—
Editor’s note: This Open Letter was posted by the author in our Good Men Project Writers’ Group as an invitation for discussion on the intersection of childhood abuse and being a nice guy.
—
Letter from a N*ce Guy
I apologize in advance because a lot has been said about the topic of Nice Guys and dating, to the point where it has become nauseating.
I wanted to come at this issue from another perspective, to speak my deep personal truth about my experience with this topic and also point out something sorely missing from this discourse.
I will not express resentment, bitterness or anger. I will come as much as I can from my heart.
I am not the guy that will text angry messages after a rejection. I am not the guy that will talk constantly about past women I have dated while on a date. I will not make misogynistic comments to a woman about the state of dating. I do not feel entitled to anything physical from a woman.
What I am is a victim of childhood abuse and deep trauma.
I grew up watching my father pummel my mother physically. From an emotional perspective. My brother bullied me so unmercifully that I made a habit of calculating what to say to people I interacted with as to not be punished. That is how I spent my nights.
I have no extended family to speak of. I came to the US when I was five, speaking no English and not having ever gone to school before. It was terrifying. That is how I spent my days.
Although I was often left alone because she worked and went to school full time, my mother was the only caretaker I ever knew as a child that did not attack me. I love her so much.
Even at thirty-three years old, when I am stressed out I remember cuddling with her when it was just the two of us and this memory instantly soothes me.
Therefore, to the best of my psychological and spiritual understanding, this is the kind of Nice Guy that I am:
1. I have a deep respect for women.
2. I get emotional very quickly about any woman I meet that I find attractive as the potential of that bond reminds me of the only positive emotion I felt as a child.
3. My father was cruel to my Mother and she hated it. I concluded therefore that to create a relationship with a woman, I should be kind to her.
4. Rejection is excruciatingly painful as I entangle it with being abandoned by my mother.
5. I am so terrified of intimacy, I disassociate and shut down when I am spending time with a woman to the point that creating a spark, chemistry, etc. is impossible.
Therefore, to my understanding and to the understanding of every psychologist that I have been to, receiving affection from
a member of the opposite sex that I am attracted to is impossible because I was abused as a child.
Please read that again and let that sink in. Feel it… receiving affection from a member of the opposite sex I am attracted to is impossible because I was abused as a child.
And this makes me exhibit the behaviour that is most often ascribed to the Nice Guy.
The pain I feel when realizing this is so overwhelming it makes me dizzy. It has brought me numerous times to the verge of suicide. It has made me so depressed that I retreat to substance abuse out of self-reproach.
I am actively working on correcting these subconscious processes. It feels like pulling myself out of hell. I do not know to what extent I will succeed and if I can ever achieve a healthy dating life.
One thing I do know by reaching out to other people over the years ….. many and probably most Nice Guys come from socially malfunctioned backgrounds of one sort or another and are unable to overcome them. They suffer from social anxiety and depression. They are in deep isolation. They live in a society that still largely judges males by their ability to create connections with the opposite sex and teaches them not to express their emotions. Even in the dating advice pages of the Good Men Project, where emotional expression from men is seen as a requisite virtue for our society to survive, they are told to grow up and become stronger. No mourning, no grieving. Get yourself together and go. Something is wrong with you so fix it.
We need a new way forward. I do not want anyone to experience this unique pain. Suggestions are welcome, just please be Nice 🙂
—
What’s your take on what you just read? Comment below or write a response and submit to us your own point of view or reaction here at the red box, below, which links to our submissions portal.
◊♦◊
Sign up for our Writing Prompts email to receive writing inspiration in your inbox twice per week.
If you believe in the work we are doing here at The Good Men Project, please join us as a Premium Member, today.
All Premium Members get to view The Good Men Project with NO ADS.
A $50 annual membership gives you an all-access pass. You can be a part of every call, group, class, and community.
A $25 annual membership gives you access to one class, one Social Interest group, and our online communities.
A $12 annual membership gives you access to our Friday calls with the publisher, our online community.
Register New Account
Need more info? A complete list of benefits is here.
—
Photo credit: Getty Images

