
I read an Instagram post yesterday where a teacher said tantra is widely misunderstood. Yet, in the same breath, the caption described tantra as a part of yoga. It was a perfect example of the confusion we have in the West. When the wellness industry links tantra to yoga, it does more than blur terminology. It changes the connotation of yoga itself, creating a barrier for those seeking a grounded practice.
In my experience, these are distinct paths with different goals. Though they share Indian roots, they often serve very different purposes. Still, the modern industry takes what it does not fully understand and throws it all into one blender labeled ‘ancient wisdom’. Yoga, tantra, and ayurveda become a single smoothie, sold with the same flavor at the front desk.
That thought followed me onto my mat for weeks. I wonder why we are so desperate to group everything together. Is it just for marketing, or have we forgotten how to distinguish between a practice and a product?
The Rooftop In Mysore
For months I climbed three flights of stairs before sunrise to a rooftop shala in Mysore. There was no music and no incense. Just a teacher who corrected my alignment with two words and a hand on my hip. We held postures deep into the burn. The same sequence, day after day, until my nervous system stopped negotiating with it.
By seven in the morning, it was already over 25 degrees. Sweat pooled on the mat before I’d finished the first sun salutation. Nobody mentioned the heart chakra. The asana was the conversation.
I came back to Europe and walked into a studio in beige and grey, soft lighting, a playlist clearly chosen by someone with excellent taste. The teacher used the word “feel” eleven times in one class. I counted. Carried by the earth. Held by your breath. Lovely words. I just couldn’t find the yoga in it.
Where The Talking Drowns The Breath
This week I went to three Pilates classes. What caught my attention most wasn’t the movement. It was the breath. Pilates teaches a sideways rib expansion, almost the opposite of the deep belly breath I learned in India. Different tool, different job.
What troubled me more was the Yin class after it. Savasana lasted maybe two minutes, and the teacher talked through most of it. This dead man’s posture is not just the end of the class. It is the most important posture of the entire practice and should never be taken lightly. Ten minutes in complete silence, accompanied only by the white noise of traffic outside the shala, serves a purpose. Two minutes of guided relaxation is not the same nervous system event as ten minutes of total integration. Talking through that window interrupts the very process it is trying to support.
One is decoration. The other is medicine.
I have written before about walking barefoot to ground my nervous system after months of overstimulation. The silence in savasana works on that same principle of somatic reset. The body needs a period of sensory quiet to actually integrate what it just did. Talk through that window and you take something away, even with the best of intentions.
Bali Made It Clear
Bali complicated the picture. Some Ashtanga classes were softened so much the sequence barely held its shape, while other Hatha flow classes had real depth. That contrast reminded me that the real issue is not geography, but what survives when a practice gets packaged.
Choosing By What I Need
I don’t think one tradition wins. The rooftop in Mysore gave me something the beige studio never could, and some weeks I need exactly what that beige studio offers instead. What I’m looking for isn’t a single correct version of yoga. It’s the right teacher for whatever state I’m actually in that day.
Wherever I land, the core remains the same with breath, repetition, and silence. It is the only way I can actually hear what is happening inside.
This essay reflects personal experiences and subjective observations regarding yoga practices. It is not intended as medical advice. Please consult with a healthcare professional before making significant changes to your physical practice or breathwork routines.
—
This post was previously published on medium.com.
Love relationships? We promise to have a good one with your inbox.
Subcribe to get 3x weekly dating and relationship advice.
Did you know? We have 8 publications on Medium. Join us there!
***
–
Photo credit: Alpesh Patwari On Unsplash
