
There is a reason people ask this question with so much urgency.
Usually, they are not sitting around trying to settle a theoretical argument about personality disorders. They are trying to work out whether the man they married can actually change.
Maybe he has been in therapy before. Maybe he apologized after a separation. Maybe he cried and said he finally understood what he had done. Maybe, for a while, things really were better.
Then the old behavior returned.
That is where the question becomes difficult. Not because change is impossible, but because remorse and change can look remarkably similar for a little while.
A person can be genuinely upset about the possibility of losing his marriage and still be unwilling to examine the part of himself that keeps destroying it.
That distinction gets lost when every difficult husband is described as a narcissist and every difficult marriage is treated as hopeless.
The diagnosis may matter in some circumstances. It is not the most useful place to begin when you are trying to understand whether a relationship can recover.
Look at what he actually does.
If he is told that something he did was hurtful, where does the conversation go?
Does he stay with it for a while, even though it makes him uncomfortable? Or does the subject somehow become his wife’s behavior, her tone, her past mistakes, her attitude, her failure to appreciate everything he has done?
You can learn a lot from that.
A man who cannot remain with his own wrongdoing will have a hard time changing it. He can understand the words. He can agree with the therapist. He can repeat exactly what he is supposed to have learned.
But if every uncomfortable conversation still ends with him protecting himself, the basic problem has not moved very far.
This is one reason I would be cautious about spending too much time trying to reconstruct his childhood.
His history may explain things. Perhaps he grew up in a house where weakness was ridiculed. Perhaps approval was conditional. Perhaps he learned very early to associate being wrong with being worthless.
Those things can be important.
They are not the marriage, though.
His wife still has to live with what he does when he feels criticized. Knowing that his defensiveness came from shame does not make being shouted at easier. Finding the original wound does not automatically create a new way of behaving.
Sometimes people become fascinated by the explanation because the explanation is easier to work with than the behavior.
It is easier to discuss why he is like this than to ask whether he is willing to stop.
That is where therapy either becomes useful or becomes another place to hide.
The husband does not necessarily need to spend years talking about how wounded he was as a child before he can admit that he has been treating his wife badly.
At some point he has to look at the actual sequence.
She criticizes him.
He feels exposed.
He gets angry.
He attacks her.
Later he regrets it.
Next time, instead of following the same route, he has to catch something earlier in the process. Maybe he notices the shame before it becomes anger. Maybe he leaves the conversation without punishing her. Maybe he comes back later and can hear what she was trying to say.
That sounds simple on paper. It is not particularly simple in practice.
For someone who has spent years defending himself automatically, the first few moments of that process can be unpleasant. There may be a strong urge to explain, argue, justify, or make the other person responsible for the feeling.
Learning not to do that is part of the work.
This is where practical forms of therapy can be useful. Techniques for regulating intense emotion, examining distorted thinking, and handling conflict without escalating it can give somebody alternatives when the usual reaction starts taking over.
But a technique cannot do much for a person who is mainly interested in getting his wife to stop complaining.
He can learn therapeutic language very quickly.
“I hear you.”
“I understand that my behavior affected you.”
“I need to take responsibility.”
Those sentences may be completely sincere. They may also be memorized.
The difference shows up later, usually when nobody is impressed anymore.
It shows up during an argument about money.
When she gets attention he wanted.
When a plan changes at the last minute.
When somebody points out a mistake.
When she says no.
The ordinary stuff is where people reveal whether the work has reached their behavior.
This is also where the idea of forcing a “breakdown” needs to be handled carefully.
A wife should not provoke a crisis in the hope that her husband will finally change. That can be reckless, particularly in relationships where there is intimidation, coercion, or violence.
But there is something worth noticing about consequences.
A person can keep functioning in the same way for years when everyone around him keeps absorbing the cost.
His wife smooths things over. She apologizes first. She forgives quickly. She explains his behavior to the children. She tells herself that he is stressed. The marriage carries on.
Then one day she stops doing some of that.
She moves out.
Or she tells him plainly that she will not continue the marriage under the same conditions.
Or she agrees to consider reconciliation only if he begins serious treatment and stays with it.
That can be the first time the consequences become impossible to outsource.
It does not guarantee anything.
Some men change when the old arrangement collapses. Some become more desperate without becoming more responsible. Some promise everything and return to exactly the same behavior once the immediate danger passes.
That is why I would be suspicious of dramatic turning points.
A man can break down in a therapist’s office because he is terrified of losing his wife.
That tells you he is distressed.
It does not yet tell you that he can build a different marriage.
The more convincing evidence usually arrives much later.
He is still irritated, but he does not punish her for it.
He is embarrassed, but he does not need to humiliate somebody else to recover.
She disagrees with him and he lets the disagreement exist.
He gets something wrong and does not spend the next hour constructing a case for why he was actually right.
These things are easy to miss because they are not dramatic. In fact, once treatment is going well, the relationship may become less interesting. There is less repairing after explosions because there are fewer explosions to repair.
That is probably a better sign than another emotional conversation about how much he loves her.
There is also a limit to what a wife can reasonably be expected to do here.
She can be honest.
She can stop covering for him.
She can decide what behavior she will accept in her own life.
She can support treatment if she believes the relationship is safe enough for that.
What she cannot do is perform the treatment for him.
She cannot regulate his emotions on his behalf. She cannot supply enough admiration to make him secure. She cannot find the exact wording that finally removes his need to blame her.
And she should not have to live indefinitely on the strength of his potential.
That last part matters because hope can become a trap.
A woman may spend years saying, “He is different when he is calm.”
Or, “He knows he has a problem.”
Or, “He really does love me.”
All of those things may be true.
They may also have very little to do with whether he can sustain a healthier relationship.
Love and harm can exist in the same marriage. Someone can be attached to his wife and still repeatedly behave in ways that damage her. Feeling guilty afterward does not undo the pattern.
The useful thing to watch is what he does with that guilt.
Does it turn into responsibility?
Does responsibility turn into different behavior?
And does the different behavior survive the next time he feels threatened, ashamed, ignored, or challenged?
That is where the answer usually becomes clearer.
Not during the apology. Not during the crisis. Not when he is afraid she will leave.
Later, when life has become ordinary again, and something happens that would once have brought out the same old version of him.
That is the part worth watching.
—
This post was previously published on medium.com.
Love relationships? We promise to have a good one with your inbox.
Subcribe to get 3x weekly dating and relationship advice.
Did you know? We have 8 publications on Medium. Join us there!
***
–
Photo credit: Alba Rebecca on Unsplash