
“To love at all is to be vulnerable.” — C.S. Lewis, The Four Loves
My daughter called me the other night with a story about a party at the house of an old high school classmate. Let’s call him Mason. The two lost touch after graduation but ended up working in the same city as adults, which is how they reconnected.
Mason is in his mid 20s, has a solid job, and recently bought his own house in the suburbs, no small thing at that age. He’s serious minded, intellectual, kind, thoughtful, and generous. He cooks well enough to put on a real spread.
He’s tried the dating apps without much luck. Matches don’t come easily, and when they do, they rarely turn into anything real. So he tried something different: instead of a screen, he’d try real life. He threw a Fourth of July dinner party at his new house and filled it with a wide mix of guests: coworkers, married couples from his church, and a few single women he hoped to get to know better.
My daughter was one of the guests. She noticed the single women there had no idea what Mason was hoping for. They spoke to him the way they’d speak to any host, warmly, easily, like a friend. Nothing about the evening gave them reason to think otherwise.
Afterward, she told Mason, gently, that this probably wasn’t the way to find a date. A group party full of couples and coworkers sends one message: he just wants to be friends. The single women there would walk away with that same conclusion, nothing more.
It is not a good strategy if the goal is romance. A woman who might actually be interested gets no clear signal, and no real chance to connect with him one on one.
Listening to my daughter tell it, I kept thinking Mason is exactly the kind of person who should have no trouble finding someone. Stable, hardworking, kind, a fabulous cook, already a homeowner. Nonetheless, good intentions and a full guest list aren’t the same as a plan that works.
My daughter suggested he try speed dating instead, something with a built in signal that everyone there is looking for the same thing. However, she’s also worried about something else. Mason seems to take kindness at a party as a sign of romantic interest.
One woman was simply warm and pleasant to him, and now he’s planning to ask her out. My daughter isn’t sure that woman is interested at all, and she worries Mason may end up hurt, or worse, that he’ll lose a friendship over a misread signal.
He has so much going for him. What he needs isn’t more parties or more patience with the apps. He needs a strategy that actually puts him in front of people who are looking for the same thing he is.
Was my daughter right that a group dinner party sends the wrong signal to someone you’re interested in? If you were coaching Mason, what would you tell him to do instead to actually get a date?
B.R. Shenoy is a lifestyle writer and the owner/editor of The Family Desk on Medium. She also publishes Musings and Reflections, a newsletter on Substack, and is the coauthor of The Invisible Lines of Poverty.
—
This post was previously published on medium.com.
Love relationships? We promise to have a good one with your inbox.
Subcribe to get 3x weekly dating and relationship advice.
Did you know? We have 8 publications on Medium. Join us there!
***
–
Photo credit: Michaja Sudar On Unsplash