
In a conversation in the comments section of someone else’s piece, Sabrina Jacklin introduced me to the term “grumpy/sunshine”, a common romantic narrative trope. When I looked it up at the site linked below, I found the following definition:
The grumpy sunshine trope pairs two romantic leads with opposite temperaments: one is gruff, guarded, and a bit of a pessimist (the grump), while the other is warm, open, and relentlessly upbeat (the sunshine). Over the course of the story, the sunshine character thaws the grump, the grump quietly becomes the sunshine’s fiercest protector, and the contrast between them sparks banter, tension, and a whole lot of melting.
It’s a flavour of “opposites attract”, but with a specific emotional engine: the joy isn’t just that they’re different — it’s watching a closed-off person slowly let the light in.
The page goes on to describe why the trope is popular, and one of the points stopped me in my tracks:
There’s nothing quite like a stern, scowling hero who’s gruff with the whole world but gentle with her. That “only for you” shift is the emotional payoff readers come back for.
This brought some uncomfortable feelings bubbling up to the surface. On the one hand, I get it. I get the emotional payoff on offer with this dynamic. But I can’t tell you how many stories I’ve read here on Medium about women who went looking for that payoff in real life, only to learn the hard way that a man who’s emotionally unavailable tends not to change just because she has chosen him.
Meanwhile, men like me who are actually emotionally available are over here thinking, “Hello? I exist! Can you not see me?” So while I appreciate the appeal of the grumpy/sunshine trope from a narrative perspective, when women try to apply it in real life, they end up unhappy, and “sunshine” men like me end up feeling invisible. And frustrated — because sunshine people (both men and women) deserve to be happy. (“Grumpy” people deserve to be happy too, but they first need to own whatever 𐊖h:t is keeping them from being emotionally available.)
If it sounds like I’m implying that women are the only ones prone to taking away the wrong message from an emotionally satisfying story, let me squelch that right now. Remember the love triangle between Leia, Han, and Luke in the original Star Wars trilogy? As much as I’m a fan of those films, the revelation that Luke and Leia were siblings felt like a big fv©king copout. It was as if George Lucas was saying, “Don’t feel bad that Leia chose Han over Luke. Had they not been related, Luke totally would’ve had a shot with her.” Whereas all the boys my age knew that Luke never had a shot with her. We’d clocked it three years earlier when we saw The Empire Strikes Back.
Granted, when we first meet them, Luke is still a boy, whereas Han is a man. So that’s a strike against Luke. I’ll concede that. But over the course of the trilogy, we see Luke grow into a man. What’s more, he’s selfless; once he’s forced out of his comfort zone (when he loses his aunt and uncle and the only life he’s ever known), he doesn’t need any coaxing to fight the good fight. Whereas Han — cynical, arrogant, and self-centered — absolutely needs to be coaxed.
And yet, Han is the one who “gets the girl”, so to speak. To me and other boys my age, that was information. The seeming takeaway was: “If you want love, be less like Luke and more like Han. If you’re too easy to love, girls won’t want you, because you don’t offer them enough of an emotional payoff.” And for a boy like me who saw more of himself in Luke than in Han, that message landed as: “Be less like yourself and more like someone you know you aren’t.” You can imagine how well that message served me.
We’re not throwing the baby out with the bathwater.
I want to be very clear here: I’m not anti-romance. Quite the opposite, in fact. I’m very much in touch with the deep yearning that romance stories speak to. I have been since I was a boy; the music of the 1980s (especially the first half of the decade) was a big help. Songs like Sweet Dreams by Air Supply:
I particularly gravitated to “yearny” songs by male vocalists, as I took them as ironclad proof that yearning wasn’t a luxury reserved only for girls and women. (How sad is it that the environment I grew up in made me feel I needed proof of that?)
I’ve also learned a lot from women here on Medium about the value they get from fantasy books written by other women. As Y.L. Wolfe writes (in the piece linked below):
Not only will you not find women being shamed for hopping into bed with her new lover as soon as the opportunity arises, but she’ll be celebrated for it, by both the lover and whoever else happens to find out about it.
And damn, these female characters speak almost jarringly plainly about their desire. They put it all out on the table. They rip their own clothes off, interrupt a kiss to place a man’s hand between her legs, and they’ll look him straight in the eyes while doing it. You won’t hear a fluttery, breathless narration like, “I wanted him so much,” but rather, “I needed his d:©k inside me as deeply as possible.” But, you know — slightly more poetic than that.
These women are voracious. They desperately want men. And the male lovers are all in.
The women writing these stories allow their male characters who are also living in patriarchy, just like us, to either exist outside it or dare to push back against it. And no, not to cater to female readers’ fantasies, but to validate men’s humanity.
What a beautiful gift, to create worlds in which men can pick a flower for a woman without being called a pu𐊖𐊖y by his friends, in which he can use the L word (love, in this case) without having his masculinity questioned, in which he can enjoy the connection, pleasure, and bonding of 𐊖εχ without having to compensate for that vulnerability by abusing or abandoning the woman he just slept with.
It’s a celebration of men and the joys of life, love, and lust that we long to share with them.
In the comments section on that very piece, one woman has written:
I learned about the type of love I most wanted in my life and I have been lucky enough to find him. We have been together for over 40 years. Romance novels played a large part.
I don’t wish to take anything away from her or any other woman who finds value in stories like this.
