The ‘What Ifs’ That Steal My Voice

If you haven’t become a member yet, click here to read for free!

“Not being able to talk is not the same as not having something to say.” — Rosemary Crossley

…

“What’s wrong?”

“Nothing.”

“Are you sure?”

“Yeah.”

And just like that, another conversation dies before it even starts.

You want to say something. You really do. But the words don’t come. So instead, you sit there, nodding, forcing a smile, hoping they don’t notice the storm inside your head.

You tell yourself you’ll explain later. Maybe tomorrow. Maybe next week. But somehow, later never comes.

So why does this happen? Why do some people find it easier to keep everything locked inside, even when they want to talk?

“We speak not only to tell others what we think, but to tell ourselves what we think.” — Oliver Sacks

…

The Science of Being Speechless

Most people assume that if you don’t talk about something, it’s because you don’t want to. But sometimes, your brain just doesn’t let you.

Ever heard of Broca’s area? It’s the part of your brain that helps you form words. But here’s the thing, Bessel van der Kolk, in The Body Keeps the Score (2014), found that when you’re under extreme stress or dealing with trauma, that part of your brain can literally shut down. Your body goes into survival mode, and suddenly, words feel impossible.

It’s why some people freeze up when they try to talk about something painful. Why you might rehearse a conversation in your head, but when it’s time to actually speak, all you can manage is a shrug and a quiet, “I don’t know.”

And it’s not just trauma. John Gottman, in The Science of Trust (2011), found that if someone has been dismissed or invalidated too many times — if they’ve heard things like “You’re overreacting” or “It’s not that deep” — their brain starts treating vulnerability as a threat. They learn that opening up isn’t worth the risk.

So if you’ve ever struggled to talk, it’s not just in your head. Your brain is literally trying to protect you.

“Silence isn’t empty. It’s full of things you’re too afraid to say.” — Unknown

…

Why Some People Just… Don’t Talk

Your Brain Thinks Silence = Safety
If every time you opened up, you were met with rejection, criticism, or discomfort, your brain starts treating silence as the safer option.
You Have No Idea Where to Start
Some emotions are so tangled that putting them into words feels impossible. So instead of saying something wrong, you say nothing at all.
You’re Afraid of Being ‘Too Much’
Nobody wants to be the person who “kills the vibe.” So instead of risking that, you bottle everything up and pretend you’re fine.
You’ve Been Shut Down Before
If you’ve ever been told to “get over it” or that you were “being dramatic,” you might have learned that silence hurts less than being dismissed.
You Don’t Want to Say It Wrong
What if you mess up your words? What if they misunderstand? For some people, the fear of explaining things wrong is enough to keep them quiet forever.

“The worst part of holding the memories is not the pain. It’s the loneliness of it. Memories need to be shared.” — Lois Lowry, The Giver (1993)

…

The Loudest Silences

“Dude, where have you been? You just disappeared.”

“Sorry, I’ve been busy.”

That’s the official excuse. The truth? You didn’t know how to reach out.

Or maybe this…

“Are you okay?”

“Yeah, I’m fine.”

They believe you. You let them believe you. Because explaining would take too much effort, and honestly? You don’t even know where to start.

Or maybe it’s the friend who’s always there for you, always checking in, always listening, but never actually talks about their own struggles.

Some silences say more than words ever could.

“Sometimes, people don’t want to hear the truth because they don’t want their illusions destroyed.” — Friedrich Nietzsche

…

How I Started Unlocking the Words

I know what it’s like to sit in a room full of people and feel completely alone because the words just won’t come out.

For me, the first step was realizing that I wasn’t broken.

I remember reading The Body Keeps the Score (2014) and finally understanding why my brain would just… shut down. Why I could be full of thoughts but completely incapable of saying them out loud.

Then, I started noticing patterns.

Writing was easier than talking.
So I started there. At first, it was just journaling. Then, I wrote letters I never sent. Eventually, I started sending them. One day, I left a voice note instead of texting. It wasn’t perfect, but it was a start.
I had to choose the right people.
Not everyone is safe to talk to. And that’s okay. I stopped expecting deep conversations from people who only wanted small talk. Instead, I found the ones who actually listened.
Therapy helped.
I won’t lie it took me a long time to actually go. But when I finally did, my therapist didn’t force me to talk. Sometimes, we just sat in silence. And somehow, that made it easier.
Small conversations lead to bigger ones.
At first, I just talked about random stuff, music, books, something funny that happened. Then, one day, I found myself saying, “Actually, yeah, I haven’t been doing great.” And that was the beginning of something real.
I stopped thinking I had to ‘explain’ everything.
Sometimes, you don’t have the perfect words. That’s okay. Even a simple, “I don’t really know how to talk about this, but I’m trying,” can be enough.

“There is no greater agony than bearing an untold story inside you.” — Maya Angelou

…

Last But not Least

If you’ve ever struggled to speak, just know:

You’re not broken.
You’re not weak.
And even if the words won’t come right now, you still deserve to be heard.

…

Hey! I want to know does this resonate with you too? Have you ever struggled to speak, even to the people you love? Feel free to share your thoughts or experiences in the comments. I’m here to listen.

And if this article meant something to you, maybe it could help someone else too. Don’t hesitate to share it.

Thank you for reading. Stay strong, and keep going!!!

—

This post was previously published on medium.com.

***