Why So Many Good Men Sound Defensive Right Now

Not too long ago (but also forever ago), we heard from a man I like. Maybe they emailed, or were on one of our community calls. They weren’t a troll. And certainly weren’t a professional outrage machine. They also weren’t somebody looking for permission to be awful and call it truth-telling. Just a thoughtful, trying-to-get-it-right man who had the unmistakable look of someone standing in a conversational minefield.

He said, “I feel like whatever I say, it’s wrong before I even finish saying it.”

Our first thought was, That sounds exhausting. Our next thought was: This is not the first time we are hearing this. And then, almost immediately: We know what the women in your life are exhausted too.

All those things can be true. That was the conversation.

♦◊♦

If you spend enough time around men right now, especially men who are trying in good faith to adjust to a culture that has changed a lot in a short amount of time, you hear a version of this over and over.

They sound defensive.

Not always angry. Not always reactionary. Not always dug in. Defensive. A little braced. A little preemptive. Like they are answering a charge before anyone has formally filed it.

And we do not think the simplest explanation is that men do not want to change.

Ok, some men do not want to change. Let’s not be children about this.

But a lot of good men sound defensive right now because they are getting hit from several directions at once. They are being asked to be more emotionally available, more self-aware, more collaborative, more attuned, more useful at home, less entitled, less brittle, less protected by old rules, less rewarded for merely showing up and calling that fatherhood. Good. Much of that is overdue.

But they are also absorbing another message at the exact same time: that if they get any of this wrong, even awkwardly, even while learning, they may be read not as unfinished but as fraudulent. Not as trying but as performing. Not as clumsy but as manipulative.

That is a rough place to learn from.

And yes, women have been navigating contradictory signals forever. More than forever, honestly. This is not a contest for who got the messiest cultural memo. We’re saying that many men right now are being asked to move, and many do want to move—but it’s all happening in a cultural climate where sincerity is sometimes doubted, softness is often mocked, old masculinity is rightly criticized, and newer masculinity is regularly scrutinized for being fake or “wrong”. Vox had a smart piece last year on the rise of the “performative male,” that figure who adopts the aesthetics of sensitivity without necessarily carrying the real weight of it. The skepticism in that piece is not invented. It came from somewhere.

So now a lot of men are standing there thinking, reasonably enough: Okay. But who, exactly, am I supposed to be then?

Yeah, that question matters. It always has.

♦◊♦

We do not believe that defensiveness comes only from ego. Sometimes it comes from shame. Sometimes from confusion. Sometimes from grief, actually, though men do not always use that word. Grief for the simpler script, even if it was a bad script. Grief for the old confidence that came from thinking manhood was clearer than it turned out to be. Grief for not having the language sooner. Grief for realizing your wife, or your daughter, or your son, or your female coworkers have been trying to tell you something for ten years and you are only just now able to hear it.

That can make a decent man sound awfully defensive.

Psychology Today published a piece last year on vulnerability in men that made a point we wish more people would say plainly: vulnerability does not weaken men, but many men still experience it as dangerous terrain because it has not been practiced, modeled, or rewarded consistently. The American Psychological Association has been making related points for years in its guidance on boys and men, arguing that rigid masculine norms can make help-seeking, emotional expression, and relational flexibility harder, not easier.

That does not excuse bad behavior. It does explain some of it.

And explanations are important, because if we misname the problem, we usually make it worse.

A man says, awkwardly, “I feel like I can’t say anything anymore,” and sometimes what he means is not “I miss being able to dominate every room unchecked.” But sometimes what he means is, “I genuinely do not know how to participate in this new conversation without getting it wrong, and I am embarrassed that I do not know.”

Those are different statements that don’t need the same response.

♦◊♦

There is another thing happening too, and this part is something we’ve been talking about since we started in 2010. But it’s also very 2025, very 2026, very now.

Public culture keeps giving men cartoon choices.

Be the old-school alpha. Be the self-aware soft guy. Be the repentant feminist husband. Be the trad protector. Be emotionally literate, but not self-absorbed. Be confident, but not “problematic.” Be vulnerable, but not messy. Be strong, but not too traditional about it. Be honest, but make sure your honesty is pre-approved by the room.

Really?

No wonder so many men sound like they are trying to assemble masculinity from spare parts in the dark.

The Guardian has covered this from a few angles over the last year, including Gareth Southgate’s warning about “callous, manipulative and toxic influencers” filling a vacuum for young men looking for direction, and a separate report on how politicians in the UK are trying to pull boys and young men away from that ecosystem by offering better models of fatherhood and care. Another Guardian piece on a large Australian study found that boys who cling hardest to rigid “manly” traits are more likely to hurt others and be hurt themselves, but also that they are in the minority. That last part is important. The loudest boys are not all boys.

That is one of the reasons we resist writing about men as though they are all standing in the same emotional weather.

They are not.

Some are retreating into the manosphere because it offers certainty, grievance, and a villain. Some are trying very hard to become more relational and sounding weirdly stiff while they do it, like a person learning to dance by watching YouTube videos. Some are defensive because they are ashamed. Some are defensive because they are still entitled. Some are defensive because the women around them are saying things that are true, and truth can sting like hell when it arrives late.

So no, it is not one story. It never is.

♦◊♦

Then what is it that’s actually happening?

I think a lot of good men sound defensive right now because they are hearing criticism they probably do need to hear, but they are hearing it in a culture that still has not done a very good job of showing men how to live differently without either puffing up or disappearing.

That’s where a lot of men get stuck, I think.

We have gotten much better at criticizing the old scripts about masculinity. Good. Some of those scripts deserved to be thrown away. But we haven’t quite gotten at how to help men build something sturdier in their place, something that is not just “be less bad” and not just “be basically feminine but still somehow recognizably masculine, and please do it gracefully.”

Yes, we’re simplifying. But only a little.

This is why The Good Men Project has mattered for a long time. We’ve never been particularly interested in men as caricatures. Not men as villains. Not men as hapless idiots. Not men as overgrown boys who just need enough women to manage them better. And not men as noble victims either. We have been more interested in thoughtful, struggling-to-get-it-right men. Men in process. Men telling personal truths before they are polished enough for a panel discussion.

Don’t like ads? Become a supporter and enjoy The Good Men Project ad free

That matters because the best stories change both the teller and change the listener. We’ve believed that from day one.

Sometimes a man will say the truer thing out loud. A woman reads it and hears something she had not heard phrased that way before. Another man reads it and thinks, Oh. It’s not just me. That is not nothing. That is culture changing at the human speed it actually changes.

♦◊♦

So what helps?

First, we think we need to get better at separating defensiveness from refusal.

Sometimes defensiveness is refusal. Absolutely.

Sometimes it is the first ugly sound a person makes before they can get to honesty. And if you have ever been married, or raised children, or tried to become less wrong about anything meaningful, you already know this.

Second, men need somewhere to stand that is not just apology and not just swagger.

We keep coming back to that. Find a place to stand.

Not on dominance. Not on grievance. Not on ironic detachment. Not on saying all the right things in perfect sequence like you are taking a graduate seminar in How Not to Alarm Women. On steadiness. On truthfulness. On taking correction without collapsing. On being able to say, “That hurt to hear, but I think you’re right.” On staying in the room.

That is masculinity we all can work with.

And third, women need room to tell the truth about what men’s defensiveness has cost them without being accused of causing it. A lot of women have spent years trying to talk to men who turn every difficult conversation into a courtroom drama or a weather event or a sudden seminar on tone. That is exhausting. It is lonely. It makes perfect sense that some women are out of patience. That truth can, and should be, part of the conversation too.

Bridge-building does not mean pretending nobody got hurt.

It means understanding things are complex. And that’s okay. We’re still looking for the better things that can happen next.

♦◊♦

We have also changed on this over the years. We’ve changed as a publication, along with the times.

We’ve watched men tell the truth badly before they could tell it well. We’ve watched them sound argumentative when they were actually ashamed. We’ve watched them cling to dumb formulations because they did not yet have a better sentence for the fear underneath. We’ve watched women in our pages say, in effect, I love men but I don’t know how to reach them, which is its own kind of painful honesty.

The comments teach you things, if you let them.

So do the marriages.
So do the sons.
So do the fathers.

This is one reason we keep thinking the real work is not to win the masculinity argument. It is to make it more livable. Less theatrical. Less stupid. Less dependent on cartoon roles. More human.

And yes, more human is messy.

♦◊♦

And if you want to stay in this conversation with us, start with The Good Men Project itself.

Read the site. Join the email list with the popup below. Follow the wider ecosystem on Substack as well as our Dating & Relationships Substack. If you have a story to tell, submit it to our submissions portal, Submittable. If you want to support this work more directly, a Premium Membership helps keep this kind of independent, human conversation alive. You can also find The Good Men Project: Real Stories from the Front Lines of Modern Manhood on Amazon.

And yes, because this is part of the full ecosystem too, we also offer paid guest posts and paid bulk guest post packages. Unapologetically. For authors, experts, brands, and organizations trying to enter this conversation in a serious way, that is one way in. Email [email protected] for pricing and more information.

The Good Men Project has been doing this work for a long time.

Not because men are simple. Not because women are wrong. Not because any of this ties up neatly. But because people still need a place to tell the truth before they know how to say it perfectly.

It’s about helping more people find a place to stand, tell the truer thing, and stay in the room long enough to hear each other.

That is the beginning.

–

Subscribe to our Email Newsletter:

Why Subscribe? Because this conversation matters. When you subscribe, you’re directly supporting independent, mission-driven journalism about masculinity, relationships, mental health, fatherhood, and social change. Your inbox becomes part of a movement that’s been challenging stereotypes and expanding what it means to be a good man since 2010. Plus, our newsletter is curated by humans, not algorithms — thoughtful context in an AI-flooded world.

The Good Men Project is a mission-driven men’s media platform. A major platform for stories about men, identity, fatherhood, and emotional intelligence—and a trusted home for the national conversation about masculinity.

The Good Men Project accepts paid guest posts and provides bulk guest post packages for SEO agencies and resellers. Email [email protected] for more information