Jamie Utt explains that if privilege guilt prevents us from acting against oppression, then it is simply another tool of oppression.
–
I remember well when I was first confronted with my privilege.
I had just started college, and some activists called me out on the ways in which my class and race privilege were showing up in the classroom as well as in activist spaces.
Of course I was indignant. “I’m not privileged! I work hard for everything I have!”
And while I did indeed work hard, that assertion is obviously laughable.
There are all sorts of aspects of my identity that afford me privilege: my race, my gender, my religious upbringing, my intergenerational wealth, my ability, and on and on.
But that didn’t make it any easier for me to hear, and as I realized they were right, I fell into a bit of depression, carrying tremendous guilt and struggling to understand how this could be true.
I felt as if I was a bad person simply for being who I am, and I was trapped in shame.
“I’m a racist, classist, sexist, ableist homophobe who is ruining everything everywhere.” Yeah, it’s a little dramatic, but it’s honestly reflective of how I felt.
In the midst of my wrestling with this guilt and inertia, I noticed a quote on the dorm room wall of a girl I was totes crushing on:
I didn’t think much of it the first time I saw it. Or the second time. But since I was hanging around in her room a lot, the quote kept showing up for me, and after a while, it really hit me.
I had to find a way to move out of guilt if I wanted to make a difference.
In time I came to realize that if privilege guilt prevents me from acting against oppression, then it is simply another tool of oppression, and sitting in guilt means further colluding with the system that is making me feel shame.
In turn, we have to find a way to move through or past guilt and toward action against oppression.
And though the process of overcoming privilege guilt must inevitably be intensely personal, there are approaches to ending feelings of guilt that all people of privilege can take.
—
Approaches to Moving Through or Past Privilege Guilt
1. Self-Reflect
If you’re struggling with shame about your identity and your privilege, that guilt is rooted somewhere, and understanding those roots is important.
Is your guilt coming from your active collusion in oppression? Is it rooted in past action? Is it rooted in feelings of powerlessness about the big-picture problems of oppression?
Without a strong understanding of where our guilt comes from, it is impossible to overcome guilt and accountably act for social justice.
After all, if our guilt is rooted in past oppressive actions, knowing so allows us to forgive ourselves and, perhaps, apologize to others for our hurtful behavior so that we can move forward.
If our guilt stems from our own collusion with oppression, lacking such awareness will only lead to “White knighting,” a term I use as a catchall for acting for or on behalf of those we wish to help. Having knowledge of our own collusion, then, allows us to begin to take steps toward solidarity.
2. Understand and Accept Your Role in Oppression
In my own experience, I’ve found that privilege guilt seems strongest in those who say things like “I’ve never personally owned a slave, and I just feel sick about racism that exists today! But why should I be held responsible for things that happened in the past if I care about making the world better?”
In the end, all this attitude allows is for the person speaking to ignore the ways in which their privilege actually makes them responsible for injustice and oppression.
And as such, it is no solution for privilege guilt.
On the other hand, understanding the fundamental ways in which I, as a person of privilege, collude with oppression every day, empowers me to act.
After all, if I am aware of the ways in which I contribute to oppression in my daily life, I can seek the knowledge and understanding I need to act for change in ways that might actually have an impact.
Simultaneously, the lack of understanding of our own collusion in oppression leads to action that lacks accountability. For example, if that #FitchtheHomeless dude had considered the ways that his little “campaign” would actually further the oppression of people experiencing homelessness, he might have reconsidered his choice of action.
Much of the time, when people are asking you to “check your privilege,” they are not telling you that you should feel guilt about your identity.
They are simply asking you to consider the ways that your words or actions are furthering oppression so that you can act differently.
3. Recognize that Knowledge of Privilege is not Enough
For a lot of people of privilege, the initial realization of their position in society is huge, even devastating. For me, it was shocking (sadly), and it led to a lot of self-doubt and guilt.
And then a professor and mentor woke me up. He said:
“The fact that you’ve inherited privilege and an oppressive system is not your fault. You should not feel guilty about that. But if you understand your privilege and that you participate in oppression and do nothing, then you have plenty to feel guilt about.”
Action, specifically action that is grounded in accountability and community, is vital to moving through and past privilege guilt. So long as we only acknowledge our privilege, we can get stuck in a cycle of inertia and self-doubt.
Actively working for justice as part of a movement, one where we listen and learn to make certain our action is needed and wanted, is not only healing, but it is vital to ensuring that we transcend guilt.
As we move toward action, though, we need to understand the distinction between acting for or acting on behalf of as opposed to acting with and in solidarity across difference.
One of my biggest pet peeves is when I hear people of privilege say that they plan to “use their privilege to help [insert oppressed group].”
While privilege can sometimes be leveraged as part of action, to see our privilege as something we can use to help only recreates and reinforces the very systems of oppression we claim to oppose.
To recreate the system of identity privilege, even as we seek to “help,” ensures that our action remains marginal and irrelevant at best or oppressive and marginalizing at worst.
Instead, we need to think of ways that we can step back or create space. Mia McKenzie talks about this some in her piece 4 Ways to Push Back Against Your Privilege.
And we must take those ideas and expand upon them, finding ways that work within our daily lives and our communities that allow us to move beyond knowledge of privilege and into concerted action against oppression.
4. Participate In and/or Create Community Acting for Justice
A sure-fire way to ensure one remains stuck in a place of shame about privilege is to wallow alone or simply spend time with those who do not much care to talk about privilege and oppression. Sure, distractions work for a while, but the guilt inevitably comes creeping back in.
And action, when done alone, is unlikely to be either accountable or effective. Thus, we must act in community, joining the chorus of voices working to overturn systems of oppression.
In some cases, that means finding ways to participate in those communities that already exist.
When spaces are open to those striving to be allies (keep in mind that not all spaces will or should welcome people of privilege), show up.
Listen, offer to help in ways that take the lead from the marginalized and oppressed, and use your skills to help the cause. In doing so, though, be aware of the space you occupy and the amount of energy you demand of others.
Other times, you may have to foster and create community, yourself.
Start discussions with people who share your privileges, and call them into the work you are doing. Find ways to support and to be supported by people who share your identity, in part because you can better understand each other’s experience and in part so that you don’t need to draw energy from those to whom you are working to be an ally.
Regardless, participating in community is vital for holding oneself accountable and for learning and growing.
But within that community, it is also important to understand the difference between being an ally and friendship. Sometimes friends can be allies, and allies can be friends. Other times someone may need an ally but have no interest in your friendship. Recognizing that those two words, ally and friend, are not synonyms is important for acting effectively in solidarity.
5. Stay in Touch with Why You Feel Guilty
As you move through and past privilege guilt, it’s important to never let it fade too far from your memory and experience. After all, you felt guilty for a reason.
Keeping the reasons for your guilty feelings close can help make you less likely to collude with oppression moving forward, but it can also help you understand why you choose to act against oppression.
Staying in touch with our guilt is important for making sure that our action isn’t paternalistic, that we’re not acting just to relieve our feelings of shame.
Instead, when we know why we were feeling privilege guilt, we can better ensure that our action is one of true solidarity, one reflective of the words of Aboriginal Elder Lila Watson:
“If you’ve come here to help me, you’re wasting your time. But if you’ve come because your liberation is bound up with mine, then let us work together.”
By knowing, understanding, and holding onto the why of our guilt, we are better able to remember that we have a responsibility to act.
After all, “guilt is a luxury we can no longer afford.” And we are all responsible for moving past it and toward a world of justice.
What’s Next? Talk with others. Take action.
We are proud of our SOCIAL INTEREST GROUPS—WEEKLY PHONE CALLS to discuss, gain insights, build communities— and help solve some of the most difficult challenges the world has today. Calls are for Members Only (although you can join the first call for free). Not yet a member of The Good Men Project? Join now!
Join The Good Men Project Community
All levels get to view The Good Men Project site AD_FREE. The $50 Platinum Level is an ALL-ACCESS PASS—join as many groups and classes as you want for the entire year. The $25 Gold Level gives you access to any ONE Social Interest Group and ONE Class–and other benefits listed below the form. Or…for $12, join as a Bronze Member and support our mission, and have a great ad-free viewing experience.
Register New Account
Please note: If you are already a writer/contributor at The Good Men Project, log in here before registering. (Request new password if needed).
◊♦◊
ANNUAL PLATINUM membership ($50 per year) includes:
1. AN ALL ACCESS PASS — Join ANY and ALL of our weekly calls, Social Interest Groups, classes, workshops and private Facebook groups. We have at least one group phone call or online class every day of the week.
2. See the website with no ads when logged in!
3. MEMBER commenting badge.
***
ANNUAL GOLD membership ($25 per year) includes all the benefits above — but only ONE Weekly Social Interest Group and ONE class.
