
There was one Sunday, maybe eight months in, that I still think about more than I’d like to. Emeka made breakfast, unprompted, the good kind, with the effort actually visible in it ,eggs done exactly the way I liked them, a coffee he’d remembered from a conversation weeks earlier. We talked for hours on the balcony about nothing in particular, the kind of conversation that isn’t going anywhere and doesn’t need to. He seemed, for one whole day, like the man I’d fallen for in the first place, undamaged, uncomplicated, entirely present in a way that made the previous three difficult weeks feel like they belonged to a different relationship entirely.
That single Sunday did more to keep me in that relationship for the following year than every bad week combined did to push me out of it. I didn’t understand, at the time, that this wasn’t inconsistency, or bad luck, or him simply having good days and bad days the way anyone does. It was the actual mechanism holding the whole thing together , and once I finally understood it, I understood why leaving had felt so much harder than the accumulated weight of the bad days alone could ever fully explain.
He didn’t need to be good most of the time. He just needed to be good often enough that I kept believing the good version was the real one.
I described that Sunday to Ngozi once, years later, expecting her to find it as strange and telling as I eventually did. She didn’t seem surprised at all.
“That’s the part people never understand from the outside,” she said. “They think you stayed because the bad days weren’t bad enough. You stayed because the good day was good enough to make you doubt your own read of everything else.”
Here are six of the mechanisms I’ve since identified underneath that one Sunday, and the year of hoping it produced.
1. Intermittent Reinforcement
The Randomness Was the Hook, Not the Warmth Itself
That Sunday wasn’t the norm, and it wasn’t scheduled , it arrived unpredictably, which turned out to matter more than how good it actually was. My somatic therapist explained why unpredictable reward is so much stickier than consistent reward, in a way that finally made the whole year make sense to me.
“A reward you can count on stops producing much anticipation after a while. A reward that arrives unpredictably keeps the anticipation running constantly, because you never quite know when the next good day is coming , so some part of you stays permanently on alert for it, scanning, hoping, unable to fully relax into either the good or the bad.”
This wasn’t him being naturally inconsistent.
It was unpredictability, functioning exactly the way it’s designed to in any system built to keep you checking.
2. The Almost-Understanding
Just Enough Insight to Keep You Chasing the Rest
He’d occasionally say something so precisely, unexpectedly perceptive about me that it felt like being fully known for the first time in my life , and then, days later, misread something obvious about my mood entirely, as though the person who’d understood me so completely had briefly left the building. That gap kept me chasing the fuller understanding I was sure was still in there, reachable, if I just explained myself a little more clearly next time.
This wasn’t a partner slowly getting to know me over time.
It was a taste of being understood, dispensed just often enough to keep me working, indefinitely, for the rest of it.
3. Future Faking as a Hook
The Life That Was Always Almost Starting
The apartment we were going to get together, discussed in enough specific detail — the neighborhood, the light in the mornings ,that it felt inevitable. The trip we kept almost booking, researched down to the flight times, never actually purchased. Specific enough to feel real, vague enough to never actually require a date, a future dangled just close enough to keep investing in a present that was, quietly, never going to deliver it on schedule or otherwise.
This wasn’t a plan that kept slipping through the cracks by accident.
It was a hook, baited carefully with a future, that never needed to actually arrive to keep doing its job on me.
4. Making You Compete for a Version of Him That Rarely Showed Up
The Best Version, Rationed on Purpose
The most attentive, warmest version of Emeka showed up rarely enough that I found myself, without ever consciously deciding to, trying harder to earn it , better moods on my end, fewer complaints, more patience, more flexibility, all quietly aimed at coaxing out a version of him that was never actually mine to summon on demand, no matter how well I performed my part of it.
The reframeThis isn’t you working hard for love. It’s a scarce resource, rationed deliberately, turning you into someone competing for access to a person who was never actually withholding it by accident.
5. The Relief After Conflict, Mistaken for Passion
Why Making Up Felt Like the Deepest Intimacy We Had
After a bad fight, the reconciliation that followed felt more intense, more emotionally close, than almost anything else in the relationship ,a flood of relief so strong it registered, in the moment, as love, maybe even as proof of how much we cared. It took me a long time to notice that the intensity was coming from the drop in tension, not from any actual depth between us. The relief of a fight ending isn’t the same feeling as genuine closeness, even though the two can feel almost identical from the inside of your own chest.
This wasn’t us growing closer through conflict.
It was a chemical crash of relief, doing a very convincing impression of intimacy, every single time.
6. Using Your Own Hope Against You
The Mechanism That Needed the Least Effort From Him
This is the one that took the longest to see, because it required almost nothing from him directly, once it was set in motion. Once that one good Sunday existed in my memory, permanent and vivid, my own hope did the rest of the work entirely on its own , filling every bad week that followed with the belief that the good version was still reachable, still real, still worth waiting for, long after he’d stopped needing to lift a finger to keep that belief alive.
This wasn’t him manipulating me constantly, actively, every day.
It was one good memory, doing years of ongoing work entirely on its own, long after he’d stopped needing to earn it a second time.
I still remember that Sunday clearly, the specific quality of light on the balcony, the exact way the coffee tasted, the sound of him laughing at something small. I’ve stopped waiting for a repeat of it from anyone who isn’t actually consistent enough, day to day, to deserve the hope in the first place. Ngozi still brings it up sometimes, gently, whenever I mention getting swept up too fast by someone new. “Remember the balcony,” she’ll say, and I know exactly what she means without either of us needing to explain it further.
He never had to work that hard to keep me.
One good day, spaced out carefully, and my own hope handled the rest of the year for him, free of charge.
—
This post was previously published on medium.com.
Love relationships? We promise to have a good one with your inbox.
Subcribe to get 3x weekly dating and relationship advice.
Did you know? We have 8 publications on Medium. Join us there!
***
–
Photo credit: Alex Tyson on Unsplash