
Scott Douglas Jacobsen and Sapira Cahana explore transcendence through biological needs, determinism, ritual, and relationships. Drawing on Robert Sapolsky, everyday practices, illness, aging, and death, they examine how people shape experience through meaning and interpretation. Cahana presents transcendence as relational, emphasizing dignity, ethical responsibility, and connection when individual capacities are diminished.
Sapira Cahana is a psychosocial expert and multifaith chaplain specializing in existential and relational therapy. Her work integrates philosophy, human rights, ritual studies, and Jewish studies. She supports clients navigating identity, caregiving, chronic illness, grief, and life transitions, emphasizing collaboration, dignity, meaning, and the relationships through which people understand themselves and others.
Scott Douglas Jacobsen: Welcome back to Existential Exchanges. I’m here with Sapira Cahana, a psychosocial expert, and I’m Scott Douglas Jacobsen, a journalist. I’m calling from Lviv today, and she’s calling from Bali. This will be text whenever people are reading it. Thank you for joining us.
We’re picking up our series, Existential Exchanges. We’ve talked about death, life, and so on. We had a series of things to discuss, and we’re going to continue those and finish them off. Today, we’ve chosen transcendence. Sapira, what does transcendence mean to you?
Sapira Cahana: Hi, everyone. Transcendence is about overcoming facticity, the facts of our very being, and using what we have as source material for change. The question is always: how do we move from what’s in front of us to understanding the larger scope, so that we can transform our sentimentality, our experience, what we know, our physiology, and our biology into a new experience?
It’s very easy to stay at the biological level. We have basic needs, and you could spend every single day attending to them. That’s very important. Our basic needs influence how we move through everyday life. But is that all?
Thinkers like Robert Sapolsky argue that biological and environmental causes determine our behaviour and that we have no free will. Even within that framework, how do we think about our own experience and existence?
How do we liberate ourselves? How do we overcome? How do we not feel bogged down by the preconditions of life?
Jacobsen: A big question orbiting that is: if you’re talking about our basic needs as human beings, what exactly is being transcended? Are those basic needs being transcended by some higher-order thing layered on top of them? Or is something being interpolated between them, so that hunger, sleep, or thirst aren’t being satisfied at that time because something else is more existentially primary?
Cahana: There are conditions in which we are traumatized or bound by the physiology of our being. In the moments immediately after acute trauma, our physiological responses can strongly direct us. It’s very difficult to overcome that in those moments.
But other times in life, there’s stability, and our security needs are met. We have day-to-day hunger; we eat three times a day, we drink water, we go to sleep. The needs are taken care of. Even so, we may need to control the outcome of our sleep or fixate on our experience of the world as mediated by our biology. In those times, there’s more of an opportunity to transcend.
Your question is: what are we transcending? It’s not just that existential needs are layered on top of biological needs. Human beings can attend to our physiology, biology, and neurobiology while also entering conversations about values and engaging with our relationship to the past and to time. That kind of thinking transcends everyday experience.
You can enter a whole world. You can build a whole world of values-driven, meaningful ideas that can transform your biological experience. Often, there’s a dichotomy between body denial and soul transcendence. That’s not what I’m talking about.
You don’t need body denial. It’s about attending to our needs as much as possible without making our biological needs the whole of experience. Experiences beyond security needs can help us transcend, think across time and space, and guide our vision of what life can be, what it ought to be, and how to follow our path.
Jacobsen: The interesting thing about being a determinist, with no free will in that world, is the question Sapolsky might ask when people say, “I have free will,” or, “I am free to transcend these biological and neurobiological basics.” He would probably retort, “What is the will free from?”
There’s another sense of transcendence there. What are we truly free from? I think any sense of transcendence has constraints.
Cahana: His paradigm is very helpful for getting acquainted with the biology, neurobiology, and neurochemistry of what’s going on. He often says who we are is a product of our circumstances. I agree that our circumstances shape us.
To me, transcendence and circumstance aren’t mutually exclusive. They’re inextricably linked. Sapolsky’s account brings together culture, environment, and biology. This even raises the question of what to focus on in our environment.
When you’re out in nature, you can look at the microscopic, at fungi, at a tree. Why are we looking at the tree, the ant, or the fungi when we’re outside in a jungle? Why are we attracted to the primate, or not attracted? That could have a biological explanation.
You could have a teleological explanation or a mechanistic explanation. Ultimately, the individual human being’s experience includes the possibility of changing their gaze to find what produces meaning and transcends their circumstances. Is it the birdsong that’s calling? Is it the ocean wave?
Whatever the input material, our gaze, our experience, and the meeting of our internal and external landscapes can transform the output, I look to Sapolsky for a lot of good scientific material. But when I talk about the capacity for transcendence, I’m asking: how are we looking? What are we seeing? How are we interpreting?
How do we transform raw material, refine it internally, and then put it back into the external world? What is the feedback loop?
Jacobsen: There are practices people engage in to reach transcendence. The input material is the action, the body. You get whirling dervishes within Sufi traditions and ceremonial practices in some Native American traditions. People have also used psychoactive substances in ritual settings and under controlled or semi-controlled circumstances to alter how their minds work.
What practices can one use to attain various states of transcendence, rather than simply changing one’s internal gaze?
Cahana: Wisdom cultures often ritualize methods of transcendence, as you suggested. Think about practice or praxis, not even in mystical traditions, but in everyday traditions.
Even simple hygiene traditions, like brushing your teeth every morning and every night, open and close your day. We have explanations for why we brush our teeth, why we have a relationship with our dentists, why we don’t want to age without teeth. Severe dental infections can be life-threatening. Whatever the explanation, we ritualize, even in a desacralized environment where the explanation is mechanistic and biological.
