The Simple Truths About the Cheater’s Dilemma

One subject that is always capable of evoking strong emotions and moral dilemmas is, of course, infidelity. It is a subject probably as old as human relationships themselves, or very soon thereafter, and at the heart of this issue lies the “cheater’s dilemma”,

The dilemma is all about cheaters’ struggle to balance their attachment to their primary partners on the one hand, with their desire for extramarital affairs with the potential consequences on the other.

Defining the dilemma

I believe the cheater’s dilemma can really be summed up in one simple question: Is the fleeting pleasure of an affair worth the potential destruction it can wreak on a committed relationship? Such is the conflict of desires and needs: longing for novelty or emotional connection outside of the committed relationship, against the guilt and potential loss of trust and intimacy within the primary relationship.

How they try to get around it

To circumvent this dilemma, cheaters may try to use various coping mechanisms and rationalizations all in attempts to justify or minimize the perceived risks of their betrayal.

Strategy 1:

At the top of the list is, denying the consequences. Some cheaters convince themselves that their actions will not have any lasting consequences while downplaying the emotional impact on their primary partner. All the while convincing themselves that they can carry on indefinitely and without getting caught.

Strategy 2:

There is also the blame everyone and everything but yourself strategy. Here they shift the blame onto external factors like relationship dissatisfaction or even their primary partner’s behavior! From where they stand, attributing the cause of their betrayal to circumstances beyond their control not only absolves them of responsibility but also justifies their actions.

Strategy 3:

Again, some cheaters also rationalize their behavior by convincing themselves that their actions are relatively harmless compared to other forms of betrayal, and that as long as they maintain their commitments to their primary partner on a practical level, their infidelity really does not constitute a serious breach.

Strategy 4:

Finally, we have cheaters who compartmentalize their affairs as something completely removed from their primary relationship because they are discrete compartments of their lives that do not intersect. By mentally separating their actions in this way, they may minimize the cognitive dissonance and moral conflict associated with infidelity.

“From where they stand, attributing the cause of their betrayal to circumstances beyond their control not only absolves them of responsibility but also justifies their actions.”

Do the strategies work?

Short answer, it depends. The effectiveness of these coping mechanisms in resolving the cheater’s dilemma varies and is dependent upon some individual factors like personality traits, the relationship’s dynamics, and other external circumstances.

While some individuals may successfully rationalize their behavior and even avoid detection or negative consequences in the short term, most eventually have to face the repercussions of their actions in the form of emotional turmoil, relational conflicts, or the dissolution of their primary relationship.

“Is the fleeting pleasure of an affair worth the potential destruction it can wreak on a committed relationship?”

Most importantly, regardless of any short-term success, the long-term consequences of infidelity are usually far-reaching. And even when cheaters manage to avoid immediate detection or consequences, the gradual erosion of trust and intimacy within their primary relationship tends to manifest in subtle but insidious ways over time. No thanks to negative emotions lingering below the surface that undermine the relationship’s foundation.

Conclusion

I am well aware that the question of whether infidelity is still “worth it” given this dilemma is still a personal one that rightly varies from one person to the next. However, even though some may at first see the short-term benefits of infidelity as outweighing any potential consequences, many eventually come to regret their actions and have to acknowledge the serious negative impact on their primary relationship, their own well-being, and even their moral standing.

We also tend to see the true cost of infidelity as one that usually extends beyond mere immediate satisfaction of desire, to the breakdown of the primary relationship and the emotional fallout for all the parties involved. With that in mind it may seem that, in the end, despite the temporary excitement, the long-term repercussions will come to outweigh the fleeting moments of pleasure. As such, committed partners grappling with this dilemma might be better off carefully considering the consequences of their actions in the long term.

—

This post was previously published on medium.com.

***

From The Good Men Project on Medium

What Does Being in Love and Loving Someone Really Mean?

My 9-Year-Old Accidentally Explained Why His Mom Divorced Me

The One Thing Men Want More Than Sex

The Internal Struggle Men Battle in Silence

***

Join The Good Men Project as a Premium Member today.

All Premium Members get to view The Good Men Project with NO ADS.

A $50 annual membership gives you an all access pass. You can be a part of every call, group, class and community.
A $25 annual membership gives you access to one class, one Social Interest group and our online communities.
A $12 annual membership gives you access to our Friday calls with the publisher, our online community.