Why So Many Christians Are Afraid of Therapy

When I was growing up, my dad was a pastor, which meant he was also everything else a church needed him to be. He preached, of course, but he also carried marriages that were splintering under years of unspoken resentment, held grieving parents after funerals, and listened to teenagers wrestling with depression before we even had language for it. In our church, if your marriage was falling apart, you went to the pastor. If someone died, you went to the pastor. If life felt hollow and heavy and too much to carry, you booked an appointment with the pastor. That was simply how it worked.

My dad was a good pastor. A faithful man. A gentle presence. People trusted him because he loved them and he showed up. I watched him sit across from people, prayed with them, and did his best to hold their pain. But he was not a trained therapist. He did not have a background in trauma counselling, or techniques for navigating attachment wounds, or clinical frameworks for diagnosing anxiety or depression. He carried hearts, not case notes. He relied on Scripture, prayer, presence, and intuition. And for many people, that was enough. But for others, it was not. They needed more than spiritual support. They needed someone trained to help them untangle the deeper knots of the human psyche, someone who knew the difference between grief and complicated grief, someone who could recognise when a person was not just discouraged but was quietly drowning.

No one talked about therapy then. Therapy belonged to another world, a world that felt clinical and secular and foreign to faith. In our world, we believed God could heal anything, so why would you go to a professional when you could go to a pastor? Why would you sit in an office with a counsellor when you could kneel at an altar? To do so felt, at least to many, like a lack of spiritual confidence, maybe even a betrayal of faith. And yet, even as a kid, I remember noticing the weight my dad carried and the quiet ache in the eyes of people who needed more than prayer and presence. I did not have language for it then, but I recognise it now: some wounds were not going to shift without help, and pretending otherwise only made them heavier.

I grew up in a world where faith was expected to be enough for everything. Now I can see how deeply we needed both the sacred and the clinical, spiritual support and professional care, prayer and therapy sitting side by side like two hands carrying one heart. Faith is powerful and beautiful, but even faith can benefit from someone who knows how to walk into the darker corners of the soul with a steady light and a trained mind.

The Stigma We Breathe Without Realising

For many Christians, even now, therapy sits in the shadows. It’s not always because people think it’s wrong. Often it’s quieter than that. An unspoken suspicion. A subtle internal whisper. A sense that if you truly trusted God, you wouldn’t need to talk to a stranger about your childhood or your fears or the panic that comes at two in the morning. It’s the feeling that faith should be enough, and if it isn’t, the fault must lie with you.

You see this tension playing out in data, not just whispers. A survey by the American Psychiatric Association found that among people who belonged to a religious community in the US, only about 52 percent said their community openly discusses mental health without stigma. At the same time, 68 percent said they would seek professional mental-health care if a faith leader recommended it.

Another study found that religious or spiritual individuals who were in psychological distress were less likely to perceive a need for professional help compared to non-religious individuals. A separate investigation found that among Christian-identified groups, stronger belief that mental illness had a spiritual cause correlated with lower intentions to seek professional help.

These are not just numbers. They are symptoms of a culture where faith and help-seeking are sometimes portrayed as being at odds. For example you might come across influencers like Milicent Sedra on Instagram, who argue that therapy is dangerous for Christians and emotions should bow to obedience. She reposts videos of people describing trauma and anxiety and states that what they need is repentance, not processing, because talking to a therapist will pull believers off the frontline of faith.

Watching such a clip, you feel both sad and familiar. Sad because wounded people are being told that seeking help is weakness. Familiar because it echoes the theology many of us were raised in: the idea that the soul is strengthened by denial, by discipline, by silence — not by bringing wounds into the light where they can breathe and heal.

Stigma rarely yells. It hardly ever marches in with banners. It whispers. It says : “You just need to pray harder.” It says : “Real Christians don’t feel this anxious.” It says : “If you go to a secular therapist, you’re giving up on Jesus.” It speaks spiritual language but delivers shame.

And the tragedy isn’t that Christians feel pain. The tragedy is that many believe they must pretend they don’t.

The First Time I Considered Therapy

The first time I seriously thought about seeing a therapist, I felt like I was sneaking into a pharmacy to buy something embarrassing. I remember sitting in my car outside the building, engine still running, rehearsing excuses in case I ran into someone I knew. I kept thinking, “What if someone from church sees me? What if they think I’ve lost my faith? What if they think I don’t trust God anymore?”

Inside me was a tug-of-war. On one side was exhaustion, grief, confusion and the growing awareness that my inner world did not match the smiling, functioning exterior I thought I was supposed to maintain. On the other side was theology that had quietly taken root over decades, a theology that whispered, “Real believers don’t need professional help. Prayer is enough. Don’t be dramatic. Be strong.”

I remember feeling embarrassed by my own humanity, as if admitting I needed help meant I’d failed some spiritual exam. It wasn’t that I doubted God. I doubted myself. I wondered if my need for support made me spiritually immature, or weak, or ungrateful. I wondered if spiritual maturity meant never cracking, never wavering, never letting anything get too close.

Sitting there with keys in hand, I realised something important. It wasn’t therapy I feared. It was judgement. It was the sound of certain voices from my past. It was the imagined disappointment of a God who, in my mind, was eternally patient with sinners but oddly impatient with sadness. I wasn’t afraid of healing. I was afraid of being seen needing it.

That was the moment something shifted. I didn’t walk into therapy because I stopped believing in God. I walked in because I finally believed Him enough to stop pretending I was invincible.

