenticity.

Don’t like ads? Become a supporter and enjoy The Good Men Project ad free

Intimacy.

Connection.

Freedom.

Boundaries are love.

Boundaries are clarity.

Boundaries are what allow us to say, “I love you, and here is what I need to feel safe and seen in this relationship.”

It’s okay to say no.

It’s okay to say, “I don’t want to.”

It’s okay to not be liked by everyone.

It’s okay to honor yourself first.

You are not here to be convenient.

You are not here to be digestible to everyone.

You are not here to shape-shift for approval.

You are here to be fully, unapologetically YOU. And if people fall away because of that? Let them fall. Because the ones who are meant to love you will not require you to abandon yourself in the process.

Craig continued teaching me something this morning that I’m still learning. That it is not only okay to voice what doesn’t feel good — it is necessary. That discomfort in the moment is better than resentment in the long run. That speaking up doesn’t mean you’re selfish. It means you’re self-aware.

So, to every recovering people-pleaser out there (and I count myself among you): you are allowed to take up space. You are allowed to disagree. You are allowed to say what you want and don’t want. You are allowed to ask for help. You are allowed to protect your peace.

And you don’t owe anyone a ten-minute explanation or an apology for honoring your own soul.

There is nothing noble about self-abandonment.

There is nothing heroic about tolerating more than you should. There is nothing romantic about being the one who always gives and never receives.

Real love — with a partner, a friend, a community — requires truth. And truth begins with you.

So, here’s your reminder: your needs matter.

Your voice matters.

Your boundaries matter.

And the people who truly love you will want to know the real you. Not the version you curate for peace-keeping.

Not the character you perform to avoid discomfort.

The REAL you.

Speak up.

Stand tall. T

ell the truth.

Because when you stop people-pleasing, you start living.

If this hit you in the gut — in the best, most truth-telling kind of way — then it’s time to stop betraying yourself and start reclaiming your voice, your needs, and your boundaries.

Comment ACTIVATE or DM me to book your private 90-minute Activation Deep Dive Call.

Let’s unravel the people-pleasing, get honest, and start building a life where your “yes” actually means YES.

As always loving you from here,

Rene Schooler

—

This post was previously published on medium.com.

***