
By Raysa S. Rodriguez, The 74
This story first appeared at The 74, a nonprofit news site covering education. Sign up for free newsletters from The 74 to get more like this in your inbox.
Earlier this month, a federal agent fired seven rounds into a car on a street in New York City’s Marble Hill neighborhood. A five-year-old boy sat in the back seat. Whatever happened in the moments before, nothing explains violence on that scale with a child in the car. The question is what he saw, and what he will carry.
I grew up in Marble Hill. Generations of my family have passed through West 225th Street, and many still live there. It is forever my home: a hard-working, largely immigrant community where the elevated 1 train rumbles past every few minutes and no one looks up.
What happened there is not one family’s story. Immigration and Customs Enforcement arrests in New York City peaked in July, the highest since the start of 2025. In Corona, Queens, community volunteers have mobilized to respond to immigration arrests, distributing know-your-rights information to parents at school pickup. This anxiety has followed families to the school door.
This is not a small group of children living with this fear. CCC’s 2026 Keeping Track of New York City’s Children finds that an estimated 267,000 children, 17% of the city’s children, live in mixed-status households where at least one family member is undocumented. More than a quarter of them are under age 5 — younger than the boy in that car. Immigrant families with children live in every borough, from Washington Heights and Inwood, where 20% of residents are non-citizens, to Corona and Elmhurst, where the share is 37%.
Research shows what this fear costs. After immigration raids in California last year, daily student absences rose 22% among more than 100,000 children, according to a peer-reviewed Stanford study. Another study found higher post-traumatic stress symptoms among U.S.-born children whose parents were detained or deported than among their peers.
Children do not need to be the target of enforcement to be harmed by it. Witnessing it, or fearing it, is enough. In a school system where one in three students was already chronically absent last year, fear is one more barrier NYC public school students cannot afford.
New York City already strictly bars federal agents without a judicial warrant from entering public schools. But children are most exposed in the spaces between home and school — the sidewalk at dismissal, the line of cars at drop-off, the entrance to a child care center. Protection must now extend to those spaces.
City and state leaders must act on three fronts:
- Strengthen and extend protocols beyond school buildings to drop-off, dismissal, and the routes children travel, and to child care centers and family child care programs. Every provider should know what to do when enforcement happens nearby.
- Notify families quickly, in the languages they speak. An estimated 216,600 children live in households with limited English proficiency. An alert sent only in English does not reach them.
- Fund mental health support in the schools and early childhood programs where children have witnessed or been affected by enforcement, starting in Marble Hill. Every public school is now required to designate a liaison for students who avoid school because of social-emotional and other concerns. Train them to recognize enforcement-related fear, beginning with schools near enforcement activity.
Of course, New York is not the only city where children face these threats, and other places can adapt these approaches to protect their residents, as well. City leaders cannot set federal enforcement policy. But congressional delegations can lead the fight to restore the protections, rescinded in January 2025, that limited immigration enforcement in and near schools for decades.
The children of Marble Hill did not choose this moment. City and state leaders can choose how to protect them. Every child, in every neighborhood, deserves to walk home from school without carrying what one 5-year-old in Marble Hill now carries.
—
This story was produced by The 74, a non-profit, independent news organization focused on education in America.
***
If you believe in the work we are doing here at The Good Men Project, please join us as a Premium Member today.
All Premium Members get to view The Good Men Project with NO ADS.
Need more info? A complete list of benefits is here.
Photo credit: unsplash

