
–
A bad commute does more than spoil the beginning and end of the day. It can influence which jobs people apply for, whether they accept a promotion and, eventually, whether they decide to leave an employer altogether.
That makes sense. A higher salary can become considerably less attractive when earning it means losing hours each week to traffic, delays or an overcrowded train.
A new Resume.io survey of 3,017 workers found that 59% would accept a lower salary from another employer if the new job came with a significantly shorter commute.
But exactly how much is a commute-free working life worth?
Respondents were asked to imagine that they could avoid their journey to work altogether. After accounting for what they would already save on fuel, fares, tolls and other commuting expenses, they estimated how much additional annual salary they would be prepared to sacrifice.
For workers dealing with some of America’s most frustrating routes, the answer ran into thousands of dollars.
In Rhode Island, commuters said they would give up $6,116 a year to escape the Route 6/10 Interchange. Several major routes converge as traffic approaches Providence, leaving drivers to contend with busy merging lanes and closely spaced exits. Avoiding it was worth more to respondents than anywhere else included in the study.
Delaware commuters placed a similarly high price on avoiding I-95 through the Wilmington Viaduct. Even after allowing for the money they would save by staying off the road, respondents were willing to accept $5,261 less in annual pay. The route cuts directly through Wilmington, with frequent exits and merging traffic capable of turning a relatively short section of highway into a drawn-out journey.
Drivers using the I-10 and I-12 Split in Baton Rouge would sacrifice $4,882 a year to remove it from their working week. Traffic divides and changes lanes around the junction as drivers continue east through the city. For regular commuters, no longer having to negotiate that same bottleneck each morning was apparently worth almost $5,000.
In New York City, workers put the value of avoiding the Cross Bronx Expressway at $4,850 a year. The road carries local motorists, commercial vehicles and traffic crossing the city, creating delays that can make even short journeys consume a sizeable part of the day.
Meanwhile, Idaho commuters travelling along Chinden Boulevard between Boise and Caldwell said they would surrender $4,806 annually to avoid the drive. The road passes through a rapidly growing part of the Treasure Valley, where increasing development and weekday traffic have placed greater pressure on the route.
View Resume.io’s infographic showing the complete results.
Nearly Half Have Rejected a Job Because of the Commute
For many workers, the commute becomes a deal-breaker before the first day has even begun. Some 46% of respondents said they had previously turned down a job because the journey was too long or difficult.
It is a reminder that candidates are weighing up more than salary, benefits and career prospects. An attractive offer can quickly lose its shine once office location, transport links and mandatory attendance days are factored in.
The Hidden Cost of Getting to Work
The financial burden of commuting is easy enough to calculate. The personal cost is harder to put on a receipt.
Nearly a third of workers, 31%, said stress or anxiety was the area of their life most affected by the journey to work. For 25%, it was lost time with family, while 23% pointed to lack of sleep. Smaller numbers said their commute left them with less time to exercise (7%), weakened their social life (6%), reduced their job satisfaction (5%) or contributed to poorer eating habits (3%).
Those figures make the commute look less like an isolated part of the day and more like something that spills into everything around it. Time spent travelling has to come from somewhere, whether that means leaving home earlier, getting back later or having less energy for life once the working day is over.
In some cases, the impact went beyond everyday frustration: 44% of workers said commuting had negatively affected their physical or mental health.
A New Job Is More Appealing Than a New Neighborhood
Workers may be prepared to change employers—or even accept a smaller paycheck—to improve their commute, but they are far less willing to compromise on where they live.
While 59% said they would consider earning less in exchange for a shorter journey, only 36% would move to a less desirable neighborhood to achieve the same result.
For most, home appears to be the less negotiable part of the equation. If work is too difficult to reach, they would sooner reconsider the job than allow an office address to determine where they spend the rest of their lives.
Returning to the Office Requires More Than a Calendar Invite
Employers planning to increase office attendance may also need to give workers time to rearrange lives that have been built around remote or hybrid schedules.
Asked how much warning they should receive, 42% of respondents said one to two months. Another 26% thought less than a month would be sufficient, but almost a third expected considerably longer. Some 18% wanted between three and five months, 9% called for at least six months, and 5% believed a full year’s notice would be appropriate.
That may sound excessive until the practical consequences are considered. An extra day in the office can mean finding childcare, buying a season ticket, rearranging household schedules or reconsidering where it makes sense to live. What looks like a modest policy change from an employer’s perspective can require a much larger reorganization at home.