The bathwater I seek to throw out is learning the wrong lessons from the stories that move us. Failing to recognize that a trope that’s narratively satisfying might be a disaster if we try to replicate in the real world. At the same time, I want to encourage everyone to think more outside the box as to how the stories that resonate with us can indeed help us in the real world.
Let me share with you how I’ve done just that with Star Wars — the very fantasy universe I criticized earlier. First of all, the concept of the Force has helped me immensely in cultivating a healthy relationship with my own libido.
I grew up in the days when the messaging around consent was “No means no”. It’s a valid message, and I took it to heart. But I felt it didn’t go far enough. The messaging has evolved since then, but I still feel it doesn’t go far enough.
It’s as if boys are naturally strong with the Force, but we as a society don’t see any value in training them in the ways of the Jedi. We pay lip service to the importance of consent, but we don’t actually teach boys and men how to wield that awesome power of theirs in ways that not only won’t harm girls and women, but will actually be mutually rewarding. And then we wonder why so many men end up either detached from their power (afraid to even talk to a woman) or wielding it like a Sith (thus becoming the next generation of men who make the consent conversation necessary in the first place).
Just for starters, what if we taught everyone this:
A woman’s body is there for her pleasure (not anyone else’s).
Not only does this respect women’s bodily autonomy; it also respects her birthright as a 𐊖εχval being and opens the door to the idea that a man can be a welcome partner in helping her claim that birthright (like in the stories Y.L. Wolfe discusses in her piece I referenced earlier).
Larger societal considerations aside, learning to see my horniness as a great power to be harnessed and used benevolently and responsibly has done wonders for me. It was instrumental in me unlocking my natural “mojo” (or “rizz”, to use a more current term), without a hint of inauthentic performativity. As I’m fond of saying (maybe too fond, but it’s just so good!):
I’m not intimidated by women’s beauty or feminine allure, because no matter how gorgeous a woman is — no matter how stunning or breathtaking I find her — I know that if she were to get naked with me, I would make it a beautiful experience for her.
To be clear, that isn’t me deluding myself into thinking I can seduce any woman I set my sights on; it’s a reminder to myself that even if a woman has a goddess-like effect on me, she is in fact a fellow human soul, and I have every right to relate to her as such without worrying I might not be in her league.
As I’ve written recently, when a woman gets naked with me, I want it to be not because my efforts to seduce her have paid off, but because I’ve always made her feel safe and seen as a person, and the energy I give her resonates with her libido:
I don’t want her to see her body and 𐊖εχvality as prizes or treasures to be given away to a man who proves himself worthy. I want her to see her body and 𐊖εχvality as gifts that were given to her — for her enjoyment — and to recognize me as a man she can share those gifts with in a way that will absolutely make it worthwhile for her.
Another way that Star Wars has given me something I’ve been able to apply in real life has to do with one Jedi in particular: Obi-Wan Kenobi. (I refer specifically to Alec Guiness’s portrayal of the character in the 1977 film that started it all.) From his very first appearance onscreen, he projects warmth coming from a place of strength:
Swagger always felt wildly inauthentic to me, but I also didn’t like being the shy boy who’s awkward around girls because he isn’t sure he’s worthy of their attention. Warmth coming from a place of strength was the third option I so needed.
My inner strength has been built up through multiple experiences. One of them was finding my mojo, as I talked about earlier. Another was training in Aikido, which awakened a “sleeping dragon” inside me. A third was coming to accept with equanimity (and without bitterness or cynicism) the possibility that intense, erotic love wasn’t in the cards for me — a possibility I was forced to confront after a long string of failures to even land a first date. All of these have helped me cultivate a quality of groundedness that, together with my warmth, women feel and respond well to.
More recently, when I thought about how I’d respond to being called a “simp”, I turned to Obi-Wan once again for inspiration, and he didn’t disappoint. Recall the following exchange between him and his former apprentice:
Darth Vader: “Your powers are weak, old man!”
Obi-Wan: “You can’t win, Darth. If you strike me down, I shall become more powerful than you could possibly imagine!”
As I’ve written the piece linked below, the key here is that Obi-Wan is aware of a reality that Vader is not, and that gives him an unshakeable confidence. In my case, the exchange would go something like this:
Vader: “You’re a pu𐊖𐊖y-worshipping simp!”
Obi-Wan: “And that right there tells me all I need to know about what a miserable existence you’re leading.”
Men who would call me a simp harbor a deep, primal insecurity about femininity and how it affects them. Whereas I, who discovered long ago how to vanquish that insecurity in himself, enjoy a peace of mind that they have no idea is even possible.
As you may have noticed, Obi-Wan is not a romantic figure. He’s no one’s lover. Nor are the Jedi or the Force romantic concepts per se. And yet, without them, I might never have had a love life. Before applying them to my situation, I was the sort of man that women like as a friend but have no interest in dating. The inspirations I received from what Joseph Campbell rightly described as a modern-day mythology helped me to bring out aspects of myself that enabled me to relate to women in new ways. Ways that allowed them to see me in a different light — a light that was conducive to a love life better than I ever could’ve imagined.
So I’ll never advise you not to find practical inspiration in stories that move you. Just make sure that it is indeed practical inspiration that you are endeavoring to apply to your life.
With Love,
© Ben Rosenthal 2026
—
This post was previously published on medium.com.
Love relationships? We promise to have a good one with your inbox.
Subcribe to get 3x weekly dating and relationship advice.
Did you know? We have 8 publications on Medium. Join us there!
***
–
Photo credit: Connor Wilkins on Unsplash