***
ANNUAL BRONZE membership ($12 per year) is great if you are not ready to join the full conversation but want to support our mission anyway. You’ll still get a BRONZE commenting badge, and you can pop into any of our weekly Friday Calls with the Publisher when you have time. This is for people who believe—like we do—that this conversation about men and changing roles and goodness in the 21st century is one of the most important conversations you can have today.
♦◊♦
We have pioneered the largest worldwide conversation about what it means to be a good man in the 21st century. Your support of our work is inspiring and invaluable.
◊♦◊
“Here’s the thing about The Good Men Project. We are trying to create big, sweeping, societal changes—–overturn stereotypes, eliminate racism, sexism, homophobia, be a positive force for good for things like education reform and the environment. And we’re also giving individuals the tools they need to make individual change—-with their own relationships, with the way they parent, with their ability to be more conscious, more mindful, and more insightful. For some people, that could get overwhelming. But for those of us here at The Good Men Project, it is not overwhelming. It is simply something we do—–every day. We do it with teamwork, with compassion, with an understanding of systems and how they work, and with shared insights from a diversity of viewpoints.” —– Lisa Hickey, Publisher of The Good Men Project and CEO of Good Men Media Inc.
–
Originally appeared at Everyday Feminism
Jamie Utt is a Contributing Writer at Everyday Feminism. He is the Founder and Director of Education at CivilSchools, a comprehensive bullying prevention program, a diversity and inclusion consultant, and sexual violence prevention educator based in Minneapolis, MN. He lives with his loving partner and his funtastic dog. He blogs weekly at Change from Within. Learn more about his work at his website here and follow him on Twitter @utt_jamie. Read his articles here and book him for speaking engagements here.
–
Photo: Flickr/durera_toujours
Oh goodie, another self flagellating male feminist attempting to convince the masses that it’s our responsibility to embrace collective guilt trips.
To who ever wrote this delusional manifesto: Please be advised that your inability to stand up for yourself makes you a poor advocate for what ever loopy progressive cause you assume the rest our your gender should rightfully champion. We’re not all Marxist feminist. We work for a living.
Expecting and driving accountability (from self and others) is the penicillin that kills the victim mentality. If one of my managers told me “My workstream is behind timeline because I am a gay black man” I think I would probably burst out laughing and check the calendar to see if it was April 1st. He’s gotten to his position because he is smart and engaging guy who gets the job done and does really well in front of the client.
Anyone remember Pat Tillman? After 9-11 he gave up a career in pro football to become an Army Ranger. When he was killed by friendly fire in Afghanistan the Army tried to cover up what really happened and use his death for publicity. His “privilege” didn’t stop a bullet, or keep him from being as expendable as anyone else.
Agree with your assessment of the guilt dynamic.
Psychologically, guilt is an emotion that should moderate more extreme forms of selfishness by promoting cooperation and even certain forms of altruism. When used politically, as is often the case, against the “rich”, for example, and their opulence and conspicuous consumption habits, it morphs into class warfare – which in my view is the inevitable artifact of this political social meme.
Sorry if this double posted – if so, please omit.. “The privileged feel guilt because of something they did, not something that was done to them… Because even if you know that you personally didn’t do this or that, you are part of the group that made the choice to actively participating in lessening the worth of other people in society… Privileged feel guilt because they ARE the society telling the minorities that they have less worth. The minority didn’t do anything to feel guilt. Something was done TO them to feel guilt.” To me, this statement here encapsulates the… Read more »
Agree with your assessment of the guilt dynamic.
Psychologically, guilt is an emotion that should moderate more extreme forms of selfishness by promoting cooperation and even certain forms of altruism. When used politically, as is often the case, against the “rich”, for example, and their opulence and conspicuous consumption habits, it morphs into class warfare – which in my view is the inevitable artifact of this political social meme.
“‘I’m a racist, classist, sexist, ableist homophobe who is ruining everything everywhere.’ Yeah, it’s a little dramatic, but it’s honestly reflective of how I felt… After all, if I am aware of the ways in which I contribute to oppression in my daily life, I can seek the knowledge and understanding I need to act for change in ways that might actually have an impact.” Given the very personal nature of guilt, and the subjectivity of these criteria, I would really like know what specific bars/standards/barometers you personally use or used to classify your behavior, thoughts & attitudes as such. What… Read more »
I don’t know if Jamie Utt is really feeling guilty, or he is just trying to score points for showing how enlightened he is. To borrow an old saying, he needs to climb down from the cross, because someone else needs the wood.