Jesus and the Courage to Feel

If you spend enough time with the Bible instead of memes about the Bible, you notice something surprising about Jesus. He was not emotionally avoidant. He did not use Scripture as a shield against real life. He did not treat pain like a failure of faith. He wept at tombs. He withdrew from crowds when life pressed too hard. He sweat blood in anguish. He allowed Himself to feel everything we spend our lives trying to outrun. If denial were holiness, Jesus would have been a sinner.

The Psalms are essentially a spiritual journal filled with panic, grief, rage, doubt, despair and longing. They are ancient therapy sessions in poetic form. “How long, O Lord?” is not the cry of someone ashamed of emotion. It is the cry of someone who trusts God deeply enough to bring their whole, unfiltered self into the conversation.

Faith was never meant to flatten us into cheerful cardboard cutouts. Faith was meant to make us more alive, not less. When we numb or suppress or spiritualise away our emotional lives, we are not being faithful. We are just trying to survive. Jesus did not come to make survivors. He came to make us whole.

There is something profoundly spiritual about sitting with your wounds instead of hiding them, telling the truth instead of performing strength, letting love in instead of pretending you don’t need it. Therapy does not threaten faith. It honours it, because faith was never meant to be a substitute for humanity. Faith was meant to breathe through humanity.

If Jesus could feel deeply and not apologise for it, then maybe holiness isn’t the absence of struggle. Maybe holiness is the courage to be honest about it.

When Churches Become Safe Places To Heal

If the stigma around therapy has lived quietly inside the church, then the future can be different. Churches do not need to become counselling centres. They do not need to become trauma clinics. They do not need to trade prayer for psychology or mystery for manuals. But they can become places where people are not ashamed to say, “I’m struggling,” and where the first response is not suspicion or spiritual diagnosis, but compassion, curiosity and support.

When we reduce everything to prayer alone, we unintentionally teach people that their minds are spiritual liabilities and their emotions are threats to holiness. Yet we now know that unprocessed pain does not disappear. Neuroscience tells us the brain stores stress in neural pathways the way the body stores tension in muscle. Emotional wounds unaddressed do not make us more spiritual. They simply make us tired. They show up in the unexpected tears, the sharp reactions, the numbness, the compulsive busyness, the inability to rest or trust or sit still without reaching for distraction. Prayer can soothe that ache, but therapy can help untangle it.

Healthy faith communities are not those where no one struggles. They are those where struggle is not a source of shame. They are communities where people can say, “I’m seeing a therapist,” and hear, “Good on you. I’m proud of you for getting support.” They are spaces where leaders model vulnerability, not invincibility, and where someone seeking help is seen as taking responsibility for their wholeness, not betraying their belief.

And here is the hopeful part. We are already seeing this shift. More pastors are naming burnout. More Christians are talking about trauma and nervous system healing. More churches are inviting counsellors to speak on mental health and hosting support groups rather than pretending everyone is fine. We are learning that it is not unfaithful to need help. It is human. We are learning that God is not threatened by our healing journey. He is already in the room.

Don’t like ads? Become a supporter and enjoy The Good Men Project ad free

Imagine a church bulletin that includes worship nights and prayer gatherings and also quietly prints a list of local therapists. Imagine faith communities where honesty is welcomed more than certainty, and where healing is not something you are expected to do alone with a brave face and clenched jaw, but something you are supported in with tenderness.

When a church becomes a place where people can say, “I need help,” without fear, something sacred happens. Shame loses its voice. Hope grows roots. And faith becomes what it was always meant to be: not an escape from our humanity, but a companion in becoming whole.

Why I’m Studying to Become a Therapist

Sometimes I think back to those afternoons in my dad’s office. The worn chairs. The half-drunk mugs of tea. The quiet bravery of people trying to hold their lives together in a church room that doubled as a counselling space because that was all we had. My dad did his best. He listened. He prayed. He cared deeply. And many times, it really did make a difference. Yet now I can see what none of us could name then. There were moments when love alone wasn’t enough, not because love failed, but because people deserved both compassion and clinical skill. They deserved someone who knew how to sit with grief and trauma and tangled family histories in ways our tradition never trained us for.

I’m not studying to become a therapist because I think the church got it wrong or because faith let me down. I’m studying because of those rooms, those people, those stories. Because I saw what happens when we try to hold everything with prayer alone, and I saw the quiet weight it placed on everyone — including the pastors who tried to carry what they were never equipped to hold. I want to honour that legacy, not escape it. I want to be the kind of support I once assumed only God could provide, until I realised God sometimes arrives in very human ways.

If there is a takeaway here, it is simple. We don’t have to choose between faith and help. We don’t have to pretend prayer and professional support live in different universes. The church I grew up in did the best it could with the tools it had. Now we have new tools. And instead of resisting them, we can receive them as grace.

I believe the future of faith is not thinner and grittier and more stoic. I think it is softer, truer, and more grounded in reality. I think it will look like pastors and therapists working side by side, like pews and counselling rooms no longer competing for loyalty, like Christians who can pray deeply and still say, “I need to talk to someone.” I think it will look like hope with feet on the ground.

And maybe one day, a kid will sit outside a counselling office the way I once sat outside my dad’s study and feel the same thing I felt then: that help is possible, and they don’t have to carry what hurts alone. Only this time, they’ll walk in without shame.

—

This post was previously published on Backyard Church.

What does The Good Men Project mean by “ethics”?

Ethics at GMP is about how we treat one another—and the world—when no one is watching. Our ethics coverage explores integrity, accountability, empathy, and moral decision-making in everyday life, politics, business, relationships, and leadership.

***