Why Some Criticism Destroys Us — and Other Criticism Barely Touches Us

Two employees work for the same boss.

One day, the boss becomes furious and lashes out at both of them.

“You’re worthless to this business.”

The first employee is devastated.

He goes back to his desk, but he can barely concentrate.

The words keep repeating in his mind.

I’m worthless.

He thinks about them on the way home.

He thinks about them that evening.

He wonders whether everyone at work secretly thinks the same thing.

The second employee walks away, almost amused.

A little while later, the first employee notices this and cannot understand it.

“Didn’t you hear what he said?”

“Of course.”

“He said we’re worthless to the business. How can that not bother you?”

The second employee shrugs.

“Because I know I’m not worthless. I know what I contribute here. Maybe the boss was having a terrible day. Maybe he’s angry about something else. Maybe he’s simply wrong. Why would his saying I’m worthless suddenly make me believe I’m worthless?”

The first employee becomes quiet.

Then he says something revealing.

“Interesting. Because I’ve always wondered whether I really contribute much here. When he said I was worthless, I thought: I knew it. He finally confirmed it.”

Same boss.

Same insult.

Same words.

Two completely different wounds.

Why?

Because sometimes criticism doesn’t create the wound.

It finds one that was already there.

Why Certain Words Hurt So Much

Think about the criticism that stays with you.

Not every insult does.

If someone accused you of being terrible at something you know beyond any doubt you do well, you might laugh.

If someone told you that you were 12 feet tall, you wouldn’t spend the evening standing in front of the mirror worrying about it.

You know it isn’t true.

But let someone criticize the thing you secretly question about yourself, and suddenly a sentence can feel like a verdict.

You’re selfish.

And somewhere inside, you have wondered:

Maybe I am.

You’re not a good parent.

And you’ve already had nights when you asked yourself exactly that.

You’re not very competent.

And you’ve spent years wondering whether everybody else knows what they’re doing while you’re somehow pretending.

You’re a failure.

And perhaps that is the accusation you have been quietly making against yourself.

Then someone else says it.

And it doesn’t feel like one person’s opinion anymore.

It feels like confirmation.

That may be why criticism sometimes hurts far beyond the importance of the person delivering it.

We think we’re reacting only to what someone just said.

Sometimes we’re also reacting to what we’ve been saying to ourselves for years.

Criticism Can Become a Search Warrant

Once criticism touches an insecurity, the mind can do something extraordinary.

It starts searching for evidence.

Someone tells you that you’re selfish.

Suddenly you remember the time you didn’t call.

The favor you refused.

The conversation where you talked too much about yourself.

The person you disappointed three years ago.

Within minutes, one criticism has assembled an entire prosecution.

But notice what happened.

You weren’t investigating yourself neutrally.

You were trying to determine whether a fear about yourself was finally proven true.

That is why one person’s criticism can sometimes outweigh a hundred pieces of evidence pointing in the other direction.

It didn’t arrive in an empty courtroom.

The case against you was already open.

But What If the Criticism Is True?

This is where advice about criticism often becomes useless.

People tell us:

“Don’t care what others think.”

“Just ignore it.”

“Know your worth.”

That’s easy when the critic is wrong.

But what happens when the critic has a point?

What if you really were selfish in that situation?

What if you really handled the meeting badly?

What if you really hurt someone?

What if your boss is right that your performance has slipped?

What if you really did make a terrible decision?

Then what?

Fix it.

That’s all.

Why must:

“I did something badly”

become:

“There is something wrong with me”?

Why must:

“I failed at this”

become:

“I am a failure”?

Why must:

“I wasn’t a good parent in that moment”

become:

“I’m a terrible parent”?

Why must:

“I made a foolish decision”

become:

“I’m a fool”?

The criticism may be completely correct.

But the conclusion you draw from it can still be completely wrong.

A Mistake Is an Instruction, Not an Identity

Imagine your GPS tells you:

Wrong turn.

What do you do?

You correct the route.

You don’t pull over, put your head on the steering wheel, and say:

I am a wrong turn.

That would be absurd.

Yet emotionally, we do something remarkably similar.

Someone identifies something we did wrong, and instead of correcting the behavior, we absorb the behavior into our identity.

The useful message may have been:

Don’t do that again.

We transform it into:

Don’t be you again.

What a terrible waste of criticism.

If someone points out a genuine flaw in something you did, criticism has already given you everything useful it has to offer.

You learned something.

