Common Communication Mistakes

Every relationship, no matter how loving or enduring, faces its share of communication hurdles. Dr. John Gottman is perhaps the most prolific and foundational researcher of couples relationships, studying hundreds of couples over decades. Gottman discovered specific patterns of interaction that can predict the health and longevity of a relationship. His work offers couples a roadmap for understanding where their communication suffers and how they can get back on track.

Dr. Gottman began his work in the 1970s, meticulously studying thousands of couples in both observational “Love Lab” settings and long-term studies. Unlike polls or correlational studies, the latter are what allowed Gottman and his associates to definitively determine factors that strengthen or weaken relationships over time. Using a scientific approach — replete with physiological monitoring, detailed video analysis, and in-depth interviews — Gottman identified key behaviors that could predict with astonishing accuracy whether a couple would stay together or break up.

The “Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse,” as Gottman calls them, are four common communication patterns most destructive to relationships: Criticism, Contempt, Defensiveness, and Stonewalling. These patterns, creating dysfunctional interaction cycles, were found to be consistent predictors of marital dissatisfaction and divorce.

Gottman’s Four Horsemen Explained

· Criticism: Criticism is an attack on a partner’s character or personality. For example, “You never clean up — you’re so lazy.” Criticism is harmful because it often makes the recipient feel attacked, rejected, and hurt. This tends to prompt the horseman of defensiveness, setting off a cycle of escalating negativity.

· Contempt: Considered the most poisonous of the four, contempt involves speaking to a partner in a patronizing way, or with mockery, sarcasm, or eye-rolling. This pattern conveys disgust and superiority, eroding the foundation of respect and admiration on which healthy relationships are built. Gottman’s research has shown that contempt is the single best predictor of divorce, as it conveys an air of moral superiority that is interpersonally corrosive.

· Defensiveness: When feeling attacked or blamed, people often respond defensively. The common element to all defensiveness is deflection of responsibility, but it can take different forms, such as making excuses, denying responsibility, or counter-attacking. Defensiveness may seem like a reasonable self-protection strategy, but it actually amplifies conflict, as it communicates to partners that their concerns are not being heard or taken seriously.

· Stonewalling: The fourth horseman occurs when one partner withdraws from interaction, shuts down emotionally, or refuses to engage further in communication. This often happens when someone feels overwhelmed or physiologically flooded and can neither listen nor respond constructively. Over time, stonewalling creates distance and a sense of abandonment.

Beyond the Four Horsemen: Other Common Communication Mistakes

While the Four Horsemen are the most researched and predictive patterns, couples frequently fall into additional communication traps that erode connection and intimacy. As you read through these pitfalls, it’s easy to notice the ones your partner succumbs to, but you’ll get more mileage out of noticing the tendencies you yourself have in your relationship and working to improve yourself.

1. Mind Reading and Assumptions

Rather than articulating needs or feelings, partners sometimes assume that their significant other should “just know” what they want or feel. This leads to misunderstandings, resentment, and frustration.

2. Passive-Aggressive Behavior

Instead of expressing frustration or disappointment directly, one partner might use sarcasm, subtle digs, or other more passive indirect behavior to communicate dissatisfaction or unhappiness. This fosters mistrust, sustains a negative cycle of hurt and counter-hurt, and makes it hard for couples to address underlying issues,.

3. Over generalization

Arguments may escalate quickly when partners use generalized, absolute language such as “always” or “never.” Such statements intensify conflict by provoking the partner to correct the record.

4. Poor Listening Skills

True listening is active and empathic. Many times, however, we are working on our rebuttals while half-listening, rather than temporarily putting aside our own grievances and working to truly understand our partner’s perspective. This results in each person talking past the other and butting heads.

5. Failure to Repair

Gottman’s research shows that effective couples make frequent “repair attempts” during conflict. These are gestures or statements intended to de-escalate tension or reconnect. In fact, he found that what he calls the “master couples” have five positive interactions for every one negative, even during conflictual conversations.

6. Bottling Up Emotions, or Over-expressing

Suppressing feelings to “keep the peace” often backfires, as confined emotions eventually surface — sometimes explosively. This tends to happen most often with “people pleasers” who, out of their fear of conflict, do not talk about the little irritations or wishes until they reach the breaking point.

On the other hand, another losing strategy — according to couples therapist Terry Real — is “unbridled expression.” This involves blasting your partner with your emotions, especially anger, frustration, or disappointment (often combined with criticism, or personal attack). Partners may justify doing so as being “honest,” but it is actually destructive.

7. Bringing Up the Past

Dragging old grievances into current disagreements undermines trust and slows resolution. It usually has the unwanted effect of rubbing salt into the wound of the current situation. Past hurts may need to be addressed, but they often need to be processed separately rather than as part of a current situation, and you need to have the tools to do so constructively.

8. Lack of Appreciation

Expressing gratitude and appreciation is essential for relationship health and for offsetting negativity bias. As Gottman puts it, master couples make a habit of noticing, savoring, and expressing the good things in their relationship and their partners.

At this point, you may be wondering: “Okay, now I have a list of all the things that I or we may be doing wrong, but how do we do it better?” Antidotes to all of these communication problems are included in the full article on my Web site. (BTW, the more you avoid these traps in all areas of your life, the more successful you will be.)

Strong communication is the lifeblood of a healthy relationship, yet even the most devoted couples may stumble into common traps. Gottman’s Four Horsemen framework — grounded in decades of robust research — provides some lenses for recognizing destructive patterns and making intentional changes. By cultivating self-awareness, learning skills towards more productive dialogue, and practicing empathy and appreciation, couples can navigate inevitable conflict with resilience, and build lasting relationships.

Robert Solley is a psychologist with a private practice in The Mission, San Francisco

—

This post was previously published on medium.com.