“The privileged feel guilt because of something they did, not something that was done to them… Because even if you know that you personally didn’t do this or that, you are part of the group that made the choice to actively participating in lessening the worth of other people in society… Privileged feel guilt because they ARE the society telling the minorities that they have less worth. The minority didn’t do anything to feel guilt. Something was done TO them to feel guilt.” To me, this statement here encapsulates the entire paradox and (I feel) the very hypocrisy of the… Read more »
If “privilege” was ever a useful concept (and I believe that at one point it was) then it has become so watered down and misused by internet slackivists that it has lost all meaning. “check your privilege” is the new “know your place.” it’s not a call to introspection, it’s a bludgeon. A weapon of the self-righteous. It’s become a way to count coup and earn points in the call out game.
I agree. It is just a slogan like “Mission Accomplished” or “Yes We Can.” It requires no real thought.
John, Philly, Wes and 8ball, ya;ll are top of this. I really like “slackavists.” We need to use the term more so that it can be added to Websters.
Of course, pointing out another’s privilege is itself the exercise of privilege. Or just a way of avoiding accountability…
Once I was approaching a street corner. 2 women were standing waiting to cross. One was blind. I was coming up behind the blind woman when the light changed. The other woman started crossing the street. I mentioned that the light was green and the blind woman started crossing also. When we reached the other side, I told her you’re across. She thanked me. The interesting thing was the other woman started asking her where she was going (a different direction than I) and offered to walk her there. I think she felt guilty that she wasn’t the person to… Read more »
It seems pretty presumptuous to assume other people automatically need, or even want help. I have
no problem helping someone if they ask. There are plenty of “White Knights” around who make it their mission in life to come to the rescue of women to make themselves look better.
Minorities feel guilt (shame?) because they are told by society at large that they have less worth Privileged feel guilt because they ARE the society telling the minorities that they have less worth. The minority didn’t do anything to feel guilt. Something was done TO them to feel guilt. The privileged feel guilt because of something they did, not something that was done to them. I believe this is why the privileged have such a hard time understanding privilege. Because even if you know that you personally didn’t do this or that, you are part of the group that made… Read more »
Guilt is a choice. You can’t impose guilt on another. It has to be accepted. I don’t see how being a white, heterosexual male is a privilege. Seriously. – We are the least publicly funded demographic. – The majority of males in the west start their lives with genital mutilation. – Girls are given extra programs and help over boys in school. – School’s in general are tailored more towards girl’s learning styles over boys. – Boys are told over and over growing up, masculinity is a pathology that needs to be fixed. – Enrollment rates in university are almost… Read more »
Brand … what you stated plus a couple of others of my own is why I feel no guilt in relationship to society. With all the pit falls I’ve experienced in life, I don’t see myself as privileged either.
Right off the top, without giving any thought, you can add:
– Un-diagnosed mental health illnesses
– Casualties of war
– Government mandated selective service
– male suicide rates
– No male centered medical facilities for breast cancer. (Added because of a recent GMP article on male breast cancer)
Oh, and this one.
– Lack of battered shelters for MEN and boys
Because even if you know that you personally didn’t do this or that, you are part of the group that made the choice to actively participating in lessening the worth of other people in society.
That’s guilty by association. Sharing demographics with someone doesn’t mean that you engage in such activities. This is the same line of logic that gives rise to the idea that all men benefit from rape. How does being a part of that group make you inherently privileged?
This is what I’m talking about. There is this narrative that I should feel guilty for being a part of something that I wasn’t a part of. It just seems illogical to feel that way. I imagine that those who struggle with such a feeling have a pretty rough time.
I never got this whole white guilt thing. Or this need for men of certain ideologies to prostrate themselves before women so completely. It seems very undignified, and must be pretty difficult to live with sometimes.
How about not feeling guilty at all rather than jumping through a series of hoops put in front of you by others? Why should one be put into a place of feeling badly about themselves by comparison to others? By extension, should one feel jealous of someone who is treated better? It seems to me that that sort of thinking is the crux of the idea of privilege in the first place. Monitor your own behavior and make sure you’re a good person. Treat others fairly and if you hold any “ism” of your own, rectify those attitudes. If you… Read more »
Guilt is just a means of manipulation, nothing more. Whether it comes from parents, teachers, religion or whatever group using it. It is just about getting you to do what they want. Feeling bad about something you screwed up is normal. You try not to repeat it and fix the problem if possible. But don’t let someone else hold it over you as a means of control.
Indeed – no coincidence that those agitating for change use privilege as a concept to guilt people with.