How do you transcend brushing your teeth? You find a relationship. You create a relationship to the experience of your teeth and what it means to have clean teeth, nice teeth, white teeth, and what that means for your social world.
We create all sorts of explanations for why it’s important. Preventing disease is one reason, but there’s also a social component. We can feel our social relationships improve when our oral hygiene improves. The appearance of our teeth can also be read as a sign of wealth. There are all sorts of things we’re trying to protect against.
That’s a very desacralized, mechanistic ritual that people engage in. In religious ritual, there’s a way to build social bonds within a community and a relationship with the divine. Whether you’re in the mood or not, whether it feels good or not, you may feel obligated to enter that relationship with the divine.
Many Abrahamic traditions use ritual to mediate between the social world and the world at large. But transcendence happens everywhere. We see it everywhere. Some traditions and rituals use primary source material and build secondary and tertiary layers on top of experience to interpret it, creating social structures, ideologies, and experiences.
Individuals don’t have to create their own structure for making meaning. There’s a larger ideological and interpretive structure, a hermeneutic structure for the world.
Transcendence is one gateway to existential emancipation. We can liberate ourselves from the shackles of moment-to-moment experience. We can think retrospectively, reflect on what’s transpired, and project our statistical or experiential expectations, our pattern recognition, into the future as we experience the present.
Some traditions say: wait, cut those two experiences out and try to experience the source material of the moment. It’s very difficult to allow moment-to-moment experience to be what it is.
We often have an interpretive gaze, a mediating gaze. Whether we use tools to interpolate our experience or draw on history, culture, experience, and ideology, we’re seeking a kind of transcendence.
In that sense, transcendence is happening. You can transcend a little, or you can transcend quite radically, where there’s a very large leap from the primary source material to the outcome.
Jacobsen: Let’s say someone’s in hospice care, or they’ve had a cardiac arrest and been resuscitated, and they have a disability afterward. Or their capacities have changed with age. What does transcendence mean in the context of reduced capacity, whether through aging, an accident, or an injury?
There are two senses here. Some people who are resuscitated after cardiac arrest report profound experiences. Others have reduced capacity in daily life because of aging or injury. There’s a paradoxical sense of transcendence in that they transcend their prior conception of the world by confronting the reality of new limitations.
Cahana: The fact of illness, aging, or death is further evidence of what all of us are doing. The fact that we age and circumstances change reminds us that no world offers ultimate independence. There’s no such thing as ultimate control.
We can try to achieve utter independence and be survivalists. That’s not my philosophical orientation. Even then, I believe there’s always a relationship and kinship between self and world.
As I’ve said before, I don’t think we can understand ourselves as isolated brains in vats. Even if that were possible, would we want it? We say that we want surprise and elements of experience. That’s not a logical argument. It’s a relational philosophical approach. That’s where I stand. That’s the camp I sit in.
What do we do with the experience of illness? We’re born, illness comes, death comes, change happens.
What do we do when change occurs, as it always does? We have the opportunity to transform our experience. Sometimes we have more capacity to transcend what we’ve been given, and sometimes it’s very difficult.
For example, if medical interventions are sustaining someone, their dependence on a ventilator isn’t a measure of willpower. You can’t make moral judgments about whether one person has enough will to transcend the breathing machine and another doesn’t.
Brain death is irreversible death. Mechanical support can maintain circulation and organ function after brain death, but it doesn’t restore consciousness or bring the person back to life. That is different from cardiac arrest, which can be reversed through resuscitation, and from being alive while dependent on life support.
There isn’t a moral argument about someone’s willpower to transcend those conditions. A person who has been resuscitated or is living with medical support remains in relationship with the people around them. After death, too, there is still a body being tended to, and the person’s relationships continue to matter to those who survive them.
Questions of dignity and ethics remain. They’re still influencing their social world. Even when transcendence doesn’t come from that person’s own speech, experience, or self-determination, people still relate to them and make decisions.
The transcendence is happening relationally. That’s a very significant experience that I’ve been privileged to encounter many times with different people and families.
Jacobsen: Thank you very much for the opportunity and your time, Sapira.
—
Scott Douglas Jacobsen is a Writer and Editor for The Good Men Project with more than 2,000 publications on the platform. He is the Founder and Publisher of In-Sight Publishing (ISBN: 978-1-0692343; 978-1-0673505) and Editor-in-Chief of In-Sight: Interviews (ISSN: 2369-6885). He writes for International Policy Digest (ISSN: 2332–9416), The Humanist (Print: ISSN, 0018-7399; Online: ISSN, 2163-3576), Basic Income Earth Network (UK Registered Charity 1177066), Humanist Perspectives (ISSN: 1719-6337), A Further Inquiry (SubStack), Vocal, Medium, The New Enlightenment Project, The Washington Outsider, rabble.ca, and other media. His bibliography index can be found via the Jacobsen Bank at In-Sight Publishing comprised of more than 10,000 articles, interviews, and republications, in more than 200 outlets. He has served in national and international leadership roles within humanist and media organizations, held several academic, media, and research institution fellowships, and currently serves on numerous international boards. He is a member in good standing in numerous media organizations, including the Canadian Association of Journalists, PEN Canada (CRA: 88916 2541 RR0001), and Reporters Without Borders (SIREN: 343 684 221/SIRET: 343 684 221 00041/EIN: 20-0708028), and others.
***
If you believe in the work we are doing here at The Good Men Project and want a deeper connection with our community, please join us as a Premium Member today.
Premium Members get to view The Good Men Project with NO ADS. Need more info? A complete list of benefits is here.
—
Photo by Aarón Blanco Tejedor on Unsplash

