In the early ’80s, the air around my preschool smelled of dry grass and wild pine. I was only four years old. At that age, you don’t think about where you’re going. You just notice the way the ground feels under your feet and how big the sky looks. It was a rustic place that felt more like a clearing in the woods than a school, where the line between the playground and the forest was thin.
I remember walking by myself. I don’t know why I was alone or where the teachers were, but I can still feel my small shoes crunching on the path. I was walking along a western-style fence with thick vertical posts and two horizontal logs connecting them. On the other side was an open field. A group of boys were there, wrestling in the dirt. As they grappled and threw each other down, thick clouds of dust rose up into the sunlit air.
They were large boys who seemed to know how to move through the world with noise and force. I watched the chaos and the swirling dust with a mix of awe and a primal kind of dread. Then, the group broke apart. One of the more muscular boys looked up and saw me standing there on the safe side of the logs. He pointed. There was a boy standing next to him who was smaller than the rest, maybe closer to my size. “Hey!” the big boy called out. “Come and wrestle him. You’re his size.”
It wasn’t a friendly invitation. It was a challenge. It was a summons to step through the wooden rails, leave my quiet place on the side, and enter that cloud of dust and struggle. I froze. I didn’t know these boys and I didn’t know the rules. Most importantly, I didn’t know if I had whatever stuff they had, that courage that let them throw themselves into the dirt and come up laughing. I felt the weight of their eyes on me.
I stayed silent. I didn’t even shake my head. I just turned my eyes back to the worn trail and kept moving. I walked away from the fence, the field, and the boys. I don’t remember what they said as I left. They might have snickered, or they might have forgotten me the second I passed the next fence post. But I remember what happened inside of me. A heaviness settled in my chest. It was the first time I ever felt shame.
At four, I didn’t know anything about masculinity or social expectations. I didn’t have the words for it. I just knew I had been called to participate in the world, and I had chosen to stay a spectator. I felt like I had failed a test I didn’t even know I was taking.
Now that I’m in my fifties, I still think about that boy on the path. I realize that the shame I felt wasn’t really about wrestling. It wasn’t about whether I would have won or lost. It was about the act of turning away.
That memory followed me for decades, pointing to the empty space where I thought my grit should have been. Where I grew up, fighting was an unavoidable part of life. While I know now that physical conflict is never the true measure of a man, not knowing if I could face it felt like a ghost haunting my character.
By the time I reached my forties, I realized I had never been in a fight. I had lived a good life, raising a family and building a career, but I still wondered if I would crumble when the world pushed back. So, I called my best friend. We’ve been close since we were on a tee-ball team together at age four, the same age I was when I stood at that fence. He’s much bigger and stronger than me, a man who’s seen real combat. I trusted him enough to ask for a strange favor: “Will you spar with me? I just need to know what it feels like.”
We met in his backyard on a Saturday morning with boxing gloves on. The air was still and the neighborhood was quiet. We began to circle each other. I was nervous, that old familiar urge to retreat pulling at my heels. Then he hit me. I felt the thud of leather on my face, and instinctively, I swung back. I landed a punch, feeling the vibration travel up my arm and settle into my bones.
We sparred in flurries for about five serious minutes until we were both out of breath. Neither of us was hurt, but that morning, the forty-year-old man finally stepped through those wooden logs. I learned that I could give and take a punch if I had to. The deeper insight was that growth doesn’t always require a victory. Sometimes it’s just about facing an old fear.
By choosing to step into that backyard, I wasn’t saying that fighting is the only way to grow. I was acknowledging that I no longer needed to protect myself from the possibility of conflict. I found peace in knowing I could stand my ground. It answered the question the four-year-old boy couldn’t. I did have the stuff after all.
It’s amazing how a moment from fifty years ago can still shape the person I am today. I used to think that shame was a scar or a sign of weakness. But now I see it differently. That shame was the birth of my conscience. It was the first time I realized I had a choice in who I wanted to be.
The real insight wasn’t that I was scared. It was that I cared about being brave. The fact that it hurt to walk away proved that, deep down, I wanted to be in the fight. I wasn’t someone content to stay on the sidelines. I understand now that I wasn’t just afraid of their strength or how hard they could hit, I was also afraid of my own power and what I was capable of doing back.
I’ve spent the last several decades trying to make up for that walk away from the field. In a way, it made me a better man. It made me the person who stays when things get difficult, the person who accepts the challenges even when I’m feeling fear.
I still feel that four-year-old inside me sometimes. He’s there, standing by the wooden fence, watching the dust rise as the big boys wrestle. But I don’t look at him with judgment anymore. I look at him with compassion. I want to go back to that path, kneel down, and tell him, “It’s okay that you walked away today. Because you’re going to spend the rest of your life answering the call. That shame you feel is just your courage waking up.”
The preschool is long gone, and those boys are probably grandfathers by now. But the lesson remains. Life keeps inviting us to wrestle with our fears, our responsibilities, and our definitions of what it means to be strong. I walked away once, but every day since has been an opportunity to turn back toward the field and get a little dust on my clothes.
—
iStock image
