By Blair Bigham, Michael Herman, Atul Kapur, James Worrall
At this moment, thousands of Canadians are waiting in crowded hospitals for their turn to see an emergency physician. For some, the wait will be deadly.
Recent media reports of young people dying in Canada’s hospitals are, sadly, just the tip of the iceberg. As emergency physicians, we witness the Russian Roulette our politicians are playing even as we struggle to identify and treat life-threatening emergencies.
Our frustration and grief bubble at the surface as we try to keep a crumbling front line from collapsing altogether. Our job is already tough enough; among the thousands of emergencies we see, major and minor, only a few may be deadly in the ED.
It’s our job to identify who will die without immediate intervention, a job that sometimes feels like finding a needle in a haystack. Threats to life aren’t always obvious. Dying patients may look well when they arrive at triage yet get sicker as they wait for hours. The average Canadian ED may be too overwhelmed and understaffed to notice.
When a young person dies of a treatable disease, a devastated health team is left wondering, “What would have happened if we could have gotten to them quicker?”
The truth is, such deaths are not a failure of one hospital, one nurse or one doctor. They are failures of our health system. One recent analysis estimates that each year, as many as 15,000 Canadians die because of hospital crowding – a “hidden pandemic” of unnecessary death.
Even in a perfect health system, let alone a stressed one like Canada’s, skilled doctors and surgeons can’t save every life. This is a reality emergency doctors must live with. But to have governments under-resource us to the point of breaking is beyond untenable; it’s unconscionable.
All Canadians deserve better.
The solutions to overcrowding are as well-known as is the heartache that accompanies untimely deaths. Yet, we feel like broken records. For decades, media has reported on deadly tragedies coupled with provincial underfunding while conditions on the ground continue to worsen.
Canada has one of the fewest inpatient hospital beds per-capita.
Among Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development countries, Canada has one of the fewest inpatient hospital beds per-capita. Patients who need to be admitted to hospital wards may wait for days in the ED, so there is less space and fewer nurses available to care for arriving emergencies. Patients crowd chaotic waiting rooms, slowly trickling into the few free stretchers as wait times balloon.
Something else is hidden under the surface of underfunding. Emergency doctors, trained to detect subtle but deadly conditions, are being beaten down by the unending logjams. Duelling pressures challenge emergency medicine from both ends. A lack of access to primary care pushes even more patients through the doors, stressing already stretched resources. And as hospitals trim the fat to stay in the black, access to the tools we need to diagnose life-threatening conditions – urgent laboratory tests, imaging studies and cutting-edge in-patient care – is becoming harder to come by.
Increasingly, we feel a sense that we don’t stand a chance of catching every warning sign before disaster strikes. Imagine a surgeon without a scalpel or a microbiologist without a microscope. Emergency doctors are being stripped of the tools we need to do our job. Delivering excellent emergency care to every patient who needs it is becoming impossible to do.
If we were pilots, we’d refuse to fly a plane under such dangerous conditions. But unlike flights, emergency departments can’t be cancelled.
It doesn’t have to be this way.
The Canadian Association of Emergency Physicians (CAEP) has provided clear scientific recommendations for a fundamental redesign of the system. Emergency physicians have done the research, appealed to policymakers and provided solutions. A coordinated system, government leadership and investment in frontline workers is needed.
Politicians must demonstrate the resolve to fix this crisis. Until governments act on our scientific recommendations and commit to meaningful system change, Canadians will continue to wait in dangerous conditions – and more families will face tragic, preventable loss.
—
Previously Published on healthydebate.ca with Creative Commons License
***
–
The world is changing fast. We help you keep up.
We’ll send you 1 post, 3x per week.
Join The Good Men Project as a Premium Member today.
All Premium Members get to view The Good Men Project with NO ADS. Need more info? A complete list of benefits is here.
—
Photo credit: unsplash