You can apologize if necessary.

You can repair damage.

You can practice.

You can make a different decision next time.

You can grow.

What additional benefit comes from hating yourself?

Does humiliation make the apology more sincere?

Does calling yourself worthless improve your judgment?

Does lying awake replaying the mistake make you more capable?

Does destroying your confidence somehow undo what happened?

Usually not.

You can take the lesson without taking the sentence.

Put Criticism Back in Its Proper Size

The next time criticism hurts you, don’t immediately ask:

“Is this person right about me?”

That question is too large.

Ask:

“What exactly might this person be right about?”

Be specific.

Not:

Am I selfish?

Instead:

Was I selfish in that conversation?

Not:

Am I incompetent?

Instead:

Did I prepare poorly for that meeting?

Not:

Am I a bad spouse?

Instead:

Did I dismiss my spouse’s feelings last night?

Not:

Am I a failure?

Instead:

What exactly failed, and what could I do differently next time?

Now criticism has been reduced from a judgment of a human being to information about an event.

And events can be examined.

Behaviors can be changed.

Skills can be learned.

Apologies can be made.

Mistakes can be corrected.

Find the Belief Beneath the Pain

But there is another question worth asking.

If a criticism hurts you enormously, ask yourself:

“What did I already believe about myself that made those words hurt this much?”

That question can reveal more than the criticism itself.

If being called incompetent devastates you, perhaps the deeper problem isn’t your boss.

Maybe you’ve been terrified for years that you aren’t capable enough.

If someone questioning your parenting destroys you, perhaps you’ve already been grading yourself brutally as a parent.

If one rejection makes you feel worthless, perhaps your self-worth was already waiting for someone else to approve it.

The goal isn’t to blame yourself for being hurt.

The goal is to discover where another person’s words acquired so much authority.

Because once you see the preexisting belief, you can finally examine that too.

Is it true?

Is it completely true?

What evidence contradicts it?

Did one mistake become your definition?

Did one period of failure become your biography?

Have you confused an area where you need growth with a verdict on your worth?

Try the Two-Question Rule

The next time someone criticizes you, ask yourself two questions.

First: Is there anything here I should fix?

If no, let the criticism belong to the person who gave it.

Maybe they misunderstood.

Maybe they were angry.

Maybe they have their own issues.

Maybe they’re simply wrong.

But if the answer is yes, don’t run away from it.

Say:

“Okay. I see it. I’ll work on that.”

Then ask the second question:

“Why should this change what I believe I am worth?”

Those are two entirely different questions.

One concerns growth.

The other concerns worth.

We get into trouble when we combine them.

You can need improvement and still possess worth.

You can have flaws and still possess worth.

You can make an embarrassing mistake and still possess worth.

You can receive criticism that is absolutely correct and still possess worth.

In fact, being able to say “You’re right. I need to work on that” without collapsing may be one of the strongest forms of self-confidence there is.

The Strongest Person in the Room

We sometimes imagine that a confident person is someone who cannot be criticized.

I think the opposite may be closer to the truth.

The strongest person may be the one who can hear:

“You were wrong.”

and answer:

“You’re right.”

Without hearing:

“You are worthless.”

He can apologize without becoming humiliated.

He can learn without becoming small.

He can change without deciding that everything about him needs changing.

He can take criticism seriously without allowing criticism to become his identity.

Because he understands something crucial:

Self-worth and self-improvement are not enemies.

You don’t have to destroy one to achieve the other.

Take the Lesson. Leave the Verdict.

There will always be people who criticize you.

Some will be wrong.

Some will be cruel.

Some will speak from anger, jealousy, frustration, or ignorance.

And sometimes—perhaps more often than we would like—they will be right.

But even then, you have a choice.

You can turn criticism into a weapon:

I’m worthless.

I’m a failure.

I knew there was something wrong with me.

Or you can turn it into information:

I shouldn’t have done that.

I need to improve this.

I owe someone an apology.

Next time, I’ll handle it differently.

One response destroys you.

The other develops you.

So when criticism comes, don’t automatically run from it.

And don’t automatically surrender to it.

Look at it.

Examine it.

Take whatever truth belongs to you.

Correct whatever needs correcting.

And then leave the rest behind.

A mistake can tell you what to change.

It does not get to tell you what you are worth.

Take the lesson.

Fix the mistake.

And move on.

Because criticism should be allowed to improve your next decision without being allowed to define the person who makes it.

—

iStock image