
My fiancee and I went to central, rural Pennsylvania to try out a baker for our wedding. Of course, driving through rural Pennsylvania means you’re often bombarded with “Trump 2020” signs (in 2022) and the occasional “unvaccinated lives matter” signs.
Then, we went to lunch at a local sandwich shop, and I got us two submarine sandwiches and a drink.
The price was shockingly cheap — it was only $10 for two really satisfying, tasty subs and a drink for my fiancee.
Where I live in a major city (Baltimore), I could have easily paid $20 for the same thing. And that’s much better than the cost of living in cities like New York City or San Francisco.
I grew up most of my childhood near New York City, and I have a lot of friends who sold their souls to the corporate and business world that now live there. Of course, one of the first things I ask my friends amidst an unprecedented housing bubble is “how much do you pay for rent?”
For those that live in Manhattan, particularly super bourgeois areas, the price is shocking. One friend whose room is barely the size of my kitchen pays $2200, and that’s on the low end. Other friends with super small studio apartments on the Upper East Side of Manhattan pay easily over $3000.
If you know anything about New York City, you would know it’s a super liberal and progressive place. That isn’t to say everyone who lives there is super liberal and progressive, but the prevailing culture and how the city generally votes is.
According to James Barron at the New York Times, New York City is facing a crisis of the rent being too damn high, making it increasingly difficult for middle and lower-class people to find affordable apartments in the city. Long-time residents are being pushed out as wealthier people are moving into the area, and the housing supply is largely not keeping up with demand.
For a two-bedroom, two-bathroom house in Baltimore, my fiancee and I pay $1700 a month. On the Upper East Side or in East Village, that same house could easily cost $5000 or $6000. A lot of people wouldn’t want to live where we live because of Baltimore’s unfortunate reputation for crime, and because our house is not in what a lot of people would consider a “good neighborhood.”
That drives down demand, but regardless, besides package theft, we have had no issues with crime, and I think anyone who lives in a major city would benefit from developing street smarts and just watching your back.
That begged the bigger question of a trend in housing and rent prices: why are conservative areas so cheap and affordable? Why are liberal areas so expensive and unaffordable?
It’s supply and demand
Despite the shocking affordability of this one particular place in rural Pennsylvania, my fiancee and I acknowledged we probably wouldn’t want to live in Trump country as a Black woman and Asian man.
In 2014, Jed Kolko at Trulia made a graph of the political leanings of different cities and the median price per square foot. More liberal areas were significantly less affordable on average than conservative areas, with the notable exception of Orange County, California, which really isn’t that conservative, to begin with.
Liberal, coastal cities have higher incomes on average than conservative rural areas, and there are plenty of exceptions to these averages. However, expensive blue areas are also very densely populated, and as more highly educated people migrate to big liberal cities, demand goes up, and supply can’t keep up.
The desirability of living in San Francisco or New York City for many educated professionals inevitably will drive up prices and has the unfortunate impact of driving up prices. This leads to pricing and pushing out a lot of residents that already live in cities, particularly Black and Brown residents, a process notoriously known as gentrification.
Let me also preface that not every liberal place is super expensive and unaffordable, and not every conservative place is super cheap. Orange County, when lumped into the “conservative” category, is a notable exception, as are conservative cities on Florida’s beaches.
Part of the answer to why liberal cities are so much more expensive than conservative rural areas is because, from a demand perspective, a lot of people want to live in cities. Critics will say it’s not about politics, but cities versus rural areas. But I’ll counter because cities have become significantly more Democratic, and rural areas have become significantly more Republican, especially after the Trump presidency.
It’s also very hard to build affordable housing in wealthy, liberal areas
With demand rapidly increasing in big liberal cities and supply not meeting that demand — this begs the age-old question.
Why don’t city governments just build more affordable housing?
Any good liberal or progressive will tell you they want affordable housing so people aren’t priced out and places to house the homeless.
But when it happens in a lot of those good progressives’ backyards, the answer becomes a lot more complicated and politically unfeasible.
In 2021, Ezra Klein talked to a policy reporter at Vox, Jerusalem Demsas on how housing became so ridiculously unaffordable in blue cities. It’s often cities where Democrats hold the most power, including New York City, Washington D.C., Seattle, and lots of cities in California.
Demsas says culturally, upper middle class, super engaged voters have a lot of political power. And when upper-middle-class voters speak up about what they’re upset about, that prevents the interests of the majority of the population from being heard — this causes delays in building infrastructure. It also causes the infamous NIMBYism (“not in my backyard”) of upper-class people in liberal cities preventing high-density housing in their neighborhoods out of fear that high-density housing would bring down property values.
Simply put, many wealthier voters who are homeowners in big liberal cities often don’t vote against their self-interest.
“People who are willing to engage in these kinds of local politics are systematically older, systematically whiter, and systematically they’re more likely to be homeowners and have a preference towards stability rather than growth and change,” Demsas says.
She cites an example of Maryland’s Purple Line, a proposed light rail project that will link several Maryland suburbs of Washington D.C. but still hasn’t been completed. The reason it hasn’t been completed is that many wealthy homeowners in Chevy Chase, Maryland (a very liberal and Democratic area) repeatedly resisted the change, citing environmental damages to an endangered species (which litigation revealed did not exist).
Part of the problem is how homeownership works — a home is the asset we have for life, that we’re told is the main way we build wealth. And homeowners are simply incentivized to try to safeguard their property values in their backyard.
So there are no easy solutions and the lack of affordability in super liberal and progressive cities is a problem that’s not going away any time soon. The lack of supply part of the problem is especially not going away any time soon.
Is moving to rural Trump country the move?
If you can look past people’s politics a bit, you can have a lot fewer expenses and a much cheaper cost of living moving from a city to a rural place that might be Trump country. That’s a big ask for a lot of people, but financially, it makes a lot of sense.
Go somewhere where the cost of living is low if the rent or cost of living is too damn high where you live. People who live in Trump country and vote for Trump are still people, after all. The average teacher who lives on Manhattan’s Upper East Side probably makes more money than a teacher who lives in the middle of rural Pennsylvania, that income rarely makes up for the higher cost of living, especially since we’re living in a time of inflation.
But when we choose where to live, finances are not the only factor we consider. It’s hard to live in a place where a good majority don’t share your values, beliefs, and politics.
My friends and I often joke the best way Democrats can win back rural and conservative America is for liberals to move en masse to states like North Dakota. Of course, it’s a joke and meant to point fun at how utterly unappealing the Democratic platform is for your average White working-class voter in North Dakota. Plus, that kind of carpetbagging would likely engender as much backlash as it would votes for Democrats, to begin with.
As for me, moving to rural Pennsylvania is not the move right now. I love living in the city. I love the interconnectedness and the fact that there’s so much to do and so many people to meet. I hated the suburbs I grew up in.
But never say never — sometimes, living in a city is way too expensive.
—
This post was previously published on MEDIUM.COM.
***
You Might Also Like These From The Good Men Project
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
Join The Good Men Project as a Premium Member today.
All Premium Members get to view The Good Men Project with NO ADS.
A $50 annual membership gives you an all access pass. You can be a part of every call, group, class and community.
A $25 annual membership gives you access to one class, one Social Interest group and our online communities.
A $12 annual membership gives you access to our Friday calls with the publisher, our online community.
Register New Account
Need more info? A complete list of benefits is here.
—
Photo credit: iStock